Movies Books Music Food Tv Shows Technology Politics Video Games Parenting Fashion Green Living more >

Lunch » Tags » Movies » Reviews » 3:10 to Yuma » User review

3:10 to Yuma

A 2007 movie starring Russell Crowe

< read all 12 reviews

Ultimately contrived as a western, but still an excellent film

  • Jan 10, 2009
This remake has little in common with the 1957 Glenn Ford classic of the same name.

The basic story is identical: Dan Evans (Christian Bale) is a hardscrabble rancher, down on his luck, trying to make a go of his dusty, drought-ridden ranch. He has borrowed from Hollander who wants Evans off the land so the railroad will buy it. (This doesn't make a lot of sense since the railroads were awash in federal land given to them.) Hollander has cut off Evans' water and Evans is desperate. Evans has but one leg, the other lost in the Civil War and a 14 year old son, William (Logan Lerman) who doesn't respect him.

Ben Wade (Russell Crowe) is a bandit and a killer, a totally cold-blooded killer. Assisted by his second-in-command Charlie Prince (brilliantly played by Ben Foster), Wade's gang pulls off a daring, bloody robbery of a stagecoach carrying a big payroll.

Evans happens to become briefly involved. Although we've just seen Wade and his gang shoot down bunch of people, they let Evans and his two sons go. This is our first hint of Wade's humanity.

The gang goes to the nearby town of Bisbee. Evans goes there looking for Hollander and instead finds humiliation - and Wade. Wade is captured and Evans accepts the offer of a $200 reward for getting Wade to prison.

Now begins the cat-and-mouse game between captive and captors. Wade is intelligent, charming and disturbingly alternates between psychopathic violence and saving the day for those of his captors he doesn't kill. It's really strange.

Ultimately it comes down to the down-to-earth integrity of Evans and the blandishments offerd by the wilely Wade.

The story is far from the simplicity of the largely this-is-good, this-is-bad line of the original. In fact, on occasion, the storyline strikes very discordant tones and feels more like a contemporary Los Angeles streets story.

Overall, there is little of the classic Western genre in this film, save men riding horses and shooting guns. There is none of of the nobility John Ford invested his Westerns with or the balletic nihilist violence of Sam Peckinpah. This is a strained morality tale with Western trappings.

It is, however, an excellent film. Crowe and Bale deliver standout performances. Ben Foster as Wade's obediant, murderous subordinate is chilling. Even Peter Fond turns in a good performance as the old bounty hunter who has been after Wade for decades.

So approach this remake without consideration of the original and you'll probably greatly enjoy it. If, on the other hand, you are looking for faithful adherence to the original, you won't find it here.


What did you think of this review?

Fun to Read
Post a Comment
November 19, 2010
This was a great movie, Ben Foster was excellent.
More 3:10 to Yuma reviews
Quick Tip by . June 28, 2011
This adequate remake of Delmer Daves' superb western substitutes Russell Crowe and Christian Bale for Glenn Ford and Van Heflin nearly fifty years after the release of the original. It could be said that these famous leads are underutilized in their respective roles; Crowe is persistently capable, Bale seemingly capable of anything and this movie is fairly undemanding in comparison to the usual rigor of their work. Even more than its predecessor, this movie's plot bears as many clever twists …
review by . October 14, 2009
Let me begin this review by stating that I have never seen the original 3:10 to Yuma, and that I am not a fan of Western movies. Having said that, I liked this movie, and thought it was one of the best movies of the year. Starring two great actors, and a host of smaller-name actors and actresses, this movie is part action, part drama, with a little bit of comedy and romance thrown in. The gun fight scenes are great, and very realistic. The storyline itself is very good with original characters. …
review by . August 29, 2008
Now I will admit something right of the bat before I get into my review. I have only recently seen this movie and turned down a number of opportunities to watch this film simply because it is a western. I will now hold my hands up and say how wrong I was and after seeing the light I have to say, this has now taken over Pulp Fiction as my favourite movie EVER!!! From start to finish this film grabs hold of you and gives you a damn good shaking. The biggest point of this film is the general authenticity …
review by . January 29, 2008
Ok, so I'm certainly not much of a fan when it comes to westerns but 3:10 to Yuma gets me in the mood for them. This feels like Russell Crowe's best film since Gladiator and Christen Bales best film ever. In the beginning the movie starts with a blazing fire. Even though it starts off with such an exciting scene I started to doubt it for some reason. Christen Bale plays Dan Evans who is a hardworking rancher and former soldier trying to take care of his family. The problem is his land is in a drought …
review by . January 18, 2008
posted in Movie Hype
Yes, it's a western, a remake, and yes, it's bloody and yes it's so terrific you will want to watch it again right after having finished it the first time.    Perfect acting by everyone. Russell Crowe is given the chance to show his amazing talent, to really dig into it. Christian Bale is marvellous as a father trying to make up for lost chances, finally doing it right.   But to me what struck me most, is the amazing talent of Logan Lerman who plays C. Bale's son. I …
review by . May 16, 2008
With his family on the brink of losing everything, Dan Evans (Christian Bale) agrees to help the Southern Pacific Railroad bring a wicked villain, Ben Wade (Russell Crowe), to justice. Justice happens to be at the train station in Contention, where Wade is expected to hitch a ride on the 3:10 to Yuma and imprisonment. The only things stopping Evans and his allies from making it to Contention is Wade himself and his vicious gang, headed up by the overprotective and violent Charlie Prince (Ben Foster). …
review by . January 09, 2008
posted in Movie Hype
If there is a truly unique American contribution to film making then that contribution has to be the Western. Though not as popular a theme these days as it was in past decades, it only takes a powerhouse film such as 3:10 TO YUMA to remind us just how pungent storytelling of this type can be. Yes, the story itself (based on a short story by Elmore Leonard) is rather simple: desperate farmer needs money to save his failing farm and family and signs on to escort a powerful outlaw to the train that …
review by . January 27, 2008
With all the positive reviews for this film, I was expecting a lot better. Christian Bayle is a cattle rancher who witnesses a group of bandits robbing a bank coach. The lead robber (Russell Crowe) lets him go, however Bayle ends up joining a group of lawmen that are after the bandits for over 20 robberies.    There is a lot of cat and mouse between Crowe and Bayle and by the end they have developed a relationship that reminded me of Crowe and Denzel Washington in American Gangster. …
review by . January 12, 2008
The comparison is old but appropriate: The samurai flick and the western are first cousins. There's the cool hero, defined by his actions, but almost completely without essence. There's a sense of honor and dangerously violent threats to life and limb. Courage, honor and loyalty defend themselves and we are left to identify with them and share their triumph. It's all good, clean fun and the transfer between samurai and cowboy works so well that The Magnificent Seven didn't even bother to adapt the …
review by . January 09, 2008
I am not a fan of Westerns. I generally find them trite, cliche and silly. In fact, there was a time I would've said I hated Westerns, as well as Romantic Comedies and Musicals. Over time, however, I've learned that what I hate are bad movies, and while many Westerns are, this one is not.    This movie is often, and rightly, compared favorably to Clint Eastwood's amazing film Unforgiven (Two-Disc Special Edition). Like that film, "3:10 to Yuma" elevates itself beyond the standard …
About the reviewer
Jerry Saperstein ()
Ranked #194
I am an e-discovery strategist, computer forensics specialist and testifying expert witness - and an avid reader.      Aside from technology books, I love thrillers, suspense, mystery, … more
Consider the Source

Use Trust Points to see how much you can rely on this review.

Your ratings:
rate more to improve this
About this movie


Here's hoping James Mangold's big, raucous, and ultrabloody remake of 3:10 to Yuma leads some moviegoers to check out Delmer Daves's beautifully lean, half-century-old original. That classic Western spun a tale of captured outlaw Ben Wade (Glenn Ford)--deadly but disarmingly affable--and the small-time rancher and family man, Dan Evans (Van Heflin), desperate enough to accept the job of helping escort the badman to Yuma prison. Wade, knowing that his gang will be along at any moment to spring him, works at persuading the ultimately lone deputy to accept a bribe, turn his back on "duty," and go home safe and rich to his family. That the outlaw has come to admire his captor intriguingly complicates the suspense. All of the above applies in the new 3:10, but it takes a lot more huffing and puffing to get Wade (Russell Crowe this time) and Evans (Christian Bale) into position for the showdown. Mostly, more is less. To Mangold's credit, his movie doesn't traffic in facile irony or postmodern detachment; it aims to be a straight-up Western and deliver the excitement and charisma the genre's fans are starved for. But recognizing that contemporary viewers might be out of touch with the bedrock simplicity and strength of the genre--not to mention its code of honor--Mangold has supplied both Evans and Wade with a plethora of backstory and "motivations." At the overblown action climax, the crossfire of personal agendas is almost as frenetic ...
view wiki
© 2015 Lunch.com, LLC All Rights Reserved
Lunch.com - Relevant reviews by real people.
This is you!
Ranked #
Last login
Member since