Movies Books Music Food Tv Shows Technology Politics Video Games Parenting Fashion Green Living more >

Lunch » Tags » Movies » Reviews » Hara-Kiri: Death of a Samurai (Ichimei) » User review

Ritual Suicide as Committed By the Third Dimension

  • Jul 21, 2012
Star Rating:

True to current cinematic trends, Takashi Miike’s Hara-Kiri: Death of a Samurai has been released in 3D. There’s no real reason this process had to be applied to this particular film, given the fact that it isn’t a fantasy, an animated family film, an action extravaganza (contrary to what the title suggests), or part of any genre in which 3D would be accepted – or, at the very least, tolerated. The film is, by and large, a character study and a tragedy, and as such, the visuals rarely lend themselves to gimmicky shots of objects flying at the screen or even creating an immersive experience. Making matters worse is the issue of brightness. Much of the film is spent within a cramped, dingy home in which sunlight almost never creeps in; this means that we in the audience must endure a dim, muddy picture of characters already immersed in shadow.
My complaints about 3D notwithstanding, I admittedly did appreciate this film more than Miike’s previous import, the overrated 13 Assassins, which isn’t directly related to this film but certainly acts as a sort of parallel story. I think what bothered me the most about 13 Assassins was that it was attempting to glamorize a life that, on the basis of what’s depicted in the film, was anything but glamorous; here were a group of men living by a barbaric code of conduct, one that viewed ceaseless servitude and glorified suicide missions as honorable. Now we have a film that not only calls into question this lifestyle but also holds back on the gore and violence. There are two exceptions to the latter. One is a grotesque and needlessly protracted sequence in which a ronin attempts to commit seppuku with a wooden sword. The other is a final battle scene, less bloody but again needlessly protracted.

Taking place in 1600s Japan, the film opens when a middle aged ronin named Hanshiro Tsugumo (Ebizo Ichikawa) enters the gates of a samurai clan. Begging an audience with the lead retainer, Kageyu (Koji Yakusho), he claims that he is a samurai without a master to serve, and therefore wants die nobly by committing seppuku in his courtyard in full view of the other samurai. Kageyu isn’t immediately willing to grant his request, seeing as it’s now common for men to enter clan compounds, lie about their status as failed warriors, and claim they want to commit suicide when what they really want is charity. He tells Hanshiro the story of a young man who did exactly that not too long ago; his request was granted, but he only ended up asking for an extra day and, ultimately, for money. An example was made of him, of course, and as painfully as possible, he went through with the hara-kiri.
In due time, Hanshiro is kneeling on a mat in the clan’s courtyard, surrounded by well-clad, well-armed samurai. But before the suicide ritual can be completed, Hanshiro reveals that what he really wants is vengeance for the young man’s death. And with that, he tells his own story, which plays as an extended flashback sequence. We learn that the young man was named Motome (Eita), and that Hanshiro took him in as a boy and raised him as his own after his father grew ill and died. We watch as Motome and Hanshiro’s daughter, Miho (Hikari Mitsushima), grow up together, fall in love, and ultimately have a baby boy. We watch the entire family enduring more downs than ups, as they are poverty stricken. Motome, who took to reading and writing at an early age, is forced to pawn off his beloved books just for two eggs – one of which inevitably falls and cracks.

The film veers into melodramatic territory the instant Miho lets out a small cough, and it only gets worse when her baby boy develops a fever. There are specific visuals related to both characters that could have easily been exploited for their ability to horrify an audience, but mercifully, Miike restrains himself; he shows that which is absolutely necessary to get the point across, and no more. Unlike 13 Assassins, which had its serious moments but was much more action driven, this movie is deliberately centered on its characters and the quieter moments they share. Although their desperate situation would fit right in with any present-day soap opera, we at least are given the opportunity to know who they are. We’re also made to feel what they feel, unpleasant though it may be.
The film, like 13 Assassins, is a remake of a 1960s Japanese samurai epic, and as the tenor of my review makes abundantly clear, I haven’t seen the original version. No matter; I suspect present-day audiences are much more likely to compare this film to 13 Assassins than to its cinematic source. At the risk of sounding like a broken record, I’m strongly advising you to steer clear of a 3D presentation of Hara-Kiri: Death of a Samurai. Short of a digital presentation or the celluloid being run through an IMAX 3D projector, you will see only dark images that barely register as having any depth – save for a few brief scenes featuring falling snow, which is far more noticeable than all the people and swords put together. It’s disappointing that Miike felt the need to do as many directors do nowadays and sacrifice imagery for technology.


What did you think of this review?

Fun to Read
Post a Comment
July 22, 2012
I liked this--but I am not sure how necessary it was to remake the amazing original. I do have to say that despite it being inferior to Kobayashi's 1963 classic, it was still a good watch and I appreciated Miike efforts in staying true to the original tale while presenting his own vision. I would say we are in agreement on this one. I reviewed this one too, but I may have to take another look since I was extremely tired when  I wrote it.
July 22, 2012
I haven't seen the original. In fact, prior to seeing this new version, I had never even heard of it. Am I correct in assuming that it never had a U.S. theatrical release date, that American audiences came to know it only from home video viewings and perhaps a few festival screenings?
July 22, 2012
yes, the original was shown in limited engagement to celebrate its anniversary from time to time. You can rent it--I PROMISE you, it will be one of the rewarding watches you may have.
July 22, 2012
That's incorrect; Harakiri was distributed nationwide to U.S. theaters in '64, as was Kaidan the succeeding year; though neither were exhibited in relatively benighted locales or regions dominated by ubiquitous drive-in theaters and their attendant fare, neither feature was an obscurity to filmgoers. Even Samurai Rebellion enjoyed a modest box office take in coastal markets in '67, and while the stateside screenings of The Human Condition trilogy in the early '70s were only intended as limited engagements, MK's humanist saga so appealed to disillusioned students of that era - social democrats, democratic socialists, anti-war proponents of varying creeds, inchoate libertarians, lapsed Objectivists, etc. - that it became a hit of ten California theaters, running four months rather than its scheduled fortnight. Faith, Kobayashi's 1960s output prior to Hymn to a Tired Man unexpectedly turned a fair profit in North America.
July 22, 2012
well I meant during this time, since I want Chris to see it. I couldn't say if it was released here since I wasn't even born yet :) in 2010 they had a special screening of all three Human Condition films in Berkeley. It was so cool!
July 21, 2012
Elsewhere, I've read that this picture's 3D presentation diminishes its photographic contrast. Did it appear so flat? Miike collaborates with numerous DPs, yet even the worst of his flicks are beautiful. That the cinematography of any would be compromised by popular gimmickry is an unfortunate notion...

A quibble and significant objection: the plural form of samurai is samurai; an unwillingness to comprehend Bushido and evaluate jidaigeki and especially chanbara in the context of the Edo aristocracy's creed do not a valid review make. One can overlook your unfamiliarity with Kobayashi's classic, but one venal moral standard castigated by narrative is poorly judged by another...especially in media critique.
July 21, 2012
Okay, but just so you know, you're so far the only one who has complained about such a minor mistake, which is nothing more or less than a typo. I'm only human.
July 21, 2012
Sophistry does not become you. Those errors that I cited (which you revised immediately thereafter) were twofold, and evidently not typographical. If I may produce essays in which I poke fun at my own maladroit prose, I further reserve some prerogative to advise others in observance of mild protocol.

Anyhow, this only concerns the lesser of my two complaints.
July 21, 2012
Good detailed review!
More Hara-Kiri: Death of a Samurai ... reviews
review by . July 21, 2012
posted in ASIANatomy
An Exploration of Revenge, Indivuduality and Honor in the Face of an Oppressive Tradition
Most of my friends and those who have followed my reviews know how rare it is that I award a perfect score to a film be it an American or foreign film. Such an honor means that a film had truly made an impression on me and had given me an experience that I may never forget in cinema. The 1962 Japanese classic directed by Masaki Kobayashi “Seppuku” (aka. Hara-Kiri) is one such film that have earned such honor for me.      When I heard that it was being remade by the …
review by . January 19, 2013
      “Are You Satisfied?”       Takashi Miike.  It’s only two words – a name, actually – but that’s usually all it takes to get some folks’ attention.  That’s because if you’re familiar with the works of Takashi Miike, then you know what kind of a visual treat you have in store for you when you hear he’s releasing yet another film.  I’ve read many reviews that draw comparisons …
Quick Tip by . July 16, 2012
posted in ASIANatomy
After Takashi Miike’s  “13 Assassins”  which was an amazing remake of the 1960’s original, Miike is now poised to make another mark in a new era of chambara and Jidai geki films. Miike’s “Hara-Kiri: Death of a Samurai” is a remake of Masaki Kobayashi’s classic chambara black and white film “Hara-Kiri”.      I am both hopeful and excited, as well as scared to death that Kobayashi’s highly acclaimed, …
About the reviewer
Chris Pandolfi ()
Ranked #5
Growing up a shy kid in a quiet suburb of Los Angeles, Chris Pandolfi knows all about the imagination. Pretend games were always the most fun for him, especially on the school playground; he and his … more
Consider the Source

Use Trust Points to see how much you can rely on this review.

Your ratings:
rate more to improve this
First to Review
© 2015 Lunch.com, LLC All Rights Reserved
Lunch.com - Relevant reviews by real people.
This is you!
Ranked #
Last login
Member since