Movies Books Music Food Tv Shows Technology Politics Video Games Parenting Fashion Green Living more >

Lunch » Tags » Books » Reviews » The Year of Magical Thinking » User review

An evocatively coherent patchwork of facts and opinions on life, loss and bereavement.

  • Apr 3, 2013
  • by
Joan Didion, one of America's foremost journalists and writers, tackles a universal experience in The Year of Magical Thinking, that of dying, death, loss and grief. Ever the practitioner of the literary succinct and eloquent-trademarks of Didion's writing style-she explores these themes and global experiences via her own personal tragedies, i.e. the sudden 2003 death of her husband-of nearly forty years of marriage-in their apartment and their daughter, Quintana's severe ill-health. She too died some short years later. How does one deal and go on continue living in the aftermath of it all? Even more striking, how does one continue to still write and document the whole (what people perceive) grim totality of it all? In the Year of Magical Thinking, Joan Didion does precisely that and a lot more.

In this book, which encompasses two different literary styles, that of the memoir and that of the field of investigative journalism, Didion, through her own experiences, becomes a searcher, an explorer, for the hows and whys of what death and grieving really are. In many instances, she catches herself in that pool of tempestuous and fluctuating emotions, for when she was not grieving for her deceased husband, John Gregory Dunne, also a noted writer, she was working to help care for her seriously ill daughter, Quintana. She was, in essence, a ping pong ball going back and forth between the death of her husband and the inevitable death of her beloved daughter. The fact that she worked and struggled to adapt herself to the dramatic changing situations in which she found herself is nothing short of miraculous. Fortunately, she had plenty of friends and some family members who helped buoy her up in her dark moments. And sometimes she didn't. Through it all, with her keen eye for observation and analysis, she realized that she now was the focal point of her own story, not the hippies, politicians and whatnot that she so excellently covered when she was (and still is) a stellar example of the New Journalism phenomenon and establishment.

There is a lot in this dense book of facts and musings and much to be gleaned; it focuses and relies heavily on an assortment of written works by doctors and medical people and even some writers who could be considered experts in the area of the dying process and the emotional aftermath results. Primarily, this book delves into the vast and complicated medical and funerary odyssey that Joan Didion found herself having to navigate, from death itself, to the funeral, to living alone and adapting to it, then trying to understand it all and then to having to repeat the whole lengthy medical odyssey all over again with her daughter. While Joan Didion didn't really espouse a particular faith belief, something I found a rather dismaying, she did hold onto what she felt was her lifeline to coping and dealing, and that was the concrete and absolute certainty in science and all the so-called intellectual fact-finding that she unearthed in the writing of The Year of Magical Thinking. I wonder if she ever read any of the books by Dr. Elizabeth Kubler Ross, a noted medical doctor of Thanatology? Perhaps if she had, her perception towards religion and the spirit might have been a little different and not so unfortunately narrow and limiting. While religion or even spiritualism did not really have a place in Didion's award-winning memoir, to me, I felt that it was just something that was visually appealing for her (in regards to churches) and obligatory (in terms of prayers and litanies). At the end of the book, however, I felt that Joan Didion was very honest and true to herself and her own beliefs. I respected that in the end, and I appreciated her for allowing us as readers to hear and share in her story and struggle of life, death and bereavement. In writing about herself and this difficult period and subject, she too wrote about all of us, for death is universal and inevitable. Truly a remarkable book!

What did you think of this review?

Fun to Read
Post a Comment
More The Year of Magical Thinking reviews
review by . April 28, 2010
No Consolation from Grief
   Click here to read the book quotes.      Originally, I read this book as a way to cope with a lot of family deaths that occurred during a difficult time in my life. It was recommended by a user of the Yahoo Cafe Libri Group, but it didn't live up to my expectations. Perhaps the disconnection lay in the fact that Didion suffered from the loss of a spouse whereas my grief was more distant: my cousin, grandmother, uncle, and great uncle all died in relative …
review by . July 05, 2010
Many years ago Joan Didion was featured on C-Span's BookTV.  I don't have many writers which register as rock stars, but for me, Didion is definitely one of them.  The show had a call-in period.  I didn't expect to get through, but low and behold after a few busy signals, did in fact get through to ask a question to one of my literary idols.  I wish I could say I asked her a phenomenal, insightful question and that her face showed she was impressed with my knowledge …
Quick Tip by . July 06, 2010
A great read, and very well-written, but certainly not a book to cheer you up. Read this if you're in the mood for something a bit sad.
Quick Tip by . June 16, 2010
So sad and beautifully written,I recommended this book to everyone I love immediately after I finished it.
Quick Tip by . June 16, 2010
A fascinating look at grief--how it changes us, how to accept when tragedies happen. A wonderful book.
Quick Tip by . June 15, 2010
Just another new age look at principles that cause people to think they can get something for nothing. That is not how life works.
Quick Tip by . August 28, 2009
The Year of Magical Thinking by iconic writer Joan Didion- tackles grief- a candid, memorable book- couldn't put it down!
review by . February 06, 2009
This whole book describes events and stories throughout the lives of Joan Didion and her family, and it serves as a way for her to express her grief and try to come to terms with the death of her husband of 40 years, all during a year of what she calls "magical thinking."      It's not an entertaining read. It offers some insight on marriage and family, but overall I felt like I was reading something far too personal, a diary of sorts, something that anyone else might write but …
About the reviewer
Christian Engler ()
Ranked #543
I am a writer who loves books.
Consider the Source

Use Trust Points to see how much you can rely on this review.

Your ratings:
rate more to improve this
About this book


The Year of Magical Thinking (2005), by Joan Didion (b. 1934), is an account of the year following the death of the author's husband John Gregory Dunne (1932–2003). Published by Knopf in October 2005, the book was immediately acclaimed as a classic in the genre of mourning literature. It won the National Book Award in November 2005 and was a finalist for the National Book Critics Circle Award as well as the Pulitzer Prize for Biography/Autobiography 
view wiki


ISBN-10: 140004314x
Author: Joan Didion
Genre: Nonfiction,Autobiography
Publisher: Alfred A. Knopf
Date Published: 2005
ISBN: 140004314x
Format: Hardcover (first edition)
First to Review
© 2014 Lunch.com, LLC All Rights Reserved
Lunch.com - Relevant reviews by real people.
This is you!
Ranked #
Last login
Member since