Movies Books Music Food Tv Shows Technology Politics Video Games Parenting Fashion Green Living more >

Lunch » Tags » Books » Reviews » The Rational Optimist: How Prosperity Evolves » User review

A Real Eye-Opener

  • Oct 11, 2010

The Rational Optimist is a self-described contrarian view of the economy and economic development, from prehistory until now. Author Matt Ridley is unabashedly optimistic about the future of humanity and makes a credible case for his view that humans will continue to progress throughout the 21st century, sustainability challenges notwithstanding. He refutes pessimists who believe that that the planet cannot support more humans than it already has by asserting that economic progress will continue through trade and technological advances.

The way Ridley tells it, the story of human development is a story of increasing specialization. In times when one person was more or less self-sufficient -- growing his own food, making his own farm implements, baking his own bread, etc. etc. -- people were able to maintain only a subsistence level of life. There was no time to think, invent, write, read, make art or do any of the other activities that make up culture and civilization. As people began to settle in groups, they learned to trade and buy things from one another. This meant that one person needed to do only one or two things well; he could trade with other individuals for the things that he didn't produce himself. The more that individuals traded, the more they could specialize, and the more free time they had to develop culture and, most important, to invent new technologies. Eventually, we ended up here in 2010. Thus, says Ridley, specialization and trade are the keys to civilization. Always have been, always will be.

His argument echoes some of the ideas put forth by Jane Jacobs in her wonderful little book, Cities and the Wealth of Nations, although Ridley's scope is far broader. The essential argument remains pretty much the same, though. People need to be in proximity to one another in order to create critical mass sufficient to begin a cycle of trading between many producers and many consumers. There do seem to be parallels to this idea operating in today's economy. It's a version of the argument put forth by the Bush Administration after 9/11: If Americans stop shopping, the terrorists win.

One other feature of his argument that I also enjoyed is that Ridley describes the role that the media play in instilling public pessimism. The media,especially television, seek drama and controversy, which means that worriers and social critics usually get more play than a reasoned, rational spokesperson. Thus viewers are far more apt to see negative, even frightening, feature stories than they are to see more nuanced content. Ridley cites a number of examples of doomsayers (Paul Ehrlich of The Population Bomb, for instance) whose prophesies Ridley claims never came to fruition.

While critics will doubtless find much to criticize in this book, as did I, the fact remains that Ridley presents a well-argued case for believing in human progress, and for being optimistic about our shared future. And his challenges to more conventional thinkers who forecast doom and gloom make for intriguing reading. This is a refreshing read and one or the rare books that I will keep in my library, and not pass along to the thrift shop.

A Real Eye-Opener

What did you think of this review?

Fun to Read
Post a Comment
February 13, 2011
Great review, Bonnie! I think there is definitely something to thinking of your glass as half-full and this book sounds like a great read. Thanks for sharing :)
More The Rational Optimist: How Pro... reviews
review by . July 09, 2010
Matt Ridley has done it. He has written a book that takes a realist's approach at looking toward the future. His findings... it's a heck of a lot better than people are predicting.      True Story. On a recent flight I had the misfortune of sitting next to a white knuckle anarchist. I decided that talking to him during the flight was probably the best way to keep me free from wearing vomit. The anarchist would make statements like, "anyone who can not feed their …
review by . August 05, 2010
If you don't already believe that we now live in the most prosperous era in human history, The Rational Optimist should convince you. Every generation before us lived shorter, harder lives, with more dangers and fewer freedoms. And things will almost certainly keep getting better and better, as the market continues to support further innovation and specialization.    Ridley argues this point exhaustively with a constant stream of numbers and factoids. Indeed, the book's broad …
About the reviewer
Bonnie McEwan ()
Ranked #128
I own a communications consultancy in NYC called MAKE WAVES, which serves nonprofit organizations and foundations. I also hold a Visiting Lecturer position at Milano: The New School for Management & … more
Consider the Source

Use Trust Points to see how much you can rely on this review.

Your ratings:
rate more to improve this
About this book


Ideas have sex, in Ridley's schema; they follow a process of natural selection of their own, and as long as they continue to do so, there is reason to retire apocalyptic pessimism about the future of our species. Erstwhile zoologist, conservationist, and journalist, Ridley (The Red Queen) posits that as long as civilization engages in exchange and specialization, we will be able to reinvent ourselves and responsibly use earthly resources ad infinitum. Humanity's collective intelligence will save the day, just as it has over the centuries. Ridley puts current perceptions about violence, wealth, and the environment into historical perspective, reaching back thousands of years to advocate global free trade, smaller government, and the use of fossil fuels. He confidently takes on the experts, from modern sociologists who fret over the current level of violence in the world to environmentalists who disdain genetically modified crops. An ambitious and sunny paean to human ingenuity, this is an argument for why ambitious optimism is morally mandatory.(June)
Copyright © Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
view wiki


Books, Nonfiction, Nonfiction Books, Economics, Wealth, Matt Ridley, Practical Reason, Optimism


ISBN-10: 006145205X
ISBN-13: 978-0061452055
Author: Matt Ridley
Genre: History, Science
Publisher: Harper
Date Published: May 18, 2010
First to Review
© 2015 Lunch.com, LLC All Rights Reserved
Lunch.com - Relevant reviews by real people.
This is you!
Ranked #
Last login
Member since