Movies Books Music Food Tv Shows Technology Politics Video Games Parenting Fashion Green Living more >

Lunch » Tags » Movies » Reviews » Secret Sunshine » User review

Secret Sunshine

Korean award-winning film

< read all 2 reviews

A Harrowing Tale About a Woman who Lost Her Religious Faith...

  • Dec 29, 2008

Lee Chang-Dong is a film professor turned director who is responsible for such acclaimed hits such as the fantastic "Peppermint Candy", the touching "Oasis" and "Green Fish". He has also been appointed as Korea's minister of culture and tourism at one point but has abandoned this post to concentrate on his filmmaking. This director has, on several occasions has managed to silence my voice because of the powerful portrayal of life in his films; it just strikes a chord in me and gets under my skin. "SECRET SUNSHINE" is no different, the film has won numerous awards and was given high praise in Europe and enjoyed a phenomenal reaction in its limited run in the U.S. The film is controversial; and it presents a very bleak view of Religion, Faith and (maybe?) brings up questions about the existence of God.

When her husband passes away after a car accident, Shin-Ae (Jeon Do-Yeon, No Blood No Tears) and her son, Jun relocate down South to her husband's hometown of Miryang. She attempts to settle down by opening a small piano school and yet she finds that she can't fit in this unfamiliar but "very normal" place. Life goes on as she gains piano students with the aid of a car repair shop owner, Kim Jong-Chan (Song Kang-Ho,Thirst) despite the fact that she finds his attentions to be nuisance. Her son, Jun seems to be adapting quite well to their new life but fate intervenes; their lives are turned upside-down when her son becomes a victim of a fatal kidnapping.

Shin-Ae turns to Christianity to relieve her pain and anger, but when something occurs that makes her question her faith, she begins to rebel against God.

          4 ½ +Stars: A Harrowing Tale About a Woman who Lost her Religious Faith


Christianity has made quite an impact in South Korea the past several years. "Secret Sunshine" boldly goes to the lengths of portraying just what Christianity is from one woman's point of view. To some, Christianity is a way of life, to some it is a social affair, to some who have religion because they see themselves as a blessed few--for this woman named Shin-Ae (played by Jeon Do-Yeon) it is the only thing she has left. Shin-Ae's religious faith is the film's central focus and the film's most powerful theme. When things don't turn out the way you wanted it to, does one turn away from God? Lee Chang-Dong presents powerful this moral character study of a woman awakened by her faith that becomes blind obsession, that turns into a frightening rebellion. Life is complex and the belief in God is no different. The film doesn't hold back in what it is trying to say, it criticizes religion itself in a very blistering manner.

The film's structure is very odd; it starts off as a romantic drama, then it becomes a thriller until it goes into overdrive as the female lead descends into her own personal darkness. However, odd it may be, it remains riveting. Its unpredictability is played quite well as it reflects just how unpredictable changes can become in one's life. I can reveal two subtle metaphors in the film's first act and near its climax that Lee Chang-Dong may have wanted to reveal without spoiling the film. It occurs in the film's first act when Shin-Ae was walking around in town soliciting for piano lessons. A small badly-lit boutique owned by a moody owner has a very small clientele. The interior of the store is painted black and before Sin-Ae walks out she advises the owner to paint the place with bright colors. Near the film's climax, the same store appears re-painted and re-decorated in white. I think these two sequences reflect the potential brightness and darkness in one's life; it would be up to the individual as to how one chooses to live his own life. Lee Chang-Dong makes a powerful statement.

                4 ½ +Stars: A Harrowing Tale About a Woman who Lost her Religious Faith

                                      4 ½ +Stars: A Harrowing Tale About a Woman who Lost her Religious Faith

Of course the film's success would have to depend on a very powerful actress and Jeon Do-Yeon does a stellar job as its lead. The actress proves the character's equal in its raw layers of depth. Jeon Do-yeon once again impresses me as she has done in the true-to-life drama, "You are my Sunshine" as a woman stricken with Aids. Her ability to express her character's descent into madness is full of powerful emotion and is so convincing that I felt genuine sympathy for Shin-Ae but at the same I was disturbed by the sequences I was privy to. Song Kang-Ho is a terrific actor and plays the man infatuated by Shin-Ae and would do pretty much almost anything for her. His character represents the goodness in her life that he would try to overcome any obstacle. Of course, the man doesn't lose his credibility as a human being--I was very surprised when he lost his cool in a fit of fury.

"SECRET SUNSHINE" is the type of film that would stay with you even after the end of its end credits. The film has the inert ability to get under one's skin with its powerful theme and motifs that more than likely will cause some to question just what exactly is religion's meaning to them. These controversial questions are brought into bear with strong precision. To some, religion is a way of life, to some a vehicle for comfort and a way to feel "blessed"--for me, the film doesn't question God's existence, (although Shin-Ae does bring this up) it just merely BOLDLY criticizes religion itself. Lee Chang-Dong expresses in a very blistering and riveting manner that one should NOT mistake having a Religion as being parallel or the same as having a strong Faith in God.

Note: This movie is getting a widespread release in the U.S. under the Criterion Collection label.

Korean Movie poster Promo poster 4 ½ +Stars: A Harrowing Tale About a Woman who Lost her Religious Faith scene actress Jeon Do-Yeon multiple time award winner 4 ½ +Stars: A Harrowing Tale About a Woman who Lost her Religious Faith scene 4 ½ +Stars: A Harrowing Tale About a Woman who Lost her Religious Faith 4 ½ +Stars: A Harrowing Tale About a Woman who Lost her Religious Faith 4 ½ +Stars: A Harrowing Tale About a Woman who Lost her Religious Faith

What did you think of this review?

Fun to Read
Post a Comment
August 03, 2011
Excellent review. This sounds like one I would enjoy! Thanks for the recommendation!
August 03, 2011
sweet! I would love to read your review on it that would again, throw my Chi out of alignment LOL!! You are the right person to review this movie too since you have such a way with words and your reviews flow so smoothly. Just keep in mind that Lee usually shoots his movies at a pace different from what we are used to; after all, life doesn't have that much editing....
August 03, 2011
LOL! I know what you mean. And, here, let me fit your Chi back into alignment...ready...one, two, three! There ya go. ;) I'm sending this film recommendation to J right now. :)
August 03, 2011
ouch....now it is my brain that is out of alignment....wait....that is normal for me to have a crooked brain LMAO!
August 03, 2011
LOL!! You are so bad! (slaps you silly)
May 03, 2011
Wonderful review WP
August 03, 2011
It is coming out Criterion too!
January 10, 2010
Sounds good to me! :-) I found Koreans to be great in some thought provoking themes and they have a way to allow you to see the world in new lights through their movies or tv dramas.
January 10, 2010
I agree. I became a fan of Jeon Do-yeon in "You are my Sunshine" and "No Blood No Tears" and I was impressed with Lee Chang-Dong's "Oasis" and "Peppermint Candy"--I watch anything with him as director and her in the lead; which is how I came across this movie.
November 24, 2009
Highest possible rating? Hmm, this definitely must be a keeper if Woo give it the 5 star treatment. I've heard you speak of Peppermint Candy before so I'll have to give these a try sometime. Fantastic work!!!
January 10, 2010
this was real good. Takes a little longer to really pick up, but once it does whoa! the acting was phenomenal.
August 03, 2011
this one is getting a criterion release this month...
August 03, 2011
Whoa! Barnes & Noble is doing a 50% off promo this month too. I just bought the copy of Antichrist. Damn good movie.
August 03, 2011
Heck yeah, man! I got that for $ 13.99 on Bluray on sale when Borders closed. Good thing a lot of people have bad tastes in movies that it didn't sell out quickly. LOL
August 04, 2011
It's only on days like those where I actually am glad people's tastes in the arts are very different from mine. Usually, it doesn't work that way but I'm thankful for the occasions in which it does.
More Secret Sunshine reviews
Quick Tip by . August 03, 2011
posted in ASIANatomy
Finally, after almost 5 years, Lee Chang-Dong’s “Secret Sunshine” is getting a widespread U.S. release and it is being released under the Criterion Collection label. Winner of numerous international awards, this film may be the first Korean movie to be selected by Criterion.             The film portrays the story of a woman who seemingly lost everything, found something and finally lost everything once again. It is a story about faith …
About the reviewer
William ()
Ranked #1
Please "Like" Film and Movies and Keep the Economy strong....LOL!!      My Interests: Movies, Anime, History, Martial Arts, Comics, Entertainment,Cooking, Things I don't … more
Consider the Source

Use Trust Points to see how much you can rely on this review.

Your ratings:
rate more to improve this
About this topic


File:Secret Sunshine.jpg

When her husband passes away after getting into a car accident, Shin-ae (JEON Do-yeon) and her son June relocate down south to her late husband's hometown of Miryang. She attempts to settle down by opening a new piano academy yet she finds that she can't fit in this unfamiliar but ?much too normal place,§. Life goes on as she gains piano students with the help of a car repair shop owner, Kim Jong-chan (SONG Kang-ho) despite she actually finds Kim's enthusiasm a nuisance. Meanwhile, June seems to be adapting new school life. Unfortunately, Shin-ae's life is turned upside down when fate intervenes that she loses her son in a fatal kidnap. -Hkflix.com
view wiki


© 2015 Lunch.com, LLC All Rights Reserved
Lunch.com - Relevant reviews by real people.
This is you!
Ranked #
Last login
Member since