Dark Souls and Hollow Hearts
A Lunch Community for all that is Film Noir
Gone Baby Gone

A movie directed by Ben Affleck

< read all 11 reviews

Amy Ryan shines and there are some fine piece parts...but there also are a lot of "acting" moments.

  • Apr 16, 2011
Rating:
+3
Gone Baby Gone drops more F-bombs than dogs in a public park drop pooch poop. That's only part of the problem with this movie, which contains within a lot of wrapping a clever, complicated mystery. Scattered throughout the movie also are what seem to be endless "acting" moments for every featured actor, a style of self-aware directing that spills over onto some of the actors' performances, plus enough social sermonizing to keep even Sean Penn happy.
 
Some of my impatience with this movie is because the mystery depends on so much well-planned sleight of hand that it raised my expectations for a solid, complicated mystery drama. The structure and presentation of the drama is well managed by director and writer Ben Affleck. So is any number of individual scenes (when the acting doesn't get impassioned). And Amy Ryan as the cokehead mother simply walks away with the acting honors. She does this by making us believe she's what she's acting as, something a number of the other actors, in my opinion, don't quite pull off. Casey Affleck is just fine as the young private investigator who at first believes what he sees and then begins to figure things out.

Ed Harris, on the other hand, and made up to look for some reason like Patrick McGoohan on Columbo, chews the scenery as if he were breaking in a new set of false teeth. Morgan Freeman plays yet another variation on his wise, humanistic, aging gentleman. Freeman needs to find a role where he can kick an aged auntie to death or humiliate a young pair of lovers. Somewhere along the way he has misplaced his real ability to be vicious. Just watch him as Fast Black in Street Smart.
 
As the story develops there are more and more twists. At first, and putting aside the feeling of the movie being too sincere for its own good, this led to a lot of tricky fun. By the time we reached the conclusion and all became clear, all also became stretched out with a series of mini-dramas that seemed to have difficulty finding a way to stop.
 
Even Gone Baby Gone's basic argument -- isn't saving a child from almost certain degradation worth bending the rules, even if really bad scumbags pay a price -- is compromised by the naivety implicit in the question. Do we really want to live in a world where the police get to play God and make those decisions? Or maybe we should let the police play God only when it comes to little kids. Or only when it comes to little kids but no more often than once a month. Is there an answer to this apparently weighty question? The movie implies that there isn't. Come on. Sure there is.
 
There's quite a bit to enjoy in Gone Baby Gone, just not enough, in my opinion, to make a fully professional, satisfying story. But I'll give it this: The movie isn't mediocre and it isn't dull.
Amy Ryan shines and there are some fine piece parts...but there also are a lot of Amy Ryan shines and there are some fine piece parts...but there also are a lot of

What did you think of this review?

Helpful
3
Thought-Provoking
3
Fun to Read
3
Well-Organized
3
Post a Comment
April 16, 2011
I vaguely remember this movie now since it has been awhile since I saw it last. I agree with your review and found it quite a remainder of how I felt about the movie. I thought it was ambitious, but the script just wasn't as polished as it should've been. I did like the direction by Affleck and the acting was indeed good. I liked it, but admittedly it needed improvement. Wonderful review.
 
1
More Gone Baby Gone reviews
review by . August 11, 2010
The right thing
Based on a novel by Dennis LeHane. With Ben Affleck, Ed Harris, Amy Madigan, Morgan Freeman.      A little girl disappears from her run down Boston neighborhood, where Patrick Kenzie grew up and, now in his thirties, has never left. He and girlfriend Angie Gennaro live and work together, and life is good. When this pair of private investigators are asked to find the missing child, they reluctantly agree. But things don't go as hoped. And when Patrick finally uncovers the …
review by . November 07, 2009
posted in Movie Hype
A good neo-noir that will boggle you, while at the same time blow you away
This movie is what you call a can't miss movie it has all the makings of a great film and let me be say that it is a great crime film at that, probably one of the best since Street Kings and Narc. It's execution and style almost borders on Noir and it does so with oh so much style and grace. Ben Affleck proves that he's as good a director as he is an actor and screenplay writer. Ben Affleck surpasses his previous screenplay which he won the Oscar for( which was just as good here) and …
review by . June 19, 2009
DVD
The story opens in a run-down section of Boston, where a 4-year old girl has been kidnapped. The police Captain (Morgan Freeman) isn't having any luck with the investigation, so the child's aunt hires two private detectives (Casey Affleck and Michelle Monaghan) to help. Their work takes them into a cruel world where life is very cheap.     This movie really surprised me. First off, it was a tense and scary detective story, but then it became a story about Right and Wrong, …
review by . November 15, 2008
This movie pulls no punches in revealing the dark sides of its characters, and the result is a gritty, compelling crime drama, with a surprise around every corner.     Casey Affleck (brother of Ben a.k.a. the Director of the movie, a.k.a. half of Bennifer 2) plays Patrick Kenzie, a low budget private investigator who specializes in finding missing people. His partner is his live-in girlfriend Angie, and the two are hired by the aunt of a missing girl to supplement the efforts …
review by . December 05, 2008
Pros: great cast     Cons: ...     The Bottom Line:   "Could it be it's the end of our world?  All the things that we cherish and love  Nothing left but to face this all on my own"  ~Iron Maiden         Despite the subject matter, Gone Baby Gone was quite a good movie.  Ben Affleck made his directorial debut for a major picture and brought along his little brother Casey for …
review by . September 08, 2008
Ben Affleck's directorial debut, based on a novel by Dennis Lehane, who also wrote Mystic River was pretty good to me. Affleck's direction is more than adequate. I'm sure he's aping Clint Eastwood's film version of Mystic River much of the time, and there's one scene that's way too reminiscent of Se7en, but he shows a lot of skill. He's great at capturing his hometown of Boston and the people who live there.     The story revolves around the investigation of a missing girl. Morgan …
review by . April 14, 2008
posted in Movie Hype
Pros: The story and plot are really good, the acting good, the pacing is great      Cons: Nothing really stands out, but it lacks something intangible from being 5 stars      The Bottom Line: A solid interpretation of a complex plot. Without reservation, it is worth the time.      Plot Details: This opinion reveals minor details about the movie''s plot. Ben Affleck’s directorial debut Gone Baby Gone adapted from the Dennis …
review by . February 14, 2008
posted in Movie Hype
`Gone Baby Gone' is as unsettling as it is intriguing. Behind the headlines of child abduction, the movie is disturbingly real with events that develop naturally. As complicated as life itself, the film captures a mystery of tangled proportions.     Little four-year-old Amanda MacReady has been kidnapped from her Dorchester, MA home. We see private detective, Patrick Kenzie (Casey Affleck) watching the latest breaking stories of her abduction on television with his girlfriend …
review by . February 13, 2008
Ben Affleck has written (with Aaron Stockard) a superb screenplay adaptation of Dennis Lahane's novel GONE BABY GONE and has proceeded to direct this tough tale with an ensemble cast of both well-known actors and unknown actors and walk-ons from the streets of the Boston area where they grisly story takes place. The result is a film so well tuned and realistic with a perfect sense of pacing and character development that it becomes a remarkable calling card for Ben Affleck's career as a director. …
review by . January 08, 2008
This is a confident and assured directing-debut for Ben Affleck. He has proven to be a good screenwriter (he co-wrote this one, as well as the Oscar-winning script to GOOD WILL HUNTING), but has been prett spotty as an actor. Sometimes his choices were poor and sometimes his performances too. He is obviously very intelligent and capable...but that doesn't always come through in his performances.     With GONE BABY GONE, filmed in Affleck's beloved and familiar Boston...he has …
About the reviewer
C. O. DeRiemer ()
Since I retired in 1995 I have tried to hone skills in muttering to myself, writing and napping. At 75, I live in one of those places where one moves from independent living to hospice. I expect to begin … more
Consider the Source

Use Trust Points to see how much you can rely on this review.

You
Charley2
Your ratings:
rate more to improve this
About this movie

Wiki


For his initial offering as director, Ben Affleck returns to the site of his first Oscar: South Boston. (He and Matt Damon shared the award forGood Will Hunting.) Hot on the heels of his moving turn inHollywoodland, Affleck's Dennis Lehane adaptation marks one of the more seamless actor-to-filmmaker transitions in recent years. Ostensibly, a procedural about the search for a missing child, class and corruption emerge as his primary concerns. First off, there's low-rent private eye Patrick Kenzie (Casey Affleck, equally adept inThe Assassination of Jesse James by the Coward Robert Ford). Then there's the girl's drug mule mother, Helene (Amy Ryan,Before the Devil Knows You're Dead). She and Patrick grew up in Dorchester, but he took a different path, setting up an agency with his girlfriend, Angie (Michelle Monaghan). Helene's aunt, Bea (Amy Madigan), hires the duo to augment the investigation, and they team up with Captain Doyle (Morgan Freeman) and Detective Bressant (Madigan's husband, Ed Harris). The authorities don't appreciate the interference, but Patrick knows how to get the local populace talking, and he soon finds there's more to the story than anyone could possibly imagine. Hard-hitting, but never soft-headed, the evocative end result proves Affleck has a flair for this directing thing and that his little brother can carry a major motion picture with aplomb.Gone Baby Gonebelongs on the list of great Boston crime dramas, along ...
view wiki

Tags

Movies, Drama Movies, Action Movies, Dramas, Ben Affleck, Casey Affleck, Casey Affleck Movies, Ben Affleck Movies

Details

Director: Ben Affleck
Genre: Action, Adventure
Release Date: October 19, 2007
MPAA Rating: R
Screen Writer: Ben Affleck
DVD Release Date: February 12, 2008
Runtime: 1hr 55min
Studio: Miramax
Polls with this movie
8MM

The best Neo-Noirs

by

© 2014 Lunch.com, LLC All Rights Reserved
Lunch.com - Relevant reviews by real people.
Dark Souls and Hollow Hearts is part of the Lunch.com Network - Get this on your site
()
This is you!
Ranked #
Last login
Member since
reviews
comments
ratings
questions
compliments
lists