Movies Books Music Food Tv Shows Technology Politics Video Games Parenting Fashion Green Living more >

Lunch » Tags » Fiction » Reviews » Airtight a book » User review

Airtight a book

A David Rosenfelt Thriller

< read all 1 reviews

Not One of Rosenfelt's Better Efforts

  • Mar 14, 2013

I have read all the Andy Carpenter books and the five or so previous one-off books that Rosenfelt has put out and have never been disappointed having always given a four or five star rating for each.  I can't say that for this book. 

Judge Brennen is about to rule on an important case involving fracking (a means of getting oil) and is found dead.  A tip leads detective Luke Somers to Stephen Gallagher's place.  When he gets there he sees Gallagher with a gun and yells at him to put it down. When he gets no response, Luke fires three bullets, killing Gallagher.  A bag of bloodied clothing is found and it appears that Gallagher was the judge's killer.  Unfortunately, Gallagher's brother Chris doesn't think so.  Chris is back on military leave and has a history of violence against "bad" people who had wronged his brother in the past.

Chris thinks that Luke went in to Stephen's place with the intent of murdering him.  So to get even, he kidnaps Luke's brother Brian and hides him underground with a week's air supply.  He then confronts Luke and tells him to re-open the investigation and find the judge's "real" killer or his brother will die when his air supply runs out.

That is the premise of the book and it may sound more interesting than it is. For me it wasn't.  I struggled with this book.  Firstly, Rosenfelt makes it blatantly obvious that Stephen may have been set up with his chapters on the fracking and the people that will benefit from it.  I had problems with Luke.  Firstly, Luke is not so likeable as most of Rosenfelt's heroes are, having wronged his brother.  I found it real hard to find much to like about Luke. 

I am a bit claustrophic and do not like tales about people stuck in tight spaces with no air.  I felt that the story just "hobbled" along and unlike prior books, had no compulsion to pick the book back up once I had put it down.  This book in no way influences me getting future Rosenfelt books, as he is still one of my favorite authors.  But even great authors sometimes put out "turkey."  Read Heart of a Killer instead or one of the author's excellent prior books.

What did you think of this review?

Fun to Read
Post a Comment
About the reviewer

Ranked #9
I first got on this blog to discuss my first passion which is books. Since I have gotten on I find that books are only a piece of this blog and I can discuss just about anything that comes to mind. It … more
Consider the Source

Use Trust Points to see how much you can rely on this review.

Your ratings:
rate more to improve this
About this topic


Judge Daniel Brennan is only days away from achieving a seat on the Second Circuit Court of Appeals bench when he’s brutally stabbed to death in his garage. An army of media and law enforcement descend on the case, and thousands of tips pour in from the public. When one tip leads New Jersey policeman Luke Somers to Steven Gallagher, things quickly go wrong, but Luke is instantly glorified for solving the case.

But to one man, Luke is no hero. Chris Gallagher raised his brother, Steven, almost single-handedly, and, certain that Steven is innocent, he won’t rest until he sets the record straight. Thanks to Luke’s newfound fame, he’s an easy man to find, and Chris quickly makes it clear that Luke’s own brother will die if Luke refuses to help clear Steven’s name. So begins Luke’s desperate attempt to find another suspect—any other suspect—in Judge Brennan’s death. But Luke’s investigation might open the door to powerful forces even more dangerous than Chris Gallagher.

From David Rosenfelt, author of the beloved Andy Carpenter series, comes Airtight, a high-octane thriller of murder, revenge, and family loyalty.

view wiki


First to Review
© 2015 Lunch.com, LLC All Rights Reserved
Lunch.com - Relevant reviews by real people.
This is you!
Ranked #
Last login
Member since