I'm with Woopak. Brett Favre is definately overated. He only won 1 but the last few years he seems to generate so much interest. Definately not in Joe Montana's or John Elway's class.

Some would feel Eli Manning, but since he wasn't considered elite when he won the SB, he just doesn't qualify in my book and neither does Brad Johnson. I would go with Trent Dilfer, Phil Simms, and yes, Brett Favre despite all his accomplishments. For someone who won only one SB, he recieves a bit too much praise, and when he left Green Bay, it took them no time to become contenders and eventually champions. Which tells me they had some good pieces. But when you look at a truly great QB like Peyton Manning, losing him the Colts were tied for dead last.

Here's my list: http://www.lunch.com/BaronSamedi3-The_Most_O...n_Super_Bowls-3093.html

I'm with Woopak. Brett Favre is definately overated. He only won 1 but the last few years he seems to generate so much interest. Definately not in Joe Montana's or John Elway's class.