Movies Books Music Food Tv Shows Technology Politics Video Games Parenting Fashion Green Living more >

Lunch » Tags » Movies » Reviews » EPITAPH (a.ka. Gidam, The Last Breath) » User review

Beautiful, Haunting and Ambitious...But A Little Clumsy in its Execution

  • Oct 15, 2009
Yeh, yeh…I know what you are thinking. Asian horror has become redundant with long-haired vengeful ghosts that seek relief from their torment. While I would agree, the “Yurei” or long-haired pale-faced ghost is actually a significant part of Asian lore; much like vampires, werewolves and zombies and we, as Americans never get tired of those elements…so why should Asians? The Jung Brothers’ horror drama “EPITAPH” (a.k.a. “The Last Breath”) is a film that tries something different and puts this horror film in the middle of a period drama that takes place during Japan’s occupation of Korea. The film is an episodic tale of three different short stories similar to “Three Extremes” but different since they are all linked together.
February, 1942. Jung-Nam Park (Ku Jin) is a young Med student who is engaged to be married to a woman he had never met. He is also assigned to watch over the cadavers in the morgue that during this time, he falls in love with a frozen dead woman (talk about necrophilia). A new patient also gets admitted who was the lone survivor of a fatal car accident. This young girl named Asoka (Joo-Yeon Ko) also becomes haunted by ghosts every night. Meanwhile, a young married couple, doctors In-Young (Bo-Kyeong Kim) and Dong-Won Kim (Tae-Soo Kim, Hypnotized) arrives from Japan and suddenly a rash of murders begin to happen…just what is this sinister hospital?

dream or reality?
The Jung brothers focus on a central theme; “Ghosts” and they attempt to challenge the thin lines between fragmented storytelling, arty style and a ostentatious narrative because of the way the stories are linked together by a common place, beautiful cinematography and bloody scenes embedded in its equation. The film does have the potential for a compelling storyline but for some reason, the direction fails to make a connection with its execution. The film is about the longing, sadness and loneliness of tormented souls and the sufferings of those left behind.
“Epitaph” is a haunting horror film and the style with which it is shot is just so enthralling; from the set designs (the morgue with wooden freezers), symbolisms are used (the use of dreams and hallucinations), the flower petals that gently eases into the wind and the manner with which the Jung bros. concentrate in enriching the visuals with touches of familiar objects that are seen in haunting locality. Once we see just how beautiful the film is, then the direction gives us a taste of gore and several freaky images. They do manage to capture the visceral images in delightful imagery; the audience will be drawn in, have their stomachs turn and then have them swim in the film’s plotline. It was obvious that the direction took inspiration from “A Tale of Two Sisters”.
However, the problems with “Epitaph” isn’t its style or even the performances. It is the manner the stories are laid out for the audience. There are a lot of characters in the film and the viewer has to pay the utmost attention in remembering each one. It is very similar to “Three Extremes” because of the three tales of horror; the story of Jung-Nam, the haunting of Asoka and the husband whose wife casts no shadow--but the cohesiveness of the story is just too episodic for its own good. It has ambition, but the way they were put together just proved too alienating even for me who is very used to mind-benders. Also, the tales themselves aren’t really that original or inventive; it is alright even if it wasn’t very compelling as long as it keeps the pace tight and precise. But the film’s plot is just left to wallow in its familiar groundwork. There is also a twist near the end, but it lacked sufficient legwork that it seemed to be a mere attempt at a cheap shock than as an inherent part of the film’s main premise. 

Asoka's haunting
The elements and devices in the film are just very familiar. It touches on the aforementioned “A Tale of Two Sisters”, a bit of “Uzumaki” and some of Takashi Miike’s tone; heck, it even throws in a bit of “Psycho” into the mix. I guess the Jung Bros. focused too much in making the film very pretty that they may have missed the fact that the story needed to be more cohesive as to generate non-stop tension to accompany its beautiful visuals in the cinematic experience.
Thankfully, the cast does turn out with several good performances, most notably by young Joo-Yeon Ko who plays Asoka, the girl haunted by ghosts and she proves to be the film’s saving grace. It was very easy to sympathize with her, although her character was a little too twisted. Ko manages to bring out several dramatic performances that can certainly get the viewer involved in the story. The other characters were pretty low key besides Bo-Kyeong Kim who is just so charming and sometimes creepy as the loving wife who casts no shadow.
“Epitaph” is a fair attempt at another entry in the books of Korean horror. While the direction got a little too careless in its conclusions and the twists emerging as too cheap; as the film tries too hard to take a stab to surprise the audience in a story that isn‘t much more than it should have been. Still, despite the clumsy storytelling, the film does manage to pull off some decent scares and some gruesome imagery. Sadly, because of the numerous familiar devices, the film was left with too much to put together and it faltered in this department. “Epitaph” is a beautiful movie with haunting imagery, strong photography and ambition; but it all feels a little hollow because of the way it overplayed its cards.
Recommended timidly with caution, a RENTAL first would be advisable [3 Stars]
poster U.S. dvd Asoka med student and the corpse dream or reality? Asoka's haunting

What did you think of this review?

Fun to Read
Post a Comment
October 16, 2009
My attention span isn't what it used to be. I can take a 3 and 1/2 hour movie if it's got singing and dancing and lots of pretty colors, but I don't want to risk spraining my brain on a ghost story that isn't all that good.
October 17, 2009
any recs for a Bollywood horror movie?
October 17, 2009
Still looking for something that I would recommend. I've checked out two oldies by the Ramsay Brothers who in the 1980s were the Kings of Bollywood horror and were compared to Hammer, though I'm not seeing it myself. I suppose it's a reference to some slightly gothic touches in their films as well as to their success itself. Both had songs, but the dance numbers reminded me of the 1960s where the kids would go into a night club or something and drool over a chubby go-go girl. I did see a preview for one that seemed to be more of what I'm looking for but there was no English title. It featured zombie like ghouls (and 2 skeletons) dancing towards the camera. I know that what I want is out there! One of the 2 films was sort of a vampire film so I'm going to try and write it up for Trashie, but it's only for completists. I have a modern one to watch this weekend but I suspects that it will be very much in the Hollywood vein with some songs thrown in.
October 18, 2009
Interesting. I'll wait for that Bollywood vampire review then. You know I am pretty open-minded to everything. The Ramsay Bros. does sound intriguing although sometimes being dubbed the kings of anything doesn't necessarily mean something...I'd like to check out some other foreign horror; I've done European and Asian horror and Bollywood is something I would like to try. But I wouldn't be confident enough to review a Bollywood as of yet...
October 19, 2009
For some reason there apparently hasn't been a lot of Indian horror. Maybe it's been because they've been living too much of it since partition. Nice touch for Halloween, by the way.
About the reviewer
William ()
Ranked #1
Please "Like" Film and Movies and Keep the Economy strong....LOL!!      My Interests: Movies, Anime, History, Martial Arts, Comics, Entertainment,Cooking, Things I don't … more
Consider the Source

Use Trust Points to see how much you can rely on this review.

Your ratings:
rate more to improve this
© 2015 Lunch.com, LLC All Rights Reserved
Lunch.com - Relevant reviews by real people.
This is you!
Ranked #
Last login
Member since