Freedom has the two-and-a-half-dimensional feel of reality television. I enjoy reading it, but I'm not convinced that any of the characters (especially Patty) is really so good at taking punches. I read this book as I might Greek mythology. Franzen the jovial God, getting kicks out of kicking his characters but never quite believing any of them could ever really exist. I don't believe any of them could exist either, but then again, who cares?
It's definitely a five-star so far. Very fun to read. No flowery, pretentious prose, just smart writing.
#
Half-way through: the characters are getting there, though I'm still not buying Patty, Walter and Richard seemed to come to life immediately. Perhaps Franzen shouldn't write female characters? I don't know, maybe it's just this one character. I don't remember thinking this in The Corrections, but I don't really recall.
All in all, still going strong. There are passages in which I start thinking of other things I should be doing, or think maybe I'll take a nap, but if I read a few minutes longer, I'm pulled back in.
#
Still smart, still a tad unbalanced. All of the women herein are depressed and needy. What gives?
I'm getting distinct glimpses of Rabbit, Run; I Am Charlotte Simmons; something else...
#
OK, final assessment: strong writing, a little dry in places; Franzen could use more humor to balance out the seriousness of the characters and their situations (yes, literature needs humor (yes, I'm referring to this book as literature)); some of the secondary characters seem more alive than the main characters; the story is mostly realistic; there's some awkward dialog, some beautiful insights, and they are bravely displayed. I do wonder why all the women characters are not only depressed, but on medication for depression and why none of the characters are capable of being faithful. The political discussions, namely the discussions on population control, a taboo subject, won me over. Largely, a very good book.
What did you think of this review?
Use Trust Points to see how much you can rely on this review.
