Movies Books Music Food Tv Shows Technology Politics Video Games Parenting Fashion Green Living more >

Lunch » Tags » Movies » Reviews » Proposition


1 rating: 3.0
A movie directed by John Hillcoat

Australian director John Hillcoat first teamed up with singer Nick Cave on 1988's disturbing GHOSTS...OF THE CIVIL DEAD, for which Cave co-authored the screenplay and took a memorably brief acting role. The two reconvene for 2006's THE PROPOSITION, with … see full wiki

Tags: Movies, Dramas
Cast: Tom Budge
Release Date: 2005
MPAA Rating: R
1 review about Proposition

Talk About Raw Human Evil Stuff

  • Jul 10, 2008
Pros: See review.

Cons: See review.

The Bottom Line: Bleak, gritty, violent, enormously powerful, wonderfully acted, and beautifully shot, The Proposition lays witness to the birth of yet another nation on the backs of the innocent and unsuspecting.

Plot Details: This opinion reveals minor details about the movie''s plot.

The Australian Outback. As I explained to my 13-year old daughter the other day, there are few places more inhospitable on the planet than the Australian Outback. And none too many movies made with it as the backdrop. Such is the case with The Proposition (2005) set in Austria in the 1880’s before Australia became its own country.

The Story

Directed by John Hillcoat The Proposition is a gritty, violent movie dominated by male actors, vile acts, and testosterone. The movie is grey, red, black and raw, and opens with a violent gun battle in the town of Banyon as the local British lawman, one Captain Morris Stanley (Ray Winestone – Beowulf, Cold Mountain) apprehends Charlie Burns (Guy Pearce – L.A. Confidential, Momento, The Time Machine) and his younger brother Mikey (Richard Wilson – 48 Shades), after the pair along with their brother Arthur (Danny Huston – 21 Grams, The Constant Gardener, Children of Men) and his gang, are accused of a vicious rape and murder.

But Arthur has fled to the hills, the Outback hills that is, but the town wants blood for blood, so Captain Morris makes an unconventional proposition: if Charlie can find and kill his older brother both he and Mikey can go free. Otherwise, Mikey, a meek and weak boy, will be hanged on Christmas Day.

Wanting to save his younger brother Charlie reluctantly sets off after Arthur with but a horse and rifle, not exactly sure what he’ll do when he finds him. Along the way Charlie runs into an unassuming bounty hunter, one Jellon Lamb (John Hurt – Rob Roy, Contact), who of course is looking for his brother, and some of the local and unwelcoming (dark-skinned) natives.

Meanwhile back at the little town in the desert, with word gets out that Mikey is in custody, and Captain Stanley starts to have problems with the town’s people, the men under his command who have little respect for him, his superior Eden Fletcher (David Wenham) is demanding heads and even Stanley's innocent alabaster wife Martha (Emily Watson – Red Dragon) demands justice in the form of more than an ounce of Mikey’s flesh.

My Thoughts

At times compelling, other time hard to watch, The Proposition unfolding as it does amidst the dusty arid plains and jagged rocky formation that make up the seventh continent’s formidable wilderness, is nonetheless a movie with a message. Ferreting out that message through the grit, wanton violence, and bloodletting might be a chore however.

There away from the coast that so defies Australia in the American mind, in the famed Outback a war is brewing that is to set the stage Australian history for decades to come. The White Europeans are at war against the indigenous black Aborigine, the English are at war against the Irish, and in the Proposition, brother is pitted against brother, and, most of all, decent humanity struggles against its own Darwinian bestiality. There is scare anything redeeming here, nothing beautiful and everything ugly.

Bleak, gritty, violent, enormously powerful, wonderfully acted, and beautifully shot, The Proposition lays witness to the birth of yet another nation on the backs of the innocent and unsuspecting. While I would not call this movie a masterpiece, it is a fitting return to the Western that American cinema no longer seems to be interested in making.


Viewing Format: DVD
Video Occasion: None of the Above
Suitability For Children: Not suitable for Children of any age

What did you think of this review?

Fun to Read
Post a Comment
What's your opinion on Proposition?
1 rating: +3.0
You have exceeded the maximum length.
Related Topics
Requiem for a Dream

Darren Aronofsky's controversial and critically acclaimed 20

Empire of the Sun

A movie

Good Will Hunting

Drama movie directed by Gus Van Sant


A 2001 drama film

First to Review
© 2015 Lunch.com, LLC All Rights Reserved
Lunch.com - Relevant reviews by real people.
This is you!
Ranked #
Last login
Member since