Movies Books Music Food Tv Shows Technology Politics Video Games Parenting Fashion Green Living more >

Lunch » Tags » Books » Reviews » The Private Patient » User review

A masterpiece of literature in a mystery novel

  • Jun 1, 2009
  • by
P. D. James is the queen of mystery writers. Her Adam Dalgliesh thrillers are engrossing stories of murder and police detection and superb literature. She has succeeded where other authors have failed. Many of their mysteries are best sellers and certainly engrossing reads, but the English author P.D. James has done this and created a literary volume as well.
The Private Patient is a tale of a woman who was disfigured as a child by her drunken father who slashed her check in anger with a broken bottle, leaving a large and deep disfiguring scar. She made no attempt to remove the scar until she struck some success as an investigating reporter. Now after 34 years Rhoda Gradwyn sought out the renowned surgeon Chandler-Powell to remove the scar. The surgeon asks why she wants the surgery now after so many years. She curiously replies, "Because I no longer have need of it."
She is offered the surgery in the surgeon's London suite or in his stunning suburban retreat. She opts for the second, and is strangled there. Subsequently, there is another murder, an attempted murder, and a suicide.
James is a master of setting scenes and delineating the inner mind of her characters. She spends, for example, close to a hundred pages at the outset of her drama depicting her people, their life, desires and foibles. These set pieces are interesting in themselves because of the literary style of presentation and the unique often unexpected and curious details, and help develop the novel's tension. They do not detract the reader's interest from the murder mystery, but further that interest and hold it firm.
Even the murder scene is written with this literary engrossing skill, as seen in the following part of a much larger murder setting. Miss Gradwyn is lying in bed after the operation.
As she lay rigid, the pale figure, white-clad and masked, was at her bedside. Arms moved above her head in a ritual gesture like an obscene parody of a benediction. With an effort she tried to struggle up - the bedclothes seemed suddenly to weigh her down - and stretched out a hand for the bell pull and the lamp. The bell pull wasn't there. Her hand found the light switch and clicked it on, but there was no light. Someone must have hooked the bell pull out of reach and taken the bulb from the lamp. She didn't cry out. All those early years of self-control against betraying fear, against finding relief in shouting and yelling, had inhibited her power to scream. And she knew screaming would be ineffective; the dressing made even speech difficult. She struggled to get out of bed but found herself unable to move.
The reader should note the frequent use of poetic alliterations in this paragraph, the frequent repetition of the letter S, as in the next selection describing the reactions of the police to the body of the murder victim, where the letter S stands out more than a half dozen times and the letter P four times in a single sentence, sometimes as a first letter and at other times in the middle or end of a word. "The best pathologists and police officers, standing where they stood now, never lost respect for the dead, a respect born of shared emotions, however temporary, the unspoken recognition of a common humanity, a common end."
Because her novel is more than a murder mystery, she devotes ten pages after the murders are solved to the further development of her characters. One of her characters' thoughts after the resolution of the crimes, the final words of the novel, ties the novel together and demonstrates again the literary qualities of this marvelous book, words we would not expect to find in the genre of mystery novels.
The world is a beautiful and terrible place. Deeds of horror are committed every minute and in the end those we love die. If the screams of all earth's living creatures were one scream of pain, surely it would shake the stars. But we have love. It may seem a frail defence against the horrors of the world, but we must hold fast and believe in it, for it is all that we have.
P.D. James's mystery raises many questions. Some are aroused by the artistically drawn people, such as: Will Dalgliesh marry his much younger sweetheart? Will his assistant Kate reunite with her boy friend? Will the surgeon's assistant leave his employ and go to Africa? Many questions are evoked by the whodunit itself. These include, of course, who murdered the woman and why? Was the second murder related to the first? Why did Gradwyn want the cosmetic surgery thirty four years after her disfigurement? What did she mean when she said that she has no need any longer for the scar?
James does not answer all of these questions. Ambiguities and obscurities frequently occur in many mystery novels and is the hallmark of good literature. It is as the Argentinean writer Jorge Borges wrote: two people write a book, the author and the reader. In The Private Patient, P. D. James did her part well; no doubt readers will enjoy doing there's.

What did you think of this review?

Fun to Read
Post a Comment
More The Private Patient reviews
review by . May 30, 2009
If Private Patient is truly PDJ's final Dalgliesh novel, she's taking him out in style! AD has always been the most human, humane, and cultured of the detective genre, and at long last, he's gained some well deserved happiness. Although most of his cases have been firmly closed at the end of each story, in this one, James has left some wiggle room. This is a fine police procedural/human interest story, as beautifully written and atmospheric as we've come to expect from her. Five stars for yet another …
About the reviewer
Israel Drazin ()
Ranked #64
Dr. Israel Drazin is the author of twenty books, including a series of five volumes on the Aramaic translation of the Hebrew Bible, which he co-authors with Dr. Stanley M. Wagner, and a series of four … more
Consider the Source

Use Trust Points to see how much you can rely on this review.

Your ratings:
rate more to improve this
About this book


Starred Review. In James's stellar 14th Adam Dalgliesh mystery (after 2006'sThe Lighthouse), the charismatic police commander knows the case of Rhoda Gradwyn, a 47-year-old journalist murdered soon after undergoing the removal of an old disfiguring scar at a private plastic surgery clinic in Dorset, may be his last; James's readers will fervently hope it isn't. Dalgliesh probes the convoluted tangle of motives and hidden desires that swirl around the clinic, Cheverell Manor, and its grimly fascinating suspects in the death of Gradwyn, herself a stalker of minds driven by her lifelong passion for rooting out the truth people would prefer left unknown and then selling it for money. Beyond the book's central moral concern, James meditates on universal problems like aging (the amorphous flattening of self) and the government's education policy, which targets 50% of the young as university-bound while ensuring that another 40% are uneducated on leaving secondary school. Against her relentless intellectual view of our dying earth, James pits the love she finally grants Dalgleish—sufficient to reinvigorate hope and faith so rare in both fiction and reality today.(Nov.)
Copyright © Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
view wiki


ISBN-10: 0307270777
ISBN-13: 978-0307270771
Author: P.D. James
Genre: Mystery & Thrillers
Publisher: Knopf
First to Review

"AD's final case?"
© 2015 Lunch.com, LLC All Rights Reserved
Lunch.com - Relevant reviews by real people.
This is you!
Ranked #
Last login
Member since