Movies Books Music Food Tv Shows Technology Politics Video Games Parenting Fashion Green Living more >

Lunch » Tags » Music » Reviews » Surf's Up - The Beach Boys » User review

Album cover

The 1971 album by The Beach Boys

< read all 2 reviews

Just one look at the cover makes it obvious this isn't your average Beach Boys album.

  • Aug 21, 2009
  • by
Following on the heels of 1970's commercial failure, Sunflower, the Beach Boys returned with a new manager and a new sound. 1971's Surf’s Up may be the Beach Boy’s most creative album, completely abandoning the fun in the sun music that first brought them to prominence. Brian Wilson no longer took complete control of the band due to his declining mental state, which allowed the rest of the band to showcase their songwriting talents. Carl Wilson really stands out with his two tracks, “Long Promised Road” and “Feel Flows”. The latter shows off the Beach Boys’ edgier sound, even featuring somewhat of a guitar solo. Bruce Johnston also stands out with his only song on the album, “Disney Girls (1957)”.  The one weak spot on the album is “Student Demonstration Time”, essentially a reworking of an old Leiber/Stoller song. Mike Love’s attempt at a blues song doesn’t work very well, but the rest of the album is well above average. Despite Brian Wilson’s problems at the time, his three compositions take center stage. “A Day In The Life Of A Tree” has manager Jack Rieley singing lead vocals, accompanied by a pump organ. It’s certainly an odd song, but it slowly starts to grow on you, and Rieley’s off-kilter voice works well with it. Next up is “‘Til I Die”, a haunting piece that was initially rejected by the band for being too depressing. It proves to be one of Brian Wilson’s best efforts, along with the final track, “Surf’s Up”. Originally intended to be on the SMiLE album, the song revolves around a piano melody, ending with various voices singing “child is father of the man”. The songs may not be as catchy as the band’s earlier stuff, and it doesn’t reach the greatness of Pet Sounds, but Surf’s Up is certainly one of the Beach Boys’ best albums.
album cover

What did you think of this review?

Fun to Read
Post a Comment
July 10, 2010
One of my favorite albums of all-time. The Beach Boys at their creative peak. A masterpiece!
August 26, 2009
Nice review. One of my all-time favorite albums. One of the few vinyl albums I actually wore out!.  I always thought that this was the period (early 1970's) that the Beach Boys made their best music. 
More Surf's Up - The Beach Boys reviews
Quick Tip by . July 10, 2010
posted in Music Matters
One of my favorite albums of all time. The Beach Boys at their creative peak. A masterpiece!
About the reviewer
Anthony ()
Ranked #410
I'm a video game, movie, sports, and music nut. I also enjoy watching TV, reading, and playing golf.
Consider the Source

Use Trust Points to see how much you can rely on this review.

Your ratings:
rate more to improve this
About this album


Surf's Up is an album title for The Beach Boys based on a song with the same title written by Brian Wilson and Van Dyke Parks for the abandoned 1966–1967 Beach Boys Smile album. The song was reworked and used as the title track for the fourteenth studio album by The Beach Boys, released in 1971. Smile, including the original version of the song 'Surf's Up,' was finally completed and released by Brian Wilson and his band in 2004.

In the fall of 1970, after the commercial failure of the Sunflower album, The Beach Boys hired Jack Rieley as their manager. Rieley, a DJ, had impressed the band with his falsified credentials (a supposed Peabody Award-winning stint as NBC bureau chief in Puerto Rico) and ideas on how to regain respect from American music fans and critics. His first initiative was to have The Beach Boys record songs with more socially aware lyrics. Rieley also insisted that the band officially appoint Carl Wilson "musical director" in recognition of the integral role he had played keeping the group together since 1967. Most importantly, he demanded the completion of "Surf's Up" for release by composer and erstwhile bandleader Brian Wilson, a song that had taken on mythical proportions in the underground press since the demise of Smile three years earlier. He also organized a guest appearance at a Grateful Dead concert in April 1971, further enhancing the Beach Boys' once-lacking hip credentials.

According to Rieley in 1996 posts to the ...
view wiki


Music, Album, Beach Boys, Music Album, Beach Boys Album


© 2014 Lunch.com, LLC All Rights Reserved
Lunch.com - Relevant reviews by real people.
This is you!
Ranked #
Last login
Member since