|
Movies Books Music Food Tv Shows Technology Politics Video Games Parenting Fashion Green Living more >

Lunch » Tags » Book » Reviews » The Impostor's Daughter: A True Memoir » User review

Laurie Sandell Wanders & Wonders as an Impostor's Daughter

  • Feb 11, 2010
  • by
Rating:
+5
Pros: Interesting and thought-provoking story
Worthwhile and meaningful illustrations

Cons: ...

The Bottom Line: Another ultra-impressive graphic novel that shouldn't be passed by

Not long ago I was cruising through graphic novel reviews trying to find some goodies for our library collection when I stumbled across Glamour contributing editor Laurie Sandell's The Impostor's Daughter.  The review hyped it up enough that I not only added it to my buy-list, I had it rushed and placed immediately on hold for me... within three days I had it in my hands, and twenty-four hours later I was finished with it.  I haven't found a graphic novel to really rock me in such a long time I'd almost forgotten how it feels... until now.

The book begins with quite an intriguing bit... a young naive looking brunette speaks of a father who, whenever away from the house, even if only for a day, has the mail held at the post office.  When she one time intercepts the mail, it is all addressed to named she doesn't recognize.  Similarly, telephone callers always ask for names she doesn't recognize, and when she tells them there is no one at the house by that name, her father oddly gets angry and says the calls are for him.  It is immediately clear that the reader is in for quite a story.  In fact, seeing the first few pages' words and illustrations are what drew me to having it rushed in the first place.

Laurie's father seems so heroic and mysterious in the beginning of the book, when she's an adolescent.  A professor at a community college, full of prestige and holding a law degree from NYU, a former green beret who's had brushes with many important, famous people... what's not to admire about her Argentine father and his larger-than-life existence?  She adores him and draws cartoons of him in a variety of humorous situations; oddly enough, her caricatures always depict him with an enormous head.  Lucky for young Laurie, her father seems to favor her over her two younger sisters and humors her with his stories of wild war adventures.  She works hard to impress him and when she disappoints him, which is rare, the world seems as though it might end.

As she grows older and becomes a teenager, however, she suddenly seems to become the very thing that angers him.  Illustrations of him throwing things at her and yelling obscenities help the reader see the degree to which the tables have turned.  No longer working as a professor, or at all, he becomes more and more of a recluse.  Upon entering adulthood, Laurie begins learning that her father may not have been what or who he said he was.  She learns of fraud he's committed involving her, and as she investigates his lies they seem to deepen.  When she questions the rest of her immediate family their responses aren't what she would want; denial, hurt, and down-right avoidance meet her head-on.

Author Laurie Sandell tells of her attempts to discover the truth about her father and the life he claimed to lead.  As her career begins to take off her exploration of her father's true life deepens... as does her unintended inquiry into her own life.  Laurie deals with her abuse of alcohol and Ambien and struggles with her own relationships with men, which she feels have been damaged because of the relationship with her father.

Sandell illustrates the book and tells her story comic book or graphic novel (though this doesn't really qualify as a novel, as it is a true story) style.  The pages are divided into frames in which she illustrates her words as she tells them, as if it were a journal.  She may write a few sentences in a frame and illustrate them to depict what she writes about.  She does include 'speech bubbles' and shows interaction between characters, but the majority of the written story is in the descriptions above many of the frames.  Her illustrations are colored generously, keeping the reader's eyes glued to the page and jumping from frame to frame, turning from page to page.  Characters are easy to differentiate from one another; in fact, her Sgt. Pepper-esque two-page spread helped to etch her illustrating ability into my memory.  In this spread, she shows some of her interviewees and it is very fun to guess who they are by her illustration of them and check the list at the bottom.  Her pictures capture not only the events themselves but also the emotion within, yet the colorful quality and clear images seem to have an almost innocent, child-like feeling to them.  I will say that I noticed that in almost every depiction of herself, Sandell is wearing blue bottoms and an orange top, or some variation of the type of clothing... but almost always that color combination. 

In The Impostor's Daughter, Laurie Sandell seems to have taken a cue (a rather large and appreciated cue) from author Allison Bechdel, imitating Bechdel's own autobiographical graphic novel Fun Home: a Family TragicomicBechdel also speaks of her confusing relationship with her father, and also writes her story as if it were a journal with illustrations.  Both authors are strong females, and I enjoy reading a graphic story written by a female and written and illustrated in this style. 

Laurie Sandell packs emotion, intrigue, and talented words and graphics into this book; as I mentioned above, it grabbed me and didn't let me go (interrupting the other book I was reading, in fact) until I was finished with it.  While I really have nothing in common with her or her story, I felt I could relate to it and put myself into every position she described.  Her story is amazingly interesting (just as much so as her father's stories) and the slightly ambiguous ending left me thoughtful.  I highly recommend this book, and am very happy to have rushed to add it to our library collection.

Recommended:
Yes

What did you think of this review?

Helpful
6
Thought-Provoking
6
Fun to Read
6
Well-Organized
6
Post a Comment
October 13, 2010
Wow, what an amazing review! Confession: I've never read a graphic novel but, this review made me want to change that and check out this one! I can see why you had it overnighted to you. Have you checked out the Graphic Novel Communities on here? I'm sure they'd love to read about this one along with any other reviews you have- For the Love of Comics (which is comics, films, and graphic novels) and Reality Inked: Comics, Graphic Novels and Manga
 
1
More The Impostor's Daughter: A Tru... reviews
review by . September 03, 2009
Laurie Sandell's The Impostor's Daughter is about, in equal parts, her impostor father and herself. This expertly crafted graphic novel charts the mysterious ways of her father, who would hoard the family's mail, getting letters addressed to him in multiple names. He boasted of amazing feats, so amazing they mesmerized young Laurie, who repeated them at school. She's curious about his odd ways, but it isn't until she finds out he's opened not just one, but multiple credit cards in her name, as well …
review by . November 10, 2009
This graphic novel was a truly wonderful read, full of insights and pathos. Sandell's willingness to lay bare her family secrets in an effort to better understand the reasons behind her sometimes self-destructive behavior is so raw and honest that I hurt for her. Her story is a touching one that outlines the challenges that those living with mental illness in the family must endure, and the terrible effect that an untreated condition can have on family members. I found myself enraged on Sandell's …
About the reviewer
Laura Elizabeth 'Anderson' Brack ()
Ranked #348
I'm brand new to Lunch and looking to get settled. I write on epinions.com as laurashrti, and enjoy writing product reviews.      I'm a 27-year-old library employee working … more
Consider the Source

Use Trust Points to see how much you can rely on this review.

You
laurashrti
Your ratings:
Aya
Aya
rate more to improve this
About this book

Wiki

In this delightfully composed graphic novel, journalist Sandell (Glamour) illustrates a touchingly youthful story about a daughter's gushing love for her father. Using a winning mixture of straightforward comic-book illustrations with a first-person diarylike commentary, Sandell recounts the gradual realization from her young adulthood onward that her charming, larger-than-life Argentine father, bragging of war metals, degrees from prestigious universities and acquaintances with famous people, had lied egregiously to his family about his past and accomplishments. Growing up with her two younger sisters and parents first in California, then in Bronxville, N.Y., the author records signs along the way that her father, a professor of economics with a volatile temperament and autocratic manner, was hiding something, from his inexplicable trips out of town, increasing paranoid isolation, early name change from Schmidt to Sandell, to massive credit-card fraud. Interviewing her father for her first magazine article, the author resolved to check his sources and even flew later to confront his past in Argentina, only to discover the truth. Feeling betrayed, guilty for exposing him and mistrustful in her relationships with men, Sandell numbed herself by abusing Ambien and alcohol. Her depiction of her rehab adventure is rather pat and tidy, and she does not address the notion that her own creativity might have sprung from her father's very duplicity. However, Sandell's method of ...
view wiki

Details

ISBN-10: 0316033057
ISBN-13: 978-0316033053
Author: Laurie Sandell
Publisher: Little, Brown and Company

© 2013 Lunch.com, LLC All Rights Reserved
Lunch.com - Relevant reviews by real people.
()
This is you!
Ranked #
Last login
Member since
reviews
comments
ratings
questions
compliments
lists