|
Movies Books Music Food Tv Shows Technology Politics Video Games Parenting Fashion Green Living more >

Lunch » Tags » Books » Reviews » Fool's Masquerade

Fool's Masquerade

1 rating: 3.0
A book by Joan Wolf

Escaping the constrictions of Regency society, Valentine Ardsley disguised herself as a groom on Lord Leyburn’s Yorkshire estate. But the arrogant (and irresistible) Diccon discovered her deception quite easily and felt he was honor-bound to offer … see full wiki

Author: Joan Wolf
Genre: Romance
Publisher: Signet
1 review about Fool's Masquerade

Gender Bending

  • Dec 9, 2010
Rating:
+3

It had been a while since I read a short historical romance, so I decided to look through the large stack of books my mother gave me. I picked one at random and was pleasantly surprised by the premise. Even if I had not read the summary on the back cover, I would have guessed parts of the book based on the Twelfth Night quotes that separated “Part I” from “Part II.”

There are two main characters, Valentine Ardsley, granddaughter of an earl, and Lord Richard Diccon Leyburn, an earl from Yorkshire. Valentine has recently lost her father in a military battle, and in an effort to remain independent, she disguises herself as a young stable boy. You can just imagine some of the mischievous adventures she has. The best part about her disguise is the ability to connect with the working class in the earl's household and the unexpected friendship between her and Diccon. Plus, who doesn't enjoy a cross-dressing heroine in a romance novel?

Although I like both Valentine and Diccon, I was disappointed by the lack of character development. The story is told through the first person perspective of Valentine, which limited my understanding of Diccon. “Part I” is too short, and Valentine doesn’t have enough antics while disguised as a boy. Additionally, the characters stay the same throughout the entire book because, as it turns out, they are perfectly suited for each other. The trials and tribulations that separate them are rather tame compared to most of the romances I read. Even though their character development is nonexistent, I still enjoyed the novel. There's something sweet about having such likable characters that remain the same.

Other supporting characters are rather superficial. There are various workers at Diccon's homestead, like Georgie and Mrs. Scone. Family relations include the earl's cousin, Ned, and Valentine's grandparents, who you meet in “Part II.” Finally, there are various suitors for Valentine's affections, many of who fall flat and are even less developed than Diccon. The only one I connected with was Lord Henry Sandcroft purely because he resembles Valentine's father. In the end, the story is about Valentine's and Diccon's relationship. Everyone else becomes part of the setting.

The setting was perfect for this type of a story. There are plenty of descriptions about the beauties of the countryside which contrast nicely with the stark city life. Valentine quickly learns that London is a place for change and fashion, emphasized with the Season, while the countryside is almost its own kingdom. Notable author Shakespeare is referenced a few times, mainly his misrepresentation of Richard III. Since England's Regency period is one of my favorites next to Medieval, I appreciated the setting. 

There are no special themes or motifs in the book other than your usual "love conquers all" sentiment. "To thine own self be true," no matter how unpopular that makes you, is another sentiment expressed in the novel. Other interesting subplots include the discussions about change, especially with workers and factories in the city. One character, radically-minded Martin Wakefield, Valentine’s cousin, discusses England's government. I am rusty on the history of the Whigs and the Tories, so I glossed over these details. I wasn't compelled to research them either, which is a sign that the book is lacking. These ideas might have been explored in more depth, but then Fool's Masquerade would be too serious. In the end, it is typical escapist literature: light, fluffy, and delicious to read. It's a "feel-good" book and was what I needed after losing the diamond from my engagement/wedding ring.

This is the only book I've read by author Joan Wolf, but I was suitably impressed that I won't hesitate to read another novel by her. There are only two flaws 1) The lack of depth to characters and issues 2) The first person perspective. Of the two, the perspective is the most harmful. In terms of a romance novel, it’s uncommon to read from this point of view. In terms of Fool's Masquerade, it limits and isolates the reader even making the writing technique appear clumsy. 

Despite this major flaw, the book was a refreshing break from more serious reads. I also appreciated the "teen" quality. There are no sex or explicit situations between the hero and heroine (extremely PG), which more mature readers might consider another fatal flaw to the first person point of view. I consider the characters' innocence, love, and affection for each other a refreshing change of pace. Plus, it's always sweet to have a genuine gentleman in a romance novel. 

This book is a perfect read for those who enjoy historical romances and want a quick read. It's also suitable for a younger audience, like middle school or teenage readers.

Caption Caption

What did you think of this review?

Helpful
18
Thought-Provoking
18
Fun to Read
18
Well-Organized
18
Post a Comment
December 11, 2010
Good review. The novel sounds kind of interesting. I don't think I'll read this one, but I like how this novel seems to address issues of gender in the sense of Valentine pretending to be a man. The historical element concerning the Whigs and Tories also sounds pretty interesting as well.
December 20, 2010
Yeah, I vaguely recall the Whigs and the Tories from my British history classes as an undergraduate. I love that historical fiction/romances fashions history around its story in such a fashion. Thanks for reading my review, Pard!
 
December 10, 2010
No sex or explicit situations? count me out! LOL! (kidding) This sounds interesting and your words "historical romance" has me intrigued. I'll keep this in mind. You have any recs on romantic epics with somewhat bleaker themes? I dunno, I feel the mood for something darker, tragic and different when it comes to romance.
December 20, 2010
LOL! Nope. Very tame as far as romances go.

I don't usually read pieces with bleaker themes. I tend to read romances for the escape feature.

Some timeless "bleak" romances include "Jane Eyre," anything by the Bronte sisters usually fits here and some of Shakespeare's tragedies, my favorite being "Romeo and Juliet." I also heard that Diana Gabaldon are rather bleak and throw you all over the place.

Hope these suggestions pique your interest. :)
December 20, 2010
I'll take a look. A friend gave me a copy of A FEAST FOR CROWS by George R.R. Martin. I am looking for some thing really tragic; I saw an anime that portrayed a man who had to kill the woman he loved because she was a threat to the world. You know me, I love dak brilliant themes!
December 20, 2010
Yeah, I know what you mean. I've never heard of "A Feast for Crows." Let me know what you think when/if you read it. :)
 
December 09, 2010
I agree with Aerin's comment below. I'm not particularly fond of romance novels, but your analysis here is great.
December 20, 2010
Aw, thanks for stopping by and reading this, Sean. :)
December 20, 2010
Sure. : )
December 20, 2010
(gives you a hug). Once I catch up on messages on Lunch, I will draft a new review or list. :)
December 20, 2010
What's the subject matter?
December 20, 2010
Haven't decided.
 
1
What's your opinion on Fool's Masquerade?
rate
1 rating: +3.0
You have exceeded the maximum length.
Photos
Fool's Masquerade
Related Topics
Tongue in Chic

A Christina Dodd romance novel published in 2007.

The Passion of Mary-Margaret

A book by Lisa Samson

The Constant Princess

A book by Philippa Gregory

A Caress of Twilight

Book 2 of the Meredith Gentry series written by Laurell K. H

First to Review

"Gender Bending"
© 2014 Lunch.com, LLC All Rights Reserved
Lunch.com - Relevant reviews by real people.
()
This is you!
Ranked #
Last login
Member since
reviews
comments
ratings
questions
compliments
lists