|
Movies Books Music Food Tv Shows Technology Politics Video Games Parenting Fashion Green Living more >

Lunch » Tags » Movies » Reviews » A.I.: Artificial Intelligence » User review

What is Being Human?

  • Jul 2, 2001
Rating:
-1
Pros: Good idea and FX

Cons: Long with large plot holes.

The Bottom Line: Great idea, but plot holes ruined what could have been a classic.

Plot Details: This opinion reveals minor details about the movie's plot.

Ever since the first days of civilization, mankind has had to ponder the meaning of life. Centuries later and still no closer to an answer, humankind has seen society evolve into an existence where machines are commonplace and to many necessary part of everyday life. As machines become more and more of our lives and as machines perform duties that were traditionally done by beings of flesh and blood, the question arises, what does being human/alive mean?
Many films over the years have tried to answer this, ranging from “2001” to “Bicentennial Man” and “Blade Runner”. While they can discuss human qualities ranging from emotions, intellectual growth, capacity to learn, and creation, none has been ever able to illustrate why humankind is more than just a sum of our parts.
The late Stanley Kubrick started our cinematic look at the humanization of machines with “2001”, as the supercomputer Hal, was a warning at the dangers of dependence on technology as Hal suffered from the same issues that can hinder human beings. Namely fear, jealousy, and not always making the correct decisions.
With the untimely passing of Kubrick, his pet project, “A.I” never made it to the screen. Kubrik had
long discussed his take on the story Super-Toys Last All Summer" by Brian Aldiss with his good friend Steven Spielberg. Kubrick had shown his storyboards and outline to Speilberg, soupcon Kubrik’s passing, Spielberg took it upon himself to write and film his friends, project as a tribute to the legendary filmmaker.
“AI” is set in the Earth of the future where the Polar Ice caps have melted flooding a good portion of the planet. While the technology of society is far advanced, the supply of natural resources are limited so human reproduction is strictly controlled, and only couples with a license are allowed to have a child.
This has created a need for children amongst many childless couples, and a robotics creator, Professor Hobby, (William Hurt) proposes the creation of a robotic child, or Mecca, who can love and in turn be loved as a substitute for the organic children many couples are not allowed to have.
Since adult robots have long been used for everything in society, it is determined that a test family is needed for the new child robot, and a young couple, the Swintons, are selected to test the prototype. The Swintons have a natural child, but he is in cryogenic stasis with an incurable disease making the distraught couple an ideal choice, as they have need for a child, and know how to care for a child. At first the wife Monica, is horrified at the idea of replacing their child with a machine but soon warms to the child robot David, (Haley Joel Osment) After accepting David, Monica activates his imprinting program allowing him to bond with the family, knowing that once this is done, David will always be imprinted upon the family, and should he not remain with them, he will have to be destroyed.
Soon after the imprinting, the Swintons receive word that their natural son, Martin, has been cured, and will be able to return to the family. This brings great joy to the family, but soon after Martins return, the family starts to see David as more of an accessory then as a child, start to ignore him. Martins tormenting of David further complicate matters as he tells David that he is nothing more than a doll.
Matters arise that force the Swintons to return David to be destroyed, but Monica has a change of heart and leaves David in the woods, with only his robotic teddy bear and instructions to avoid humans and seek his own kind.
It is at this point that “AI” becomes lost much as young David is. David wanders the woods looking for the Blue Fairy from Pinocchio, as he is convinced she can make him a real boy and he can return to his family. Along the way David meets a Pleasure model named Gigolo Joe played by Jude Law. Joe is on the run as he has been framed for a murder committed by a jealous lover and has to seek others of his own kind for survival Joe becomes a mentor for David and they set off to find the Blue Fairy while Joe informs David about the Humans as they like us, always quest to discover and understand their creators.
A Flesh Fair soon captures David and Joe where robots are destroyed for entertainment by people who see their kind as an abomination to humanity. Though Joe and David escape, the path they continue on is uncertain as they wander to a futuristic city to continue their quest.
The biggest problem with “Ai” is that while it is a visual marvel at times, it is a long (2 Hrs 20 Minutes) movie that has a very slow pace. The ending of the film was very unsatisfying as few of the questions the film presented were ever answered and the reliance upon the fairly tale myth of Pinocchio sometimes takes on absurd proportions as the quest of the two robots has some serious inconsistencies in logic on continuity. At one point near the end, David meets up with his creator, only to have him excuse himself from the room for a moment never to return. It is almost as if the good Professor dropped off the edge of the world.
Towards the end of the film, “AI” reflected heavily on some of Kubrik’s more dark visions of humanity and there was some very unsettling things, I found the resolution of the films ending to be very unsatisfying as there are options open to us today that I am sure a society with highly advanced technology would have easily been able to reproduce.
I must say that in all my years of doing reviews, “AI” is the hardest film I have ever had to review. On one hand, it is a well made film with a fantastic performance from Osment and great special effects. On the other hand, it is a long, slow paced, film that leaves one disturbed and unsatisfied at the end. and leaves more questions than it answers.
I would have liked to have seen the film view Humanity from the eyes of an outsider, rather than simply retell the tale of Pinocchio in the form of a high-tech fairly tale. After the first hour of the film, story and logic were replaced with flashy visuals that seemed to be noting more than eye candy and did little to advance the story or character development. Characters enter the story and were often never seen again with no explanations, and while the film is ambitious, it never seems to come close to reaching the potential it held and becomes a film that is dark and disturbing but never bothering to show the viewers the steps that led to key events in the film, and in many ways takes the easy way out for many scenes rather than expanding them to their natural and logical sequences and conclusions. I also want to make a note that due to some disturbing and intense images and scenes, this film is not suitable for children.
2.5 stars out of 5.
Gareth Von Kallenbach

Gareth@nwlink.com



,


Recommended:
No

Suitability For Children: Suitable for Children Age 13 and Older

What did you think of this review?

Helpful
3
Thought-Provoking
3
Fun to Read
3
Well-Organized
3
Post a Comment
More A.I.: Artificial Intelligence reviews
review by . August 10, 2009
posted in Movie Hype
The Blue Fairy... nothing artificial about it!
Haley Joel Osment is one great child actor. It is in this movie and some other movies like Pay It Forward and the Sixth Sense that he demonstrated his talent fully.       I like this A.I. - Artificial Intelligence best!    Screenplay: Steven Spielberg. Director: Steven Spielberg.   What's there not to like? :-)      The main theme?    Love of a child, a robot child. Can the human love a robot child like …
Quick Tip by . March 11, 2012
posted in Movie Hype
Caption
I'm man enough to admit that I cried like a girl (Not trying to be chauvinistic here) during the last part of this movie. It was so bloody sad. Literally a 22nd Century Pinocchio Story Involving a Robotic Child named David who wants to be real human boy.  As I said before the ending of the movie about the last 30 minutes are heart wrenching. Even remembering it now makes me wanna tear up.      Look I watched Titanic and thought I was boring (no offense to the people …
Quick Tip by . December 13, 2009
The intelligence may be artificial but the love for a mother is not! A most thought provoking movie beautifully crafted by Spielberg.
review by . May 08, 2009
This Pinnocchio-like tale was highly enjoyable throughout but started to go downhill towards the end. The actor that plays the boy is extremely talented and you really feel for him when he can't get the same affection as his "human" brother. His search for affection has some dangerous consequences and leads his parents to abandon him in a very heart-wrenching scene. He later meets and befriends a robot "gigalo" (Jude Law) who tries to help him to attain his mother's …
review by . December 06, 2005
posted in Movie Hype
This film was started by Stanley Kubrick (2001: A Space Oddysey) but finished by Stephen Spielberg (E.T., War of the Worlds).    A modern Pinocchio-like story, Haley Joel Osment plays an artificial intelligence that is "programmed" to love the Mother who buys him and speaks a specific activation code. However, his adoptive family rejects him, leaving him yearning for love and looking for the "blue fairy" for his answers--and a reunion with his beloved Mother.     Osment's …
review by . February 19, 2004
This Pinnocchio-like tale was highly enjoyable throughout but started to go downhill towards the end. The actor that plays the boy is extremely talented and you really feel for him when he can't get the same affection as his "human" brother. His search for affection has some dangerous consequences and leads his parents to abandon him in a very heart-wrenching scene.He later meets and befriends a robot "gigalo" who tries to help him to attain his mother's affection. They believe in the Pinnocchio …
About the reviewer
Gareth Von Kallenbach ()
Ranked #112
I am a syndicated movie & game critic, writer, author and frequent radio guest. My work has appeared in over 60 publications worldwide and he is the creator of the rising entertainment site "Skewed … more
Consider the Source

Use Trust Points to see how much you can rely on this review.

You
garethvk
Your ratings:
rate more to improve this
About this movie

Wiki

A.I. Artificial Intelligence, also known as Artificial Intelligence: A.I. or simply A.I., is a 2001 science fiction film directed, produced and co-written by Steven Spielberg. Based on Brian Aldiss's short story Super-Toys Last All Summer Long, the film stars Haley Joel Osment, Frances O'Connor, Jude Law, Sam Robards, Jake Thomas and William Hurt. Set sometime in the future, A.I. tells the story of David, a child-like android programmed with the unique ability to love.

Development of A.I. originally began with Stanley Kubrick in the early 1970s. Kubrick hired a series of writers up until the mid-1990s, including Brian Aldiss, Bob Shaw, Ian Watson and Sara Maitland. The film languished in development hell for years because Kubrick felt computer-generated imagery was not advanced enough to create the David character, whom he believed no child actor would believably portray. In 1995 Kubrick handed A.I. to Steven Spielberg, but the film did not gain momentum until the death of Kubrick in 1999. Spielberg remained close to Watson's film treatment for the screenplay, and replicated Kubrick's secretive style of filmmaking. A.I. was greeted with mostly positive reviews from critics and became a moderate financial success. This film was dedicated to Kubrick's memory with a ...
view wiki
First to Review
© 2014 Lunch.com, LLC All Rights Reserved
Lunch.com - Relevant reviews by real people.
()
This is you!
Ranked #
Last login
Member since
reviews
comments
ratings
questions
compliments
lists