Movies Books Music Food Tv Shows Technology Politics Video Games Parenting Fashion Green Living more >

Lunch » Tags » Movies » Reviews » Amelia » User review

A Free Spirit Viewed So Casually

  • Nov 14, 2009
  • by

Title: Amelia
Director: Mira Nair
Staring: Hilary Swank, Richard Gere
Aspect Ratio: 2.35:1
Studio: Fox Searchlight Pictures
Genre(s): Drama





(For some sensuality, language, thematic elements and smoking)  

Buy From Amazon.com: Soundtrack / Poster

The life of Amelia Earhart was one of liveliness and mystery. She was the first woman to fly the Atlantic seas, and then mysteriously disappeared never to be seen again. I’ve always been fascinated by this person. She seemed carefree and lived life to it’s fullest. When she married her husband she did so only under the condition that if he didn’t satisfy her within a year she was free to leave him. Some would call him nuts to marry under those terms but hey, if that woman was Amelia maybe I’d make a similar sacrifices myself. The new film “Amelia” is brought to us by Mira Nair who tries her hardest to make this movie work. It has wonderful actors. Hilary Swank and Richard Gere seem like perfect casting choices to play the lead roles (though a supporting role by Ewan McGregor seems more for publicity).

I personally don’t think Swank is much of an actress. Having seen her in good and bad films, I’ve come to the conclusion she can be great when the script is right but she herself can not bring something to the script. This movie does not change my mind about her, but her acting does stand out in a movie that does not. The cinematography is beautiful and sweeping. I had to think back to Martin Scoresese’s underrated “The Aviator” to recall a more recent film that captured the wonder of flight and aviation so well. Clearly this was a film made from love, but I sense the studio may have gotten too involved in the making of it. I sense that a studio executive read the script, saw some of the early work, and saw Oscars in the films future, and had it retooled to encompass that vision.

Of course I’m being skeptical because I have no idea how many changes (if any) were forced on the film, but for something that looks this good it should feel more special then it does. Amelia Earhart (Swank) is not portrayed as a woman with a free spirit, but rather a feminist who has a point to prove. When she talks about how she loves the feeling of being free when she flies it all feels phoney and by-the-numbers. The film makers have to cut to a clip of a young girl looking into the sky stupidly, as if they are admitting that Swank’s speech is not terribly convincing on it’s own. When Amelia has a brief affair with aviation pioneer Gene Vidal (McGregor) it feels...passionless.

Like the characters looked at each other, saw they were both pretty, and decided there was some rule that stipulated that they just HAD to get in bed together! The only time Amelia seems truly happy is during brief moments with her patient husband George (Gere), which shows just how “free spirited” she really is in this movie. The movie does have an exciting climax where Amelia and her navigator search in vain for the island they need to land on, and simply disappear never to be seen or heard from again. This all sounds nice on paper and there are moments, but the drama and heart seem flat and lifeless. Swank will likely grab a third Oscar nomination considering the weak competition in the Best Actress category, but I feel the film is harmless but instantly forgettable.

Follow Kevin T. Rodriguez on Facebook, Twitter, MySpace, or one of his websites: The Comic Book Guy.com, The Movie Wizard.com, and Kevin's Stash.

What did you think of this review?

Fun to Read
Post a Comment
More Amelia reviews
review by . May 24, 2010
   I was very disappointed with this film.  It had a good cast (Swank and Gere) and I generally like these biopics (ex. The Aviator with Leonardo DiCapprio).  I found most of this movie incredibly boring and very little insight was presented about Amelia the person.  Yes, she has a strange relationship with her promoter/husband and an even stranger one with a married flying instructor (Ian McGregor) and we do briefly see her fascination with flying (about 30 seconds) …
Quick Tip by . June 01, 2010
posted in Movie Hype
wasted opportunity to tell a great story. be prepared to be bored an thoroughly uninspired.
review by . November 01, 2009
  In the 1930s, Amelia Earhart was a pioneering woman pilot. She married a man who helped promote her flights. She went missing on the last leg of a round-the-world flight in 1937.       That's all I got from the movie, which is shockingly bad and instantly forgettable. Earhart was a national figure followed by millions, yet you'd never know why from this tepid film. While Hilary Swank seems likeable as Amelia and does bear a striking resemblance to her, the script fails …
review by . December 30, 2009
A good look into the life of Amelia Earhart....
I've seen Biopic's on allot of famous and infamous  people of the 20th century, Public Enemies(John Dillinger), Aviator(Howard Hughes), Schindler's List(Oskar Schindler), Iron jawed Angel(Alice Paul). But this film, this film has to take the  cake as one of the best I've seen  yet.             Mira Nair's "Amelia" is a breathtaking  and exploitative look into the life and achievement's of one of the greatest women of the 20th …
Quick Tip by . January 28, 2010
Gd movie! I thoroughly enjoyed it mostly due to my love for flying. Gere did good here too. Feel very sad to be lost & never found though.
About the reviewer
Kevin T. Rodriguez ()
Ranked #126
Kevin T. Rodriguez is an aspiring film journalist. He's more comfortable typing a review then doing an on-camera appearance, but he loves doing the occasional rant. Whether it be on movies, eBay, or comics, … more
Consider the Source

Use Trust Points to see how much you can rely on this review.

Your ratings:
rate more to improve this
About this movie


Amelia is a 2009 dramatized biographical film of the life of Amelia Earhart, starring Hilary Swank as Earhart along with a cast that includesRichard Gere, Christopher Eccleston[2] and Ewan McGregor. It is directed by Mira Nair based on a script initially written by Ronald Bass. The screenplay was largely based on research utilizing authoritative sources such as East to the Dawn by Susan Butler and The Sound of Wings by Mary S. Lovell. To date, the film has garnered predominately negative reviews. 
view wiki


Director: Mira Nair
Genre: Drama
MPAA Rating: PG
Studio: 20th Century Fox
First to Review

© 2014 Lunch.com, LLC All Rights Reserved
Lunch.com - Relevant reviews by real people.
This is you!
Ranked #
Last login
Member since