Love of Foreign Films
A Lunch Community
There Be Dragons

A movie directed by Roland Joffé

< read all 2 reviews

History as a Personal Crusade

  • May 19, 2011
Rating:
+3
Star Rating:


Roland Joffé’s There Be Dragons opens with the disclaimer that it was inspired by true events. Already, this is a bad sign. If horror movies have taught me anything, it’s that such claims should be taken as seriously as a piece of junk mail with the words, “Urgent! Open immediately!” written on it. This movie, like many well-intended historical epics, falls victim to the whims of its director; in deciding to dramatize history for the sake of telling “a story about people trying to find meaning about their lives,” Joffé has made a film that’s astonishingly simple-minded, as if he wrote it to satisfy his own needs rather than to appeal to an audience. I’m not saying that there’s anything inherently wrong with this. I am saying, rather sternly, that this material doesn’t lend itself to it. Here’s one movie that deserved to be far more compelling.
 
It begins in 1982, when a Spanish journalist named Robert (Dougray Scott) struggles to mend his relationship with his dying father, Manolo. Prior to his becoming ill, the two had a contentious relationship and had not spoken in years. As Robert learns the truth about his father’s life, the film shifts back to early twentieth century Spain, where a complicated friendship between Manolo and a fictionalized version of Josemaría Escrivá unfolds before and during the Spanish Civil War. The real Escrivá was a Roman Catholic priest and is best known as the founder of Opus Dei, an organization that preached the sanctification of an ordinary life. This is opposed to a life of strict regiment and servitude within the walls of a church, which was not open to everyone – least of all women and those who are married. In 2002, twenty-seven years after his death, he was canonized by Pope John Paul II, who considered him “among the great witnesses of Christianity.”

                                           
                                             
Joffé makes the dread mistake of glossing over Escrivá’s complexities, some of which remain controversial to this day. In the film, he’s a one-dimensional caricature – a man so selfless and pure that at times, he seems completely out of touch with reality. As a boy (Juan Cruz Rolla), he was of limited means, although he clearly had the love of his family and the calling to be a priest. As a young man (Charlie Cox), he sees political strife all around him and believes that the best way to protest is not to fight, but merely to love. This leads to the founding of Opus Dei, which is itself reduced to little more than an ideal. Admittedly, it’s an appealing one; peace, charity, and tolerance are always preferable to war, selfishness, and hate. But never once does Joffé address the controversial aspects of Opus Dei, including accusations of elitism, misogyny, extreme right-wing leanings, and secretiveness. Granted, all of these are unproven and generally regarded as myths propagated by opponents. Still, if there’s even a chance of them being true, they deserve to be explored.
 
And with this, I return to Manolo. As a boy (Felipe Agote), he was raised in a privileged but loveless household. As a young man (Wes Bently), he came to believe that money and power, and not the priesthood, were his higher calling. Someone like Josemaría, a man of the cloth, represents all that has gone wrong with the country. When civil war ravages the country, he enlists in the army, is recruited as a spy for the fascist government, and infiltrates the communist uprising, which descends in gun-toting, speechifying droves. He meets a Hungarian girl named Ildiko (Olga Kurylenko), and becomes obsessed with her, although no clear reason is given for this. Ildiko is really in love with Oriol (Rodrigo Santoro), an extreme left-wing activist who promises her that, if he should fall, he will wait for her on the other side.

                                           
                                             
Josemaría, meanwhile, is forced to go into hiding, as members of the clergy are being murdered left and right. He can only appear in public in street clothes and with a wedding ring on his finger. He holds makeshift confessions at a local zoo, where those seeking forgiveness are forced to stand or sit next to him and whisper into his ear. He’s then faced with the prospect of leaving the city, which he is against; abandoning the people, he believes, goes against the altruistic principles of Opus Dei. In the throes of his moral crisis, he will encounter a girl in a mental institution (Lily Cole). In her brief scene, she speaks cryptic dialogue, which is obviously meant to challenge Josemaría’s beliefs; she’s not a character, but a plot device.
 
At this point, I’m forced to ask myself two questions. First, whose story is really being told? By keeping Josemaría and Manolo apart throughout most of the film, Joffé has essentially made two separate movies, and at no point do they neatly converge. Second, why are both stories told in flashback from only Manolo’s point of view? Geographic and temporal logistics suggest that he could not have possibly witnessed much of Josemaría’s life. Joffé unsuccessfully attempts to alleviate this glaring technicality with the addition of a plot twist, one so melodramatic and implausible that it seems to have been transplanted from the pages of a Victorian gothic novel. From this, I can only conclude that There Be Dragons was not a depiction of history, but rather a personal crusade. In writing the movie, Joffé saw what he wanted to see, and no more.

                                              

What did you think of this review?

Helpful
6
Thought-Provoking
6
Fun to Read
6
Well-Organized
6
Post a Comment
May 19, 2011
well-written review. I cannot comment too much since I have yet to see it. But this film has my interest. Plus it has Olga Kurylenko....
May 20, 2011
You seem familiar with this actress. I have no idea who she is. Or perhaps I saw her in a previous film and never bothered to remember her.
May 20, 2011
Kurylenko was in Quantum of Solace, Hitman and Max Payne. However, she makes better movies in Europe. Hopefully, the package my movie contacts are sending me will have some of her new movies....(yes, you know I am sending you some).
May 20, 2011
Amazing. I've seen all those movies -- I've even written reviews for them -- and yet she never made an impression on me. I guess not everyone can be memorable, even if they happen to be good at what they do. These new movie you speak of: Exactly how new are they? I'm just curious.
May 20, 2011
Kurylenko is seen as a sex symbol here in the States but in Europe, she is more as one of those actresses. As for those movies, usually they are from 6-15; depends on how many advance copies they have (usually a month ahead, but this is a little rare) but more often a small number are official screeners so they can gauge the demand. They'll have instructions, but honestly I'll take whatever that comes in my hands that I haven't seen.
 
1
More There Be Dragons reviews
review by . May 19, 2011
I have always found foreign films to be something of an acquired taste.  There are stories that are so interesting that you cannot help but want to watch, there are images that are either so original or so stunning that you just have to watch play out, and then there are those that fit into a niche that you follow and watch out of fan-dom.  There Be Dragons is a story, that truthfully I know nothing about.  Granted it is not a "true story" and the fact that it is "Based …
About the reviewer
Chris Pandolfi ()
Growing up a shy kid in a quiet suburb of Los Angeles, Chris Pandolfi knows all about the imagination. Pretend games were always the most fun for him, especially on the school playground; he and his … more
Consider the Source

Use Trust Points to see how much you can rely on this review.

You
Chris_Pandolfi
Your ratings:
rate more to improve this
About this movie

Wiki

Details

Director: Roland Joffé
Genre: Biography, Drama
Release Date: 6 May 2011 (USA)
MPAA Rating: PG-13
Screen Writer: Roland Joffé
First to Review
© 2014 Lunch.com, LLC All Rights Reserved
Lunch.com - Relevant reviews by real people.
Love of Foreign Films is part of the Lunch.com Network - Get this on your site
()
This is you!
Ranked #
Last login
Member since
reviews
comments
ratings
questions
compliments
lists