|
Movies Books Music Food Tv Shows Technology Politics Video Games Parenting Fashion Green Living more >

Lunch » Tags » Books » Reviews » A Christmas Carol And Other Christmas Stories » User review

I have never not finished a book before.

  • Dec 29, 2009
Rating:
+1

I know that Charles Dickens is considered by many to be one of the greatest writers of the nineteenth century, but I found this book extremely difficult to get through. It consists of A Christmas Carol, as well as three shorter Christmas-themed stories: A Christmas Tree, A Christmas Dinner, and A Good-Humored Christmas. The book also contains a lengthy introduction by Frederick Busch, as well as a lengthy after-word by Gerald Charles Dickens, Charles Dickens’ great-great-grandson. I personally never saw the point in introductions and after-words, especially since they are, in this case, about as long as the short stories themselves.

A Christmas Carol is perhaps the best of the four works, as well as the longest. I’m not particularly fond of Dickens’ writing style; he does not use much descriptive language or imagery, and the only reason why I can imagine the story’s setting is because I saw the Disney version of the story, the one with Mickey, Goofy, etc. For the most part, Dickens does nothing but describe what people do. It isn’t just his main characters that he describes; he describes the actions of random passers-by as well. Dickens also doesn’t develop his characters very well. It seems odd to say so, but in the Disney version of A Christmas Carol, Scrooge and his miserly lifestyle is described in much more depth. The viewer sees several ways in which Scrooge’s selfish actions affect not only his own life, but the lives of those around him as well. He hoards and spends hours counting money and makes life miserable for his poor clerk. In the novel version, however, Scrooge came off as nothing more than a grumpy old man. He didn’t seem particularly selfish in the least. Also, Dickens takes his sweet time saying or revealing anything. For example, in the chapter where Scrooge meets the Ghost Of Christmas Future, it takes Scrooge exactly seventeen pages to realize that he is the dead man whose death is being either celebrated or ignored. This wouldn’t be so much of a problem, except that the entire story is only about one-hundred pages, and not much happens, plot-wise. So when it takes about one-fifth of the story to reveal a minor plot point, the reading can become rather dull. Ignoring all other interpretations of the story, and focusing solely on Dickens’ original novel, I would say that he did such a poor job of characterizing Scrooge that, in the end, I felt that his previous actions did not really warrant the coming of the Spirits at all anyway. However, the conclusion to this story was rather good, as the effects that the traumatic experiences had on Scrooge were well illustrated. I do wish that there had been more mention of Tiny Tim in the written version; he plays a large part in the aforementioned Disney version, and it is always touching when a child warms the cold heart of a hardened old cynic.

The second story, and the first of the three short stories, titled "A Christmas Tree", was equally unsatisfying. It is merely twenty-one pages of Dickens’ description of a Christmas tree that he remembered from his childhood. This would not have been so bad, if Dickens had not tried to make the story into a narrative, and drift off on a tangent about the many instances in which people he knew were haunted by ghosts, only to die shortly afterward.

The third story, and the second of the three short stories, titled “A Christmas Dinner”, is a narrative about people becoming excited over a Christmas dinner complete with turkey, pudding, and the like. I read this one only a day or so ago, and cannot remember a single detail of it. That statement alone should tell you everything that you need to know about this piece.

The fourth story, and the third of the three short stories, titled “A Good-Humored Christmas”, is the story that I stopped after reading about one-quarter of the way through it. There are at least five characters, who have been given names or titles, yet I cannot remember who a single one is, because they are so poorly developed. These men are traveling somewhere (apparently to a Christmas wedding, according to the book’s back cover), but that has not been revealed yet, as far as I’m concerned. All that I’ve gotten out of this story is a bunch of oddly-named men riding around with horses. People have conversations with other random people, leave, and do the same thing again. There isn’t much of a coherent plot, and I can’t bring myself to finish the story. I will eventually force myself to do so eventually, after I tend to the other unread titles on my shelf.

Overall, I am very disappointed in Charles Dickens’ style of writing. He uses little imagery and does a poor job of developing his characters or bringing any of them to life. The character given the most attention and personality was Scrooge, and even he seemed like nothing more than a mere cynic. He didn’t even seem to really deserve being tossed about through time by three Spirits who nearly gave the old man a heart attack. In the end, I found Dickens’ stories very dull and difficult to read through. On the book’s back cover, Dickens’ Christmas stories are described as “nostalgic”, though all they did was make me want to watch the Mickey Mouse version again. On a final note, I would also like to tell the people that write these twenty-page-long introductions and after-words that if they aren’t going to write a novel of their own, they need to stop wasting pages in everyone else’s. Why do I need you to summarize for me and tell me how great Charles Dickens’ stories are? Am I not about to read them for myself and find out?

What did you think of this review?

Helpful
6
Thought-Provoking
6
Fun to Read
6
Well-Organized
6
Post a Comment
December 29, 2009
wow! excellent honest take on a book. I have to confess that I don't read much nowadays (do graphic novels count?) but I can tell that this is not for me. A Christmas Carol is definitely a classic, but I love your critique.
December 29, 2009
Thank you very much. I can see how "A Christmas Carol" would be considered a classic by some people, but it just wasn't for me.
December 31, 2009
December 31, 2009
Wow, that was thorough. Thank you for sharing the link. It had somehow slipped past me. That review definitely made it easier to see why A Christmas Carol became such a classic. I have nothing against the story itself, just the writing style, because I love the film/animated adaptations. It is a wonderful tale of redemption and the dismissal of cynicism.
 
December 29, 2009
It's cool how you don't limit your reviewing to a single category/ genre. I try to bounce around but always seem to come back to the same few things. Do you read a lot? I wax and wane with the fantasy novel scene (Robin Hobb, George RR Martin, Robert Jordan and so on). Ever get into that stuff? You seem to have a great capacity for it. By the way I'll trade you some of that Floridian weather for the blizzard we're having here in NY right now!!
December 29, 2009
I've never read much into the fantasy novel scene, but it definitely sounds interesting! I enjoy reviewing anime the most, but I think it's much easier to review novels because you don't have to worry about reviewing animation, music, and dubs. If I get stuck when working on an anime review, I'll write out a quick book review instead so I can return to the anime review with a clear head. It's actually getting pretty cold here in Florida, well, compared to the usual weather. It's about fifty-five, which probably sounds warm to you...
December 30, 2009
For sure- novel reviews are a walk in the park compared to anime (especially the big series). I just started Zone of Enders last night and have really been enjoying it thus far. Review coming soon. Also should you ever pick up a fantasy novel, please do drop a line. Would love to discuss. Finally, you are so right! 55 would be paradise to this single digit crap. I dread going out for any reason!
December 30, 2009
Really? I guess I find snow and single-digit temperatures to be exciting because I've never had to endure them. If you had to recommend one fantasy novel title, which would it be? I'd love to get into the genre, but wouldn't know where to start. I've never seen Zone Of The Enders, though it looks interesting. I've been working on an Ergo Proxy review for like three days now. I hope to finish by tomorrow. I'll be looking forward to the ZOTE review.
December 30, 2009
You know Ulalume, for better or worse, fantasy novels have the distinction of never being stand alone (they're all huge series). That said before I make a recommendation, let me ask a few things. 1) ever read The Hobbit or Lord of the Rings? 2) Ever see any Peter Jackson's LOTR films? 3) Do you fear commitment when it comes to books 4) Are you concerned at all with historical events (in our world)?
December 30, 2009
No, I've never read The Hobbit or LOTR, or seen the LOTR films. I don't mind commitment, since I read manga series that can be pretty lengthy, and when you say historical events, do you mean do I mind if they are portrayed accurately, or do I mind reading about history? Because it's no for either one. I read a Dean Koontz book where a guy traveled in time and changed the events of WWII, so I'm able to suspend my beliefs a little.
December 31, 2009
Good info, thanks. Keeping that in mind I would suggest picking up "A Game of Thrones" by George RR Martin. It's actually the start of a huge saga (The Song of Ice & Fire) but it's one of those things that you can continue on with if you liked it or simply pull the plug if not. If it turns out you do enjoy it, boy there are some real gems I could also recommend but so as not to overload you with options, I would honestly say give that one a try. I would so love to get into a discussion with you on this subject matter. It's just so intriguing.
December 31, 2009
Alright, thank you very much. I received a few books for the holidays, but I will pick up a copy of A Game Of Thrones as soon as I can.
 
1
More A Christmas Carol And Other Ch... reviews
Quick Tip by . June 29, 2010
I read a Christmas Carol every Christmas Eve
Quick Tip by . June 26, 2010
Good stories. Pleasant to read.
About the reviewer
GCS ()
Ranked #87
My user-name was derived from the title of a poem by Edgar Allan Poe. I came to Lunch with the hopes of publishing reviews that would be appreciated by others and reading the reviews of others that hope … more
Consider the Source

Use Trust Points to see how much you can rely on this review.

You
Ulalume
Your ratings:
rate more to improve this
About this book

Wiki

A 224-page book containing Charles Dickens' "A Christmas Carol", as well as three other Christmas stories.

view wiki

Details

ISBN-10: 0451531094
ISBN-13: 978-0451531094
Author: Charles Dickens
Genre: Fairy Tales, Christmas Fiction, Parable, Ghost Story
Publisher: Signet Classics
Date Published: November 4, 2008
First to Review
© 2014 Lunch.com, LLC All Rights Reserved
Lunch.com - Relevant reviews by real people.
()
This is you!
Ranked #
Last login
Member since
reviews
comments
ratings
questions
compliments
lists