Its a close one between this and Berserk but I had to give #1 to Berserk cause Guts is a lot cooler and more crazier than Clare. But the supporting cast for Claymore is better than Berserk at the current moment. Maybe after a few more volumes of Claymore, I'll move this to the top.
See the full review, "The female version of BERSERK".
Although the characters and some of the episodes are pretty lame and stupid, I've always said that One Piece has one of the best overall storyline. Its a pirate boy who's dream is to become the most famous pirate in the world in the age of pirates. The whole anime is one grand adventure.
See the full review, "The story as a whole is what's great about this one.".
Although I personally do not like the main character, Naruto, I love the this anime because of its supporting cast like Shikamaru, Kakashi, and Sasuke. And the fights and battles are also really cool too.
See the full review, "Great storyline to go with likeable characters".
Although everyone complains about the long stretched out fights, I love it. Not because of the action, but because of the humor. I just get a kick out of it when they spend 2 episodes explaining how they got more powerful and then another episodes to power up and then 20 episodes to actually get through the fight. Sure its repetitive but its the little things in between that cracks me up all the time. Especially when Vegeta's involved.