This film asks more questions than it attempts to answer, if that’s the premise of the science fiction author, that is. It involves the world of human clones where their existence is purely to provide organ replacements to the “originals”.
Well, based on that, the author then attempt to explore the human side of the clones? Granted, they are as real as the humans and therefore ought to have emotions as they are. Then, the story hints that those who fall in love are allowed to defer their ultimate departure (after being fully “extracted” of their uses!).
Stop it right there… this is one messed up story! If you didn’t know they are clones, then the story is quite humanlike. And yet, what makes it a different movie is because they are not real and original. The audience may be left to argue about what is real and what is not. Then again, why the emphasis on falling in love (which I presumed the author is trying to emphasize that as the ultimate and treasured human emotions, I may be wrong!)? Of course, at the near end of the film, one gets to find out the motive of that assumption.
In films or in science fiction, one is allowed to experiment with clones and morality of cloning. This is possible and permissable. Not so when the real clones are in the world one fine day. That is messing with life big time! And perhaps this is what the author is trying to put the message out there.
Having said that, it’s taken reality out of proportion. To me, it’s extremely surreal and mind-boggling… why these clones never rebel (are they unable to, afraid to or simply accepting their fates)? Again, I got the feeling that they live in a world of their own. I don’t see “real” humans. What kind of a world do they live in? Where is the real world?
It’s not a film that fully makes sense but it’s one that if you let yourself believe, you would. Ultimately, it attempts to answer the question if the human clones have souls and from the look of it, they do! Then I think it’s too selfish of humans to put one’s own clones (ie. Your “other” self) through living hell and hopeless existence, even if ultimately to save oneself! No, I don’t like it a bit!
This is not a love story, not a science fiction nor is it a documentary. It is a mixed up toss of humanity (as in what defines human) and a resigned look at fate.
P.S. If clones exist, how do governments deal with the explosive population growth? Energy and food requirements? I don't think the world want another Gadaffi or Osama, do we?!
Looking at the film’s title, one wouldn’t be hard-pressed to think that it is a love story; and while it is in its own way, the film has proven to be a lot more than that. Based on the novella with the same name written by Kazuo Ishiguro; the Japanese never cease to amaze me when it comes to themes of remorse, existentialism, life and the way they take a grim premise within a heart-warming execution. This film was directed by Mark Romanek with screenplay by Alex Garland; and it debuted … more
28-year old Kathy H. (Carey Mulligan) reminisces about her life, starting in her unique boarding school, Hailsham. The children were raised strictly but well-cared for and raised to know they have a valuable purpose in life. A distressed new teacher tells the children what that purpose is, but it seems they already know and accept it utterly. A childhood love triangle between Kathy and her classmates Ruth and Tommy has a lasting effect on the three; years later as they fulfill their destinies, Kathy … more
Amazing actors wasting their time in a story that literally undoes itself not just once but twice. I watched it twice just to make sure I didn't have a stroke. Nope, I'm stroke free the movie just sucked despite the best intentions of an amazing cast.
NEVER LET ME GO Written by Alex Garland Directed by Mark Romanek Starring Carey Mulligan, Keira Knightley and Andrew Garfield Famed music video director, Mark Romanek, takes on Kazuo Ishiguro’s much loved and heavily praised novel, NEVER LET ME GO, as his second venture into feature filmmaking. It is a daring challenge indeed given the underlying questions about the value of human life but Romanek takes the challenge head on. … more
Never Let Me Go it's one of those adaptations that uses great technical execution in order to cover it's flaws in story's narration. The story revolves around this love and friendship triangle between Kathy (Carey Mulligan), Tommy (Andrew Garfield) and Ruth (Keira Knightley) formed while spending their childhood inside an english boarding school, that would keep the children away from their freedom in order to make them unaware of the true living outside the "fence". … more
If I were to pick an “it” girl and boy right now, by which I mean an actress and actor who are receiving media attention and celebrity more for their star potential than for their achievements on the screen thus far, I might pick Carey Mulligan and Andrew Garfield. Mulligan caused quite a stir (and rightly so) with her performance in last year’s “An Education;” Garfield drew a lot of attention playing Jesse Eisenberg’s best friend/enemy in “The Social … more
Not sure where to begin with Never Let Me Go. I liked certain aspects of it and yet also was frustrated with its slightly pretentious nature. The main issue I had was that the film tries to achieve some level of sophistication and artistry that it never really managaes to grasp and this is due to the fact that the filmmakers treat the material as if it were really original which it isn't. Right off the bat, we've all seen the youthful love triangle film, the British boarding school … more
Walking out of "Never Let Me Go," I felt as if I had experienced a death. This isn't to suggest that the film pushed me away. If anything, I was deeply drawn in, entirely taken by the sheer power it had on me emotionally. I'm fairly certain I wasn't the only one; I sensed solemnity in the audience I sat with, the profound feelings of shock, loss, grief, anger, and helplessness. The film projects all that, as if saying, "It's not fair. It shouldn't have to be this … more
Never Let Me Go is an upcoming dystopian drama film based on a novel of the same name written by Kazuo Ishiguro. It is directed by Mark Romanek and stars Keira Knightley, Carey Mulligan and Andrew Garfield. Alex Garland wrote the screenplay for the film. The film is produced by DNA Films and Film4. It will premiere at the 2010 Toronto International Film Festival, and will open the 54th London Film Festival. It will be distributed theatrically by Fox Searchlight Pictures in the United States on 15 September 2010. In the United Kingdom it will be distributed theatrically on 14 January 2011, by Twentieth Century Fox.