So far, the best in the series. . .

During this time, I have been repeatedly asked, as a parent, as a clergyman, and as a student of fantasy literature, what my "opinion" of the series is. After having read all five books, and having seen both movies, I am now prepared to comment.

Some people, especially those in the conservative Christian camp, decry the books as inherently Satanic, dealing, as they do, with "witchcraft", etc. As a conservative Christian father and clergyman, I must admit that I do NOT agree with this assessment -- an assessment made, all to often, by persons who have not actually read the books in question. Do I understand "why" some would suggest this? Of course I do. The difference, however, lies in the nature of fantasy literature. As can be seen in other fantasy series, (Katherine Kurtz' "Saint Camber" stories come to mind) the characters in the "Harry Potter" stories are endowed at birth with certain gifts, powers, etc., not typically applicable to ordinary persons. Much like "The Force" in the "Star Wars" stories, this power can be used for good or for evil and is, in and of itself, neither. It is this point which firmly seperates "Harry Potter" from those who actually believe in and seek to practice the Dark Arts -- activities which conservative Christians -- rightly -- condemn as anti-Scriptural.

Thus, it is within this deliberate "suspension of belief" that these stories must be judged. Are they good fairy tales???

"Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban " is, in the opinion of this reviewer, the best of all five books so far. I'll grade it as follows:

Plot: B+ -- a serious perceived threat against Harry is maintained throughout the entire book. New characters are added, and old friends reunited. New professors and classes are introduced. The wider world of the magical community is explored. The climax is well handled and ends with a surprisingly human twist.

Character Development: B+ -- In the first story, Harry develops quite a relationship with Professor Dumbledore. In the second story, this relationship is poorly handled. In this third volume, the relationship is back to where it was in book one -- making sense! The (once again) new Defense against the Dark Arts professor is developed quite well.

Setting: B+ -- several cute additions: The Knight Bus and the village of Hogsmead give some additional venues for action and excitment -- and move the setting beyond merely Hogwarts.

Overall, an honest four stars.