Music Matters
A Place for Music Fans!

Evelyn Evelyn

4 Ratings: 4.3
A duo comprised of Amanda Palmer and Jason Webley.

   Evelyn Evelyn is a unique musical experiment which combines multiple genres (pop, alternative, folk, cabaret, and narrative storytelling) to tell the fictional tale of conjoined twins both named Evelyn. In reality, these twin are in fact … see full wiki

Genre: Indie Music
1 review about Evelyn Evelyn

A Quick Tip by Count_Orlok_22

  • Jun 30, 2011
The self-titled debut from Evelyn Evelyn, the conjoined twins singing sensation!

Okay, yeah, so in reality they aren't twins... or conjoined... or sisters... or even named Evelyn. Makes no difference to me.  This is very probably the most quirky, creative, and clever concept album I've ever listened to. In many ways I felt like I was hearing the soundtrack to a strangely beautiful stage musical, except that there is no stage musical (yet). What you hear is what you get and it's sheer brilliance.
Evelyn Evelyn consists of two musicians and singers: Amanda Palmer and Jason Webley. People may be familiar with Palmer through her Boston-based cabaret-punk band The Dresden Dolls or through her solo work. Webley is an alternative folk singer from Seattle. Both performers have a taste for the theatrical, obviously, and a penchant for experimental musical efforts. Yet nothing that's come before could have prepared me for the originality or the audacity of Evelyn Evelyn.

Their debut album is a 12 track masterpiece featuring eleven original works and a melancholic folk cover of Joy Division's "Love Will Tear Us Apart". The songs shift in mood, tone, and genre with skill and intelligence from the patently absurd "Chicken Man" to the epically moody "Sandy Fishnets" to the strange country tune "You Only Want Me 'Cause You Want My Sister". The lyrics throughout are either mockingly melodramatic or irreverently humorous and full of the unexpected rhymes and double entendres which will have you laughing with maddening delight.

Thematically, the album is all over the place and the story it has to tell is simultaneously tragic, hilarious, and ingenious! It tells the story of an unlucky set of conjoined twins who go from being orphaned on the day of their birth (mother died in labor and father was accidentally killed by a chainsaw when the eccentric doctor decided to separate the twins... unsuccessfully). The twins go from being adopted by an eccentric chicken breeder who keeps them in a cage to being sold to a woman who takes fetish photography of children to then being sent to the circus before finally ending up as internet celebrities after they record a song and post it on MySpace. Along the way they meet a variety of lunatics and eccentrics of every sort and discover how hard it is to be born as freaks of nature. The continual squabbling between them provides for a great deal of humor, as does the whole story, though it does have moments of genuine drama and emotional sincerity.

And that's not all folks, there's even a graphic novel!
Caption Caption Caption Caption
Was this helpful?
Post a Comment
July 08, 2011
Cool music videos. Great QT!
July 08, 2011
It's a great CD. I'd love to see them perform live just because it'd be so weird.
July 08, 2011
Yeah, I bet that would be fun to watch.
July 07, 2011
Yes, indeed I must get this. I would probably buy any of Amanda's projects. The last album I had purchased of hers was Who Killed Amanda Palmer which is excellent. I will definitely check this out. Thanks for the great review!!!
July 07, 2011
This really is incredible. I want Tim Burton to turn it into a stop-motion animation musical.
July 08, 2011
That would be fun. You should find a way to get in touch with him and present that idea. Have you heard Amanda's duet with Voltaire? That's another good one that I almost forgot about. It's a few years old but still a goodie.
July 08, 2011
Check out the "Sandy Fishnets" video above. : )
September 22, 2011
The graphic novel comes out in just a few days! : )
September 22, 2011
And a graphic novel to boot. Wow. ;-) Very cool.
July 01, 2011
here's another review hiding behind the mask of a QT LOL!!
July 01, 2011
Yeah, I admit this one was kind of pushing the limits. LOL! You see my one Amazon?
July 02, 2011
Does it make much of a difference anyway? You and like three other people are the only one who read them anyhow.
July 02, 2011
same here...we have our own audience....LOL! plus, you do need to also read other folks' stuff more often. and I know you are busy.
July 08, 2011
Check out all the videos. : )
What's your opinion on Evelyn Evelyn?
4 Ratings: +4.3
You have exceeded the maximum length.
Related Topics
The Band

English pop-rock group that became known for their anthemic

The Band

An unusually creative rock group founded by eclectic artists

Source: Evelyn Evelyn on
© 2014, LLC All Rights Reserved - Relevant reviews by real people.
Music Matters is part of the Network - Get this on your site
This is you!
Ranked #
Last login
Member since