|
Movies Books Music Food Tv Shows Technology Politics Video Games Parenting Fashion Green Living more >

Lunch » Tags » Movies » Reviews » City of Life and Death » User review

City of Life and Death

A movie directed by Chuan Lu

< read all 2 reviews

A Powerful Achievement In Chinese Cinema!

  • Mar 25, 2010
Rating:
+5

Many of us have some knowledge of the Sino-Japanese war; and many are the films that have portrayed what happened during that period. “CITY OF LIFE AND DEATH” (2009) is director Lu Chuan’s attempt in portraying the massacre in Nanking (rape of Nanking), a period that occurred between 1937 and 1938 when the Imperial Japanese army have occupied China’s capital committing atrocities against defenseless Chinese P.O.W.s such as murder, mutilation, looting and rape. The incident is truly one of the most emotional issues between China and Japan that it would be easy to assume that a Chinese-made film that portrayed the events would have strong anti-Japanese sentiments.
 
However, Lu Chuan does something quite surprising and impressive; as the director, he has managed to bring forth a certain balance by offering different viewpoints in this harrowing event during the Sino-Japanese war. His work is well-balanced and quite frankly, “City of Life and Death” has a strong sentiment of humanity in its screenplay with the way it lets the film’s themes and characters speak for themselves. “City of Life and Death” comes real close to the harrowing portrayals depicted in “Schindler’s List”. 

      
 
December 1937, when the Imperial Japanese army has conquered the capital of Nanking while pockets of resistance fighters made of Chinese soldiers (some under the age of 15) are trying to fight back. A band lead by a Chinese soldier (Liu Ye) confronts a Japanese battalion with a young soldier Kadokawa (Hideo Nakaizumi) caught in the ensuing melee. The outcome of the battle was never in doubt, given that the Chinese is undermanned and undersupplied. The Chinese soldiers are overpowered, captured and executed in the most inhumane ways. After the executions, a safety zone is established by a Nazi businessman named Rabe ( played by John Paisley, called “China‘s Oscar Schindler“) by safeguarding as many Chinese citizens as he can. However, he isn‘t a successful savior as Schindler, as Rabe was being pushed around by the Japanese when their needs require it. What follows are events so harrowing that almost made me turn away…
 
Shot in black and white, director Lu Chuan presents an atmosphere that can make the viewer wonder if the sequences are news reels or they are just being ‘sensationalized’. I applaud the black and white approach as it gives the movie a sense of authenticity as it goes on to depict each harrowing event after the next, from the battle in the opening act, to the massacre of Chinese soldiers by burning them alive, mutilating their bodies and burying them alive in mass graves, shooting them with machine guns and finally to the actual occupation of Nanking. The battle sequences are pretty intense and realistic; I was real impressed with the manner it took the viewer in the heat of combat. You could really feel that both sides are actually in real danger. War is hell, and while the horrors of war are indeed in full exposition during the battles, the horrors are just beginning for those who lost.

 
 
After the execution of the Chinese soldiers and refugee camps were established, this is where the film lets the characters take over the film’s script. The direction tosses about loads of sympathy around to enhance the cinematic experience. You see the Japanese and the Chinese as both the victims, heroes and the perpetrators; as Mr. Tang (Fan Wei) is a Chinese man who would sacrifice anything, his soul, his countrymen and women to save his family, we see a stubborn, beautiful woman (Jiang Yiyan) filled with pride who is shattered when she is raped by the Japanese. Then she becomes a hero as she sacrifices herself to become a ‘comfort woman’ for the Japanese in exchange for food, warmth and shelter for the other Chinese people. An officer (Kohata Ryu) relishes the atrocities they commit but develops a liking for several Chinese people. Kadokawa is a soldier who becomes smitten by a Japanese comfort woman, while he does his “soldiering”, he never sexually abuses a woman. Lu Chuan’s direction puts the characters in situations that effectively depicts the evils of human behavior; but no matter from which angle you look at things, the film maintains its humanity while painting very strong anti-war sentiments.
 
The direction has several harrowing and unnerving sequences that bring the characters and situations to their requital. The fate of the Chinese soldiers are truly wrenching and unnerving as well as the fates of the “comfort women”; whether they be  Korean, Japanese and Chinese, the women are all victims of their fate, but they did have their moments of heroism despite their sad fates. The film has several scenes of graphic nudity and rape that were very difficult to watch. There were also a few sequences when Ms. Jiang (Jiang Shuyun) was trying to save as many surviving Chinese soldiers as she could and Lu as he marched to his final execution. Both scenes depict the act of nobility and final defiance. These scenes are certain key moments in the film that truly depicted courage, defiance and heroism.
 
I guess if the movie had a flaw, it would be that the film was a little too balanced that it felt quite constructed. It trades in plot complexities to maintain a balance. Kadokawa becomes a sympathetic character as the direction uses him as a situational template; a soldier caught in the middle of the extreme situation given little choice but to do nothing. This story arc is relevant and yet it is only proven as something that is needed for the theme and not for the characters’ development. Some scenes should’ve have been more disturbing than Lu Chuan portrays them; kids being buried alive and mutilated weren’t totally brought into bear. While Lu Chuan went the distance, he didn’t seal the deal and leaves some room for another director to really define the events in “Nanking”.
 
True, “City of Life and Death” may not be perfect but it is pretty close in becoming the definitive film based on the harrowing events during the rape of Nanking. The film has awesome cinematography and style, the acting is stellar and the plot is well-developed. The direction knew what it was aiming for and the themes were effective enough in portraying the harrowing effects of war. Lu Chuan’s “City of Life and Death” was heavily criticized for portraying the Japanese as not being “evil enough” while some has said that he made the Japanese too ruthless and evil. Some people has even said that China is just giving itself the image of a victim given its own lack of respect for human rights. Both countries; China and Japan have both acknowledged their past mistakes and trespasses. People will undoubtedly use this film as a launching pad for criticizing the two countries. But let’s just say that Lu Chuan’s film has to be seen to be believed. This film should be embraced as a one of great achievements in Cinema.
 
Highly Recommended! [5- Out of 5 Stars]



 
 
4 ½ Stars: A Powerful Chinese CINEMATIC Achievement

What did you think of this review?

Helpful
21
Thought-Provoking
21
Fun to Read
21
Well-Organized
21
Post a Comment
April 15, 2010
Wow...this sounds so sad! I can't watch "Schindler's List" without crying. I'm sure this would be one of those films as well. Since I liked "Schindler's," I'm sure I would enjoy this one as well.
April 30, 2010
sniff sniff (boo-hoo) you will love this!
May 01, 2010
LOL! I get too emotional for my own good when it comes to these types of movies. I'll see if I can get a copy sooner rather than later. Then, I will write a review on it for you too. :)
 
April 07, 2010
WP I have to absolutely have to see this, amazing review.
April 08, 2010
Thanks, man. If you liked Schindler's List then this movie is definitely for you.
 
March 31, 2010
When you have created a film where both the victims and the victimizers are complaining I think you've achieved something that is close to the truth. This goes on my list today.
March 31, 2010
I'll see if I can more screeners that I can send out. Have you seen the doco THE RAPE OF NANKING? it is pretty harrowing and depicts this story real well.
March 31, 2010
No. The closest I've come is MEN BEHIND THE SUN. That was pretty hard to take too.
 
March 25, 2010
Looks really good, but the use of black and white seems rather derivative of "Schindler's List", especially considering the time period and the story. Still, I'd like to see it. I like depressing historical films.
March 26, 2010
Not to worry, Sean, its similarities to SL ends with the black and white. The events in Nanking is horrifically very real and yes, depressing movies can be so brilliant, when done with care.
March 26, 2010
I find that tragedy is often the best way to reach an audience that might otherwise be uninterested. Apparently Shakespeare thought so too, since most critics agree that his tragedies are superior ro his comedies in terms of characterization
March 29, 2010
You think Karen will like this film? She has got to see this!
March 31, 2010
If it's availble on NetFlix, it'll be on my list today!
 
March 25, 2010
Wow. Based on our nearly identical movie taste I have already added this film to my queue (the Saved Queue...whatever that means). You description is intriguing. I like films from this period anyway and your description is convincing. If this film is a fraction of Schindler's List I will love it.
March 26, 2010
I love movies from this time period too. I think this movie is indeed for you.
 
March 25, 2010
This sounds very, very intense, but I'm intrigued because 1) It's shot in black and white, 2) I'm interested in Chinese history, or history in general, 3) Those screen shots look stunning, 4) I love the way you described it, and 5) Woopak gave it a +5!
March 26, 2010
Thanks, Lady D! I had a feeling you might actually notice this review. This is indeed intense and comes really close to the depressing themes we've seen in Schindler's List and The Human Condition. This movie was incredibly well executed; after you see it, just be sure you see something real "cute" and fun, like this CUTESY flick LOL I said cute in the review title and you didn't notice? You're losing your touch ;-P
 
1
More City of Life and Death reviews
review by . June 26, 2011
CITY OF LIFE AND DEATH is a masterpiece - of film making, of finding the midline of response to war from both sides, of cautiously but successfully blending intimate stories with the gory atrocities of war, and of recreating a period of history we too soon forget unless prodded by works such as this. Lu Chuan both wrote and directed this vision of the 1937 decimation of Nanking, the capital of China, by the Japanese that lasted in action for only six weeks but that has been a permanent festering …
Quick Tip by . July 05, 2010
posted in ASIANatomy
Unlocks the hidden mystery into Communiust China
About the reviewer
William ()
Ranked #1
Please "Like" Film and Movies and Keep the Economy strong....LOL!!      My Interests: Movies, Anime, History, Martial Arts, Comics, Entertainment,Cooking, Things I don't … more
Consider the Source

Use Trust Points to see how much you can rely on this review.

You
woopak_the_thrill
Your ratings:
rate more to improve this
About this movie

Wiki

City of Life and Death takes place in 1937, during the height of theSecond Sino-Japanese War. The Imperial Japanese Army has just captured the then-capital of the Republic of ChinaNanjing. What followed was known as the Nanking Massacre, a period of several weeks wherein massive numbers of Chinese prisoners of war and civilians were killed.
 
The film tells the story of several figures, both historical and fictional, including a Chinese soldier, a schoolteacher, a Japanese soldier, a foreign missionary, and John Rabe, a Nazi businessman who would ultimately save thousands of Chinese civilians.

File:CityofLifeandDeath.jpg
view wiki

Details

Director: Chuan Lu
Genre: Drama, History, War
Release Date: 22 April 2009 (China)
Screen Writer: Chuan Lu
Runtime: Hong Kong: 132 min
First to Review
© 2014 Lunch.com, LLC All Rights Reserved
Lunch.com - Relevant reviews by real people.
()
This is you!
Ranked #
Last login
Member since
reviews
comments
ratings
questions
compliments
lists