Friends and Fans of Fantasy
A Lunch community for fantasy fans...

Troy: Director's Cut (film)

1 rating: 3.0
The Epic Fantasy film directed by Wolfgang Petersen
1 review about Troy: Director's Cut (film)

Extended Director's Cut Improves on the Original Theatrical Cut of "Troy"

  • Dec 14, 2011
Rating:
+3
When I saw TROY in the theaters, I wasn't expecting much (perhaps I should review it one day). After that first viewing, I knew there was something missing; the screenplay just didn't grab me, it failed to immerse me on the scenes. I am quite familiar with Greek myths, also both Norse and Roman mythology. Well, I managed to purchase the director's cut of Troy, and although it is not as outstanding as KINGDOM of HEAVEN Director's cut, it is a better cut of the film.

I presume that most of the folks who'll be interested in the director's cut are fans or at least the ones who saw it in theaters as I did. One Obvious improvement this version has over the previous dvd is the Picture transfer. The Video this time out is more vibrant, sharper and cleaner. Another difference is the soundtrack on certain scenes; the training scene of Achilles and his cousin, the duel between Hector and Achilles. Also, the music is improved with added bass during the siege at the beach and on the gates of Troy. The music sounded more powerful. But it fumbled the track in the Hector-Achilles duel, and it makes it a little underwhelming. It is a wonder how much a soundtrack can mean in a film's scene.





The Director's cut has the same plotlines, characters and scenes. It does have added "meat" and do they make Troy a better cut of the film? Yes.

1: Opening scene with a dog going around the spoils of war. (Dead bodies)
2: Nudity in the scene between Paris and Helen. Their relationship is also a bit more fleshed out. Love scenes are extended. Suffice it to say, the film is a bit more uninhibited when it comes to nudity and sex.
3: Helen's husband is shown as unfaithful. It gives more motivation to Helen's actions.
4: Odysseus is developed as the humble King of Ithaca. He likes to be among the common folk. His character is also more fleshed out; the film also emphasizes how it is Achilles trusts his judgment.
5: Hector knew about Paris' affair with Helen even before they boarded the ship back to Troy. He warns him of the potential consequences.
6: Achilles' ego is more fleshed out. He has a confrontation with Agamemnon regarding the Priestess of Apollo. (Extended)
7: Extended battle sequences. More blood is shown. Heads get lopped off more often.
8: Funeral sequences are extended. It shows more emotion and emphasizes the combatants' sorrow with the lost of their comrades.
9: A dog licks off the "fake" disease after the Trojans took the wooden horse inside their city.
10: Agamemnon's obsession and arrogance is more fleshed out.
11: Extended final act sequence; last assault on the city of Troy. More blood and gore is shown. A tad more brutally graphic that gives the film more gritty realism. 

                    

                    

                   

There may be more that I missed, it did contain an added 30+ minutes of footage. The film is contained in 2 discs (2 Dual layer DVDs) similar to the terrific extended cuts of the Lord of the Rings trilogy and Kingdom of Heaven Director's cut. The director's cut is a more rounded release and adds more emotional impact than what was in the theatrical cut.

VIDEO/AUDIO: 2.35 Anamorphic widescreen. Exceptional transfer, an improvement over the previous dvd release; Near-flawless picture quality, nice colors, improved sharpness and contrast. Black levels are solid. 5.1 Dolby Digital English is very powerful. I'd had hoped that this cut would include DTS sound mix, it would have been better with DTS.

In closing: Is the director's cut worth a "double dip"? For me, for $ 14.99 2-disc edition director's cut, definitely yes! As for the other more "stylish" Ultimate Edition (includes photo book etc.)with the $ 25.99-$ 34.99 price tag, I'm not so sure. For fans of the film, or if you don't have the original release, this is a no-brainer. The lack of DTS track is a minus, but this new edition definitely has a bit more "grandeur" than the theatrical release.

Updated: The Bluray is a lot cheaper than the dvd currently.
However, if you hated the original cut, this new director's cut may not change your mind, but it does make it a more competent and entertaining motion picture.

Recommended Timidly [3 ½ Out of 5 Stars]
This Review was originally posted in amazon.com on Sept. 24, 2007 and rewritten for Lunch.com
Caption

What did you think of this review?

Helpful
15
Thought-Provoking
15
Fun to Read
15
Well-Organized
15
Post a Comment
December 16, 2011
Agreed with you on most of this. The essential problem I had with the original release AND the extended cut is that, historically, they're both so w-i-l-d-l-y inaccurate. I've always been a huge fan of THE ILIAD and (even moreso) THE ODYSSEY that I've read a handful of other works detailing the Trojan War that TROY just makes me angry b/c it's so disrespectful to so much of what happened in the war.
December 16, 2011
I agree. I really don't know where the filmmakers' brains where when they made those revisions to the story. I guess in their attempts to try something different, they just caved it in upon themselves. Have you Ridley Scott's extended Cut of Kingdom of Heaven? That was just awesome and a totally different film from the theatrical release...more than an hour longer of depth, action and detail.
December 16, 2011
Yes, I have seen the extended cut of KINGDOM OF HEAVEN, and you're right ... it's a VASTLY better film with those extensions. Heck, it's almost a completely different theme ... just so much of an improvement over the theatrical cut which I thought felt incomplete. I guess you win some lose some when director's decide to go back into the editing suites.
 
December 14, 2011
Great write up man, I have this version as well.
December 14, 2011
this was an improvement over the original cut.
 
1
What's your opinion on Troy: Director's Cut (film)?
rate
1 rating: +3.0
You have exceeded the maximum length.
Photos
Troy: Director's Cut (film)
Troy: Director's Cut (film)
Details
Related Topics
Immortals

A movie directed by Tarsem Singh

Source: Troy: Director's Cut (film) on Lunch.com
© 2014 Lunch.com, LLC All Rights Reserved
Lunch.com - Relevant reviews by real people.
Friends and Fans of Fantasy is part of the Lunch.com Network - Get this on your site
()
This is you!
Ranked #
Last login
Member since
reviews
comments
ratings
questions
compliments
lists