Gourmand
Where gourmands come to meet/eat.

Gourmand » Lists » My Favorite Store Bought Cookies

My Favorite Store Bought Cookies

  • Feb 18, 2011
Can't beat scratch-made, freshly baked cookies. But sometimes you get a coupon or a hankering for that strangely delicious ingredient, convenience! Or your milk is just begging you for some Oreos.
2
Pepperidge Farm Milanos
Elegant, pleasantly crisp, with a nice chocolate decadence inside.
3
Double Stuffed Oreos
How 'bout covering these bad boys in fudge? Or combining two to make a quadruple stuffed Oreo? Awwwwww, yeah!
4
Fig Newtons
It's not just that I feel the need to be somewhat healthy and sneak some fruit into this list. These often found their way into my sack lunches as a kid. They're comfort food.
5
Vanilla Wafers
Almost the saltine cracker of the cookie world, you can say they're a bit plain, but their charm is in their simplicity. Strangely addicting, I can just keep popping those things into my mouth. I can eat about a million in one sitting.

What did you think of this list?

Helpful
29
Thought-Provoking
26
Fun to Read
30
Well-Organized
27
Post a Comment
March 20, 2012
What No Chips Ahoy soft cookies. Throw em in the Microwave for like 30 seconds. The closest you will get to heaven. Awesome list dude.
 
March 01, 2011
Really? No Nutter Butters? P'shaw!!!!
March 01, 2011
Sorry, not quite top five. Top ten, easily, though!
 
February 28, 2011
I haven't had any convenience since I started making cookies two years ago ;) But before then, the Milanos were my absolute favorite!
 
February 22, 2011
Mmmmm, tasty :D You're making me crave cookies right now! I love Oreos as well (I actually eat Trader Joe's Joe Joe cookies) and in terms of Pepperidge Farm cookies, Bordeauxs are my fave :)
 
February 22, 2011
I love Foureos. Strawberry Newtons are great. I have some old comics where they advertised Cherry Newtons in a white wrapper for a while.
 
February 21, 2011
I love Pepperidge Farm Milanos! And though I haven't had a Vanilla Wafer in years, those used to be a staple growing up. Fun list!
 
February 21, 2011
Those are all great picks, thanks for sharing. In high school I used to be able to polish off half a bag of Keebler Soft Batch chocolate chip cookies. Now I shudder at the thought, hah!
February 21, 2011
Oh, yeah, I forgot about that red bag! We had a bunch of those in our lunches, too. I thought they were a step up from Chips Ahoy, personally.
 
February 20, 2011
sweet list. Someone gave me a box of Girl Scout Cookies the other day, Samoas are the best! Check out these other lists: http://lunch.com/t/ybg and http://lunch.com/t/wm8. Thanks!
February 21, 2011
Gotta agree with the links, Thin Mints all the way!
 
February 19, 2011
Great list, Jay! I was so bummed when they discontinued number 1, I've had to learn how to make them which isn't as fun without that lovely ingredient, convenience ;p I like what you said about Nillas too, it's true- they are the saltine cracker of the cookie world!
February 20, 2011
Wait ... seriously? No more Fudge Covered Oreos? Nooooooooooo! Oh, well, we'll continue covering the double stuffed in Belgian chocolate.
February 20, 2011
We can't find them in our Safeways or Luckys and trust me, every one we go to I look! I do the Milk Chocolate Hersheys melted and dip the cookies in there but, Belgian Chocolate sounds MUCH better :)
 
1
About the list creator
Jay N. ()
Ranked #32
I'm a Southern California guy who loves food almost as much as I love my wife! Almost! I also love to travel. But I think the best way to experience a new place is to try the food. Not the stuff at … more
© 2014 Lunch.com, LLC All Rights Reserved
Lunch.com - Relevant reviews by real people.
Gourmand is part of the Lunch.com Network - Get this on your site
()
This is you!
Ranked #
Last login
Member since
reviews
comments
ratings
questions
compliments
lists