I have Mantle at first, since I did not see him play the outfield. It's hard to leave him off my team, as he was the greatest switch hitter of all time.
I have seen some great 2nd baseman like Morgan, and Sandberg, but Carew could do it all. He was a great clutch hitter, and it's hard to name a better bunter than him.
Great list. It would be great if you could add commentary for all the players. You list Walter Alston and I am not sure why since he was known for his managing and not as a player.