|
Movies Books Music Food Tv Shows Technology Politics Video Games Parenting Fashion Green Living more >

Lunch » Tags » Books » Reviews » There Is a God: How the World's Most Notorious Atheist Changed His Mind

There Is a God: How the World's Most Notorious Atheist Changed His Mind

1 rating: 1.0
A book by Antony Flew

British philosopher Flew has long been something of an evangelist for atheism, debating theologians and pastors in front of enormous crowds. In 2004, breathless news reports announced that the nonagenarian had changed his mind. This book tells why. Ironically, … see full wiki

Tags: Books
Author: Antony Flew
Publisher: HarperOne
1 review about There Is a God: How the World's Most Notorious...

Flew's argument is not perfect

  • Jul 16, 2009
Rating:
+1
Professor Antony Flew was one of the world's most outspoken atheists until he reached age 81 in 2004, when he admitted: "the world's most notorious atheist changed his mind." He tells the tale in his 2007 book There is a God, republished in 2008 as a paperback. The volume also has an essay by Roy Abraham Varghese on the same theme and one by Bishop N. T. Wright on the question of revelation.
Flew says that he accepts Aristotle's view of God who has the attributes of "immutability, immateriality, omnipotence, omniscience, oneness or indivisibility, perfect goodness and necessary existence." He summarizes his thesis, "it is possible to learn of the existence and nature of this Aristotelian God by the exercise of unaided human reason," in other words, without the need for revelation. This is the very comforting view - a view accepted by many but not all people - that we can prove that God exists by simply looking at the universe that He created.
Flew supports this position in three ways. The first is the age-old and well-known "so-called argument from design," that Flew had rejected for eight decades of his life. The contention is that the design that people see in nature proves the existence of "a cosmic Designer."
Flew states that there is a clear and perfect design in nature that can only be explained by saying that there must have been a designer who designed it. It is like finding an enormous well-constructed castle in the desert. No one would reasonably contend that the castle appeared by chance. It must have been designed and built by someone.
Flew's second proof is that the universe is "finely tuned" for humans. It is like coming across a palace in the desert and, upon entering, noticing steaks and expensive wines on a well-decorated table together with an assortment of fruits and vegetable, polished silverware, dining room chairs with well-groomed servants standing behind each chair ready to serve, air conditioned rooms with a large assortment of books - novels, history, biography - bedrooms with turned down sheets, a welcoming sign, and a host of other amenities and facilities. It should be evident, Flew contends, that the palace furnishings were prepared to accommodate people. So, too, the natural laws show that a "Master Designer" must have arranged these laws for humanity.
Flew's third contention is that humans have two characteristics: they are living beings with "an inherent goal or end-centered organization that is nowhere present in the matter (that is, the flesh and bones) that preceded it." They also have the ability to reproduce, which does not exist in this matter. These abilities, he claims, are so amazing that one cannot say they appeared by chance, but: "The only satisfactory explanation for the origin of such `end-directed, self-replicating' life as we see on earth is an infinitely intelligent Mind."

What are Varghese's proofs?
Varghese is more expansive than Flew in his attempt to prove the existence of God. He says that "five phenomena are evident in our immediate experience that can only be explained in terms of the existence of God. These are, first, the rationality implicit in all experience of the physical world; second, life, the capacity to act autonomously; third, consciousness, the ability to be aware; fourth, conceptual thought, the power of articulating and understanding meaningful symbols such as are embedded in language; and fifth, the human self, the `center' of consciousness, thought, and action."

What are Flew and Varghese saying?
Although the two scholars present their proofs as three or five separate ideas, the proof is essentially one, the "argument from design," that the world is designed so that it is perfectly suited for humans and, therefore, must have been formed by a creator who had this suitability in mind and the ability to produce it. The proofs are credible, but not conclusive or entirely convincing.
The contention that the laws of nature are so perfect that they show that there must have been a "cosmic Designer," has at least two problems: (1) Science has demonstrated that people tend to see a pattern when no pattern exists. The ancients saw "clearly" that the sun revolves around the earth and that the earth is flat. People see figures and constellations in groups of stars. Thus, it is possible that there is no perfect design, but we see a pattern only because it is in our nature to see patterns. (2) We know that science is making new discoveries almost daily that establish, in essence, that what we perceive about nature is wrong. Quantum physics has disproved the physics we learnt as youngsters. Thus the "perfect pattern" that we imagine we are seeing today will most likely be shown to be false in the future.
The argument that the laws of nature are finely tuned for humans does not prove that natural laws did not result from chance. It is only an argument, nothing more. In fact, it can be argued that natural laws are not finely tuned for humans. They only allow the existence of certain kinds of humans and these humans are subject to all kinds of problems. Many people die from diseases and wars. Every six seconds a child perishes somewhere in the world because of hunger and related causes. As many as 25,000 adults and children starve to death each year, or a total of nine million a year.

What did you think of this review?

Helpful
0
Thought-Provoking
0
Fun to Read
0
Well-Organized
0
Post a Comment
What's your opinion on There Is a God: How the World's Most Not...?
rate
1 rating: +1.0
You have exceeded the maximum length.
Photos
There Is a God: How the World's Most Notorious
Related Topics
Gary Larson - The Complete Far Side: 1980-1994

A collection of Far Side comics

Photography

A book by Bruce Warren

Sisterhood of the Traveling Pants

Mini-series of young adult novels by Ann Brashares

First to Review
© 2014 Lunch.com, LLC All Rights Reserved
Lunch.com - Relevant reviews by real people.
()
This is you!
Ranked #
Last login
Member since
reviews
comments
ratings
questions
compliments
lists