|
Movies Books Music Food Tv Shows Technology Politics Video Games Parenting Fashion Green Living more >

Lunch » Tags » Books » Reviews » Lying: Moral Choice in Public and Private Life » User review

You will never think about lying in the same way again.

  • May 5, 2011
Rating:
+5
When the Swedish-born philosopher and ethicist Sissela Bok released her seminal work "Lying: Moral Choice In Public and Private Life" way back in 1978 Anthony Lewis of the New York Times hailed it as "A fascinating and exceptionally important book."  J.M. Cameron from the New York Review of Books observed that "It is pleasant to find a work of such analytical power devoted to a set of severely practical problems."  Indeed, when I first read "Lying: Moral Choice In Public and Private Life" some 20 or more years ago it changed my life.  Just the other day I found my old copy of the book and decided that all these years later this was one book that was definitely worth re-reading. 

In "Lying" Sissela Bok methodically builds the case that most of the lying we all cavalierly engage in on a regular basis in matters both large and small gradually erodes trust in families and in society at large.  She explains that "All our choices depend on our estimates of what is the case; these estimates must in turn rely on information from others. Lies distort this information and therefore our situation as we perceive it, as well as our choices."  Bok goes on to say that "To the extent that knowledge gives power, to that extent do lies affect the distribution of power; they add to that of the liar, and diminish that of the deceived, altering his choices at different levels."  I must admit that before reading this book I had never spent a whole lot of time considering the devastating impact that lies have in our personal relationships and in the community and world in which we live.

Throughout the pages of "Lying: Moral Choice in Public and Private Life" Sissela Bok presents a series of practical situations where lies may occur and examines the impact of those lies from the perspective of both the liar himself and the deceived.  Clearly, in the overwhelming majority of cases a lie puts the unsuspecting dupe at a substantial disadvantage.  Among the issues covered are the deceptive use of placebos in medical research, grade inflation, recommendations for employment and doctors covering up for incompetent colleagues to name but a few.  Meanwhile, Bok also explains why our deliberate silence in certain situations can also be deceptive and every bit as devastating as a spoken lie.  Sissela Bok also explores the age-old question "Is it ever OK to lie?" from the perspective of the great philosophers like St. Augustine, Thomas Aquinas, Friedrich Nietzsche and Immanuel Kant.  She also examines the idea of the "white lies" that we all engage in at one time or another and how harmful they actually can be. Then there are the "noble lies" that government officials insist are necessary from time to time to protect the public and safeguard social harmony. It seems that our leaders are convinced that the general public simply cannot handle the truth and that they know best. Very interesting stuff indeed!

More than three decades later "Lying: Moral Choice in Public and Private Life" remains in print.  An updated edition was issued back in 1999. This is a book that appears to be every bit as relevant today as it was back in 1978.  A couple of recent incidents in the news illustrate just what Sissela Bok is getting at in her book.  In 2008 and 2009 a young conservative activist named James O'Keefe III came to national attention when he went undercover and filmed unguarded conversations with workers at both Planned Parenthood and ACORN (Association of Community Organizations for Reform Now). O'Keefe accuses his targets of being unethical, irresponsible and biased.  Perhaps they were.  But what can be said of Mr. O'Keefe's under-handed behavior in this matter?  Do the ends really justify the means?  Then there is the worldwide scandal known as "Climategate" whereby substantial evidence has been uncovered indicating that scientists knowingly manipulated data and withheld evidence that did not support the theory of "global warming".  It seems to me that in both instances those who chose to employ deceptive practices to advance their political agendas did their causes substantially more harm than good.  These kinds of deceptive practices tear at the fabric of our society and ultimately result in increased suspicion and further division.

Now I can say with a fair amount of confidence that reading "Lying: Moral Choice in Public and Private Life" will change your life too.  I can promise you that you will never think about lying in the same way again.  It is Sissela Bok's fondest desire that after reading her book readers will "decide to rule out deception wherever honest alternatives exist, and become much more adept at thinking up honest ways to deal with problems." This is a very scholarly work that is also highly readable. There is certainly a ton of "food for thought" in this book.  Very highly recommended!
You will never think about lying in the same way again.

What did you think of this review?

Helpful
18
Thought-Provoking
18
Fun to Read
18
Well-Organized
18
Post a Comment
July 17, 2011
"Among the issues covered are the deceptive use of placebos in medical research, grade inflation, recommendations for employment and doctors covering up for incompetent colleagues to name but a few. " (1) Placebos in medical research may hinder a person in need of treatment from getting it early enough to make a difference. That's why second and third opinions may be needed in some cases. (2) Give examinations that are unassailable as to level of difficulty and you won't be accused of grade inflation. (3) Usually an astute interviewer can glean a person's competence together with professional credentials and verifying academic transcripts. Probation periods do exist so there are mechanisms to deal effectively with employment decision-making . (4) Insurers usually weed out bad doctors by forcing them to perform non-clinical functions. Generally, the truth- whatever it is- becomes known at some point either sooner or later.
 
May 09, 2011
Sounds very interesting! I like that the author explores other philosophers' thoughts about lying as well. Excellent review/essay, Paul!
 
May 09, 2011
This book sounds fascinating. I sometimes think that "a little white lie never hurts", but I'd be interested to read the author's remarks on that. So it talks about the psychology and ethics of lying, but does it talk about physiological effects and how to tell if a person's lying, etc? Great review, Paul!
 
May 06, 2011
Thankfully lying is not necessary in our family. You are loved regardless of what you did, honesty and integrity are personally more important to us than self-image. I understand why lies are prevalent in government, business, and corporations, but I think it has no place in the family. I would not want to be living with someone whom I know I cannot trust and who I know is okay with lying - just doesn't work that way around here and it isn't the way we were brought up! :)
 
May 05, 2011
--But don't we all lie? I suspect that lying, in most cases, is little more than part of the social behavior that keeps most of us from getting divorces, hurting feelings, avoiding wars or beatings, and experiencing public shame. Children and diplomats would be left defenseless without lies. ("I didn't eat the last chocolate chip cookie, mom!" "We've gotten rid of all our nerve gas!") --Most lies, I think, are like compromises, which we sometimes condemn in politicians but which we exercise all the time in our own lives just to live together more peacefully with our neighbors and co-workers and to get useful things done. --The problem with O'Keefe (and a few others) is that, unwilling simply to settle for being a sneak and a liar himself, he used careful selection, editing and entrapment. A far more serious case of lying is when someone who knows better says an organization spends 90 per cent of its money on abortions when the actual figure is three per cent. Hitler would have been proud of that one. --For the question of the earth's climate, seems to me that there are a number of people on both sides of that question, as you point out, who are equally bulgy-eyed fanatics. All I know is that if I live long enough I probably will save a ton of money I now spend on tanning salons. –I enjoyed reading your essay.
 
1
About the reviewer
Paul Tognetti ()
Ranked #2
I guess I would qualify as a frustrated writer. My work requires very little writing and so since 1999 I have been writing reviews on non-fiction books and anthology CD's on amazon.com. I never could … more
Consider the Source

Use Trust Points to see how much you can rely on this review.

You
drifter51
Your ratings:
rate more to improve this
About this book

Wiki

Details

ISBN-10: 9780375705281
ISBN-13: 978-0375705281
Publisher: Vintage Books
Date Published: September 14, 1999
Format: Paperback
© 2014 Lunch.com, LLC All Rights Reserved
Lunch.com - Relevant reviews by real people.
()
This is you!
Ranked #
Last login
Member since
reviews
comments
ratings
questions
compliments
lists