|
Movies Books Music Food Tv Shows Technology Politics Video Games Parenting Fashion Green Living more >

Lunch » Tags » Books » Reviews » The God Upgrade: Finding Your 21st-Century Spirituality in Judaism's 5,000-Year-Old Tradition

The God Upgrade: Finding Your 21st-Century Spirituality in Judaism's 5,000-Year-Old Tradition

1 rating: 5.0
A book by Rabbi Jamie Korngold

Produces a fresh view of God.... [A] powerful message [that] can resonate with people of all faiths as they struggle to reconcile science and religion. Publishers Weekly         Funny, honest and passionate ... a provocative, … see full wiki

Tags: Books
Author: Rabbi Jamie Korngold
Genre: Religion & Spirituality
Publisher: Jewish Lights Pub
1 review about The God Upgrade: Finding Your 21st-Century...

Does God exist? Good thoughts on the subject.

  • May 5, 2011
Rating:
+5
Rabbi Korngold may be a pantheist. She writes that she believes what she understands Spinoza did that God is found in nature. She runs religious adventure outings and takes people to camps and woods to experience God. She admits that she receives hate mail from fellow Jews who strongly dislike her approach to Judaism. But she feels that she is right and, more importantly, she feels that everyone should find their own way to understand God.

She quotes Albert Einstein frequently because she agrees with him. He said: "I believe in Spinoza's God who reveals Himself in the orderly harmony of what exists, not in a God who concerns Himself with fates and actions of human beings."

She notes a recent Harris poll that "only 9 percent of American Jews claimed to believe in a God who makes things happen in the world" even though the opposite is taught in Jewish schools and sermonized by pulpit rabbis. She quotes Albert Einstein: "It is a miracle that curiosity survives formal education."

Korngold feels that while the Hebrew Bible made an undoubted significant contribution to civilization, moving ancient people to a higher level of humanity and inspiring further development, it "fits into our modern (computer) world about as well as a manual typewriter from the 1960s does." She doesn't "advocate throwing out meaningful history and tradition. Rather, let us build on the thousands of years of wisdom we have inherited." She emphasizes that we need to recognize "that when we talk about God in the prayer book that it's a metaphor," not meant to be taken literally. A person doesn't need to "buy into the idea that God split the Red Sea or spoke to Moses on Mt. Sinai" to be a good Jew.

She rejects the idea of a personal God who is involved in human affairs, who listens and responds to prayers, who tests people, rewards them for good deeds and punishes them for bad ones. She cites a poll that found that "Twenty-one percent of Americans (but few Jews) still cling to this belief" that in "the afterlife, I will be rewarded for my misery here." "If people are good because they fear punishment, and hope for reward," Albert Einstein wrote, "then we are a sorry lot indeed."

Prayer is a period of reflection, of judging oneself, of making an assessment. The Hebrew word for praying l'hitpaleil, means "to judge oneself." Prayer reminds us of our history, family, our potential, and to care for others. People have a responsibility to think and act, take control of their lives, and not sit back and rely on divine help. Galileo wrote: "I do not feel obliged to believe that God who has endowed us with sense, reason, and intellect has intended us to forgo their use." She writes: "I do not pray to God when I pray…. I experience God through my prayers."

She offers the views of some famous Jewish thinkers. Maimonides (1138-1204) taught that we cannot know God but that we can learn about God by studying the universe. Thus people should study science. He and many others were convinced that the Torah as everything else must make sense. "Thus, when he encountered an irrational teaching in the Torah, he felt compelled to reinterpret it so that it made rational sense." A serpent did not entice Eve in the garden, and Jonah was not swallowed by a whale. These are parables. The donkey did not speak to Balaam, or Jacob wrestle with an angel. These were dreams.

She does not believe that "the Torah was revealed by God to Moses on Sinai." She writes that "some students of his (Maimonides) works believe that this was only his belief as written for the public. In private, they argue Maimonides doubted the possibility of revelation at Sinai because it didn't make rational sense." She could have added that this view is consistent with Maimonides' contention that prophecy is not a revelation or a communication from God; it is the human ideas of a very intelligent person.

She understood Spinoza (1632-1677), as we mentioned earlier, as believing that God is found in nature. But just as Spinoza is unclear, so is she. Does this rabbi mean that there is actually no God, but if we want to think of God, it is nature? Or are she and Spinoza saying what Maimonides said before them. We cannot know God, but the best way to understand Him is through His creations. Scholars debate what Spinoza meant. It seems that she understands Spinoza in the first way: "he thought God was nature and nature was God, all one and the same."

She mentions the views of some modern thinkers. Rabbi Harold Kushner, for example, believes that God has nothing to do with the bad things that happen to good people. Although she does not say so, Kushner took his idea from Maimonides who said the same thing and elaborated: what people consider bad comes from what they do to themselves, such as overeating; what others do to them, as when someone hits another person; or is a natural event, such as a hurricane, which cleans the air but kills people. She understands Kushner to believe that while God is not involved in the hurtful event, "God helps us respond to and cope with the disaster." This seems like a contradiction to her Spinoza view that God is nature; if so, how could inanimate nature help? Maimonides does not think that God helps; people need to do help themselves.

In short, she seems to take a pantheistic view of God: "As Spinoza taught us, the whole Earth (the capital E is hers) truly is filled with God's glory, and holiness abounds." "We meet God in places and moments of awe." "For me," she writes, "the first step toward making traditional prayer meaningful was to move the service into the wilderness." Readers can decide it they want to accept her ideas in total or in part or not at all. They are thought-provoking.
Does God exist? Good thoughts on the subject. Does God exist? Good thoughts on the subject. Does God exist? Good thoughts on the subject. Does God exist? Good thoughts on the subject.

What did you think of this review?

Helpful
3
Thought-Provoking
3
Fun to Read
3
Well-Organized
3
Post a Comment
May 05, 2011
The concept of the Divinity is explained beautifully by Dr. Benjamin Fain. Dr. Fain believes that the shear complexity of the universe begs for a belief in G-d or a Divinity or higher order. The complexity of the human genome also points toward a Creator of sorts. Atheists do not believe in G-d while agnostics would like to see more positive proof before believing in anything. The 10 Commandments provide us with a good set of rules for living. Some of these Commandments could be found in Civil and Administrative Laws like "Thou shalt not kill." or "Thou shalt not steal." or "Thou shalt not covet thy neighbor's wife or goods." or "Thou shalt not bear false witness." Even atheists could agree with some of the 10 Commandments and I've told them the same. Another point of confusion is the concept of free will. G-d gave humankind free will to establish accountability for sin. Without free will, there can be no sin. In addition, without free will G-d would be required to direct virtually every human act- a seemingly impossible task.
 
1
What's your opinion on The God Upgrade: Finding Your 21st-Centu...?
rate
1 rating: +5.0
You have exceeded the maximum length.
Photos
The God Upgrade: Finding Your 21st-Century
Related Topics
2E8DC9E3446638F3F58F481107DD4EC

A book by Silvana Franco

Twilight

The first book in the "Twilight Saga" by Stephenie Meyer.

Sisterhood of the Traveling Pants

Mini-series of young adult novels by Ann Brashares

book cover

A book by Dave Pelzer.

First to Review
© 2014 Lunch.com, LLC All Rights Reserved
Lunch.com - Relevant reviews by real people.
()
This is you!
Ranked #
Last login
Member since
reviews
comments
ratings
questions
compliments
lists