Movies Books Music Food Tv Shows Technology Politics Video Games Parenting Fashion Green Living more >

Lunch » Tags » Books » Reviews » Before Their Time: A Memoir » User review

Before Their Time: A Memoir

A book by Robert Kotlowitz

< read all 1 reviews

They were soldiers once....

  • Feb 20, 2010
The World War II generation is fast passing away. My dad died 20 years ago, and my father-in-law is going to be 87 this year. While we can, we should learn from them what they went through during the war.

This is an excellent memoir of war, even if it really doesn't get into the horrors of battle. It is, rather, a tale of disparate young men coming together and, through training and just living together, becoming a unit ready for battle. The personal scenes are impressive, and quite moving at times.

These brave men and women often don't wish to tell their stories, because even after 60 years the memories are too raw. We should, therefore, be grateful for the ones who could get down on paper what they experienced.

We who haven't lived through those times can really not appreciate what happened. One thing is that they have never forgotten the past. I remember coming out of the theater after seeing "Saving Private Ryan" and, in the back of the theater were two elderly gentlemen in wheelchairs, obviously veterans, with tears streaming down their faces. That is the essence of those men and women, and we should be grateful to them every day for the freedom we experience.

What did you think of this review?

Fun to Read
Post a Comment
About the reviewer
Frank J. Konopka ()
Ranked #89
I'm a small town general practice attorney in the hard coal region of Pennsylvania. Books are my passion, andI read as many of them asI can. Being the President of the local library board for over … more
Consider the Source

Use Trust Points to see how much you can rely on this review.

Your ratings:
rate more to improve this
About this book


In the summer of 1943, Robert Kotlowitz, an indifferent premed student at Johns Hopkins University, was drafted into the army. "I told myself," he writes in his affecting memoir of World War II, "that it was better than being blatantly tossed out of college." In any event, he continues, "part of me, at eighteen, was eager to suffer the hazards and humiliations of war."

Hazards and humiliations he found in abundance. He was assigned to a company led by an inept captain and put to work in a Browning Automatic Rifle unit. In combat school at Fort Benning he learned that, in battle, such units had a life expectancy of eleven seconds. "That is not hyperbole," he adds wryly. "It is scientific fact." But Kotlowitz lived through the war, fueled by his hatred, as a Jew, for the German enemy, and burning with the patriotic fervor of a young man. Both his hatred and his fervor diminished as he endured battle, living close to the bone and watching as his comrades fell.

Kotlowitz writes with skill and mordant humor of the infantryman's life, of the incredible instinct to survive, of "the sounds ... never before heard, swelling over the noise of small-arms and machine-gun fire, of men's voices calling for help or screaming in pain or terror--our own men's voices, unrecognizable at first, weird in pitch and timbre." His fine memoir belongs on readers' shelves alongside such books as Stephen Ambrose's Band of Brothers and Paul Fussell's Doing Battle, primary documents of a terrible time. ...

view wiki



ISBN-10: 0385496036
ISBN-13: 978-0385496032
Author: Robert Kotlowitz
Publisher: Anchor

First to Review
© 2015 Lunch.com, LLC All Rights Reserved
Lunch.com - Relevant reviews by real people.
This is you!
Ranked #
Last login
Member since