|
Movies Books Music Food Tv Shows Technology Politics Video Games Parenting Fashion Green Living more >

Lunch » Tags » Religion » Reviews » The Missionary Position: Mother Teresa in Theory and Practice » User review

+ 1 star after a few years of sober thought

  • Mar 10, 2004
Rating:
-1
The very first book I ever reviewed on Amazon was this one. At the time I had never heard of Chris Hitchens and doubted his motives.

I now am very familar with him and his opinions and looking at this book a 2nd time come to the following conclusions:

Hitchens has as always written an honest book as in my review of many years past I don't dispute the facts he details

Hitchens is not convinced of a vast Vatican conspericy as I thought he is instead the classic anti-theist. He has no use for religion and his conclusions of Mother Teresa stem from that.

The Basic arguement of the book is Mother Teresa is no saint because she is more interested in Catholic doctrine and belief then the care of the poor and furthermore put those doctrines ahead of her mission. He is quite correct.

However he forgets that #1 without that belief none of the good done by her and the sisters would have been done, and #2. As a believing and devout Catholic if she put the work ahead of her belief then she would be sinning. This is not only biblical (He who loves mother or Father more than me is not worthy of me) but best addressed in Lewis's SCREWTAPE LETTERS #23 "...we do want and want very much to make men treat Christianity as a means...a means to anything --even to social justice...the Enemy (God) will not be used as a convenience."

Much like his view of Mel Gibson's The Passion of the Christ the idea that the worship or belief in Christ as the primary cause for an action makes it less whole. If you believe religion is a waste of time then you will agree with both views. If you are a believer in Christ you will not.

Either way the book is worth reading. If only for the fact is is the only contrary view of Mother out there and is a more honest view than any other critic would give.

What did you think of this review?

Helpful
0
Thought-Provoking
0
Fun to Read
0
Well-Organized
0
Post a Comment
More The Missionary Position: Mothe... reviews
review by . June 17, 2000
As a Catholic after recovering my shock at this book and the various reviews (AH HA NOW WE SEE THROUGH THAT CHARLITON etc...!) I decided to read this book myself to see what was being said. I found the book compact and easy to read and much to my surprise VERY AMUSEING! It wasn't the facts as presented that amused me. They were presented in a fairly straight forward manner. It wasn't the attacks on Mother Teresa's order methods from the doctor or the nurse. Both have the right to their opinion aquired …
review by . March 01, 2000
Pros: A genuinely needed 'expose' rather than a gratuitous one     Cons: Too brief -- Hitchens is best in essay format, and unquestioning religious types will not be willing to hear a word of this     Sitting down to write about Missionary Position : The Ideology of Mother Teresa, I am both cheered and dismayed to find that somebody else has beaten me to the punch, and done a bang-up job. In many ways I have little to add, in no small part because my motivations …
About the reviewer
Peter Ingemi ()
Ranked #260
   I am a blogger who hosts a Saturday evening Radio show on WCRN 830 AM out of Worcester Mass. I blog about politics, religion, baseball and doctor who at datechguy.wordpress.com I also cover … more
Consider the Source

Use Trust Points to see how much you can rely on this review.

You
DaTechGuy
Your ratings:
rate more to improve this
About this book

Wiki

What's next--The Girl Scouts: The Untold Story? How could anybody write a debunking book about Mother Teresa and her Missionaries of Charity order? Well, in this little cruise missile of a book, Hitchens quickly establishes that the idea is not without point. After all, what is Mother Teresa doing hanging out with a dictator's wife in Haiti and accepting over a million dollars from Charles Keating? The most riveting material in the book is contained in two letters: one from Mother Teresa to Judge Lance Ito--then weighing what sentence to dole out to the convicted Keating--which cited all the work Keating has done "to help the poor," and another from a Los Angeles deputy D.A., Paul Turley, back to Mother Teresa that eloquently stated that rather than working to reduce Keating's sentence, she should return the money he gave her to its rightful owners, the defrauded bond-holders. (Significantly, Mother Teresa never replied.) And why do former missionary workers and visiting doctors consistently observe that the order's medical practices seem so inadequate, especially given all the money that comes in? (Hitchens acidly observes that on the other hand, Mother Teresa herself always manages to receive world-class medical care.) Hitchens's answer is that Mother Teresa is first and foremost interested not in providing medical treatment, but in furthering Catholic doctrine and--quite literally--becoming a saint.--This text refers to an out of print or unavailable edition of this title.
view wiki

Details

ISBN-10: 185984054X
ISBN-13: 978-1859840542
Author: Christopher Hitchens
Genre: Religion & Spirituality
Publisher: Verso
© 2014 Lunch.com, LLC All Rights Reserved
Lunch.com - Relevant reviews by real people.
()
This is you!
Ranked #
Last login
Member since
reviews
comments
ratings
questions
compliments
lists