Movies Books Music Food Tv Shows Technology Politics Video Games Parenting Fashion Green Living more >

Lunch » Tags » Movies » Reviews » Hostel Part II » User review

Hostel Part II

A movie directed by Eli Roth

< read all 4 reviews

Disgustingly exploitative step down from the respectable original.

  • Feb 13, 2012
* out of ****

"Hostel: Part II" is the answer to the question of what's wrong with the horror genre as of late. In a nearly artless 95 minutes of feminine-exclusive exploitation; director Eli Roth does nothing more than demonstrate that he is skilled in the process of staging a kill scene. I've read up on Roth and I'm an admirer of both his persona as a human being (his activism with the PETA is nice) and as a filmmaker. I enjoyed "Cabin Fever" and to an extent, the first "Hostel"; but here, he's only hurting himself. For 95 minutes, we get to watch as Roth indulges in the exploitation of violence against women; it wouldn't be surprising if he enjoyed himself in the making of this sick, insultingly brainless genre offering.

Sometimes, the film isn't shocking; but at the same time, there are moments that cross the line; and at that, I draw a considerably tame one. I can appreciate what people categorize as "extreme horror films", but they've got to have some substance, and that's something that "Hostel: Part II" lacks nigh completely. It's the kind of genre bastardization that was most likely conceived from the requests and cries of horror fanatics everywhere; we want something fearless and bold. Roth intends to give us just that.

The only way to expand on the basic premise of "Hostel" - which concerned a murder-for-profit business exclusive to Slovakia - is to focus on an entirely different, new group of people. Instead of three men; there are three women, and then another - native to the region - who joins and leads them to the hostel from the first movie. By night; they tour the local festivities and try to have a good time, but it is that night on which the horror that lurks in the shadows of the area shall reveal itself.

Another twist to the story is a thoroughly satirical tone; but only when specific characters are around. In this case, there are two clients who come from America to do business with the underground Slovakian killers; their names are Stuart (Roger Bart) and Todd (Richard Burgi). Roth intends for their on-screen presence to be funny because they are inexperienced in the trade of murder; too bad I didn't laugh. I've got a sick sense of humor; but I guess it's not sick enough.

The characters are stupid. We don't care about any one of them. There's one girl in the group by the name of Lorna ("Welcome to the Dollhouse" starlet Heather Matarazzo) who provides the film with some much-needed comic relief that, for the most part, actually works; even if it never comes close to saving this sorry film's skin. I might have cared about the movie had anyone else been this entertaining; but no, they're absolutely paper-thin. To make matters worse, Roth provides yet another racist, unintelligent view on Slovakia, the people, and their culture. It's as if he's yet to even meet a member of the nation.

Alas, "Hostel: Part II" is not unwatchable because it is excessive and sadistic (and it is); but rather because it's just so darn bad. Knowing the horror aspect of the story, we go in knowing just a tad too much; and any suspense deteriorates before it even makes an attempt to get going. On top of that, the lighting is pretty bad throughout; with only Roth's stylistic cinematography and impressive gore effects lending a helping hand. I was able to take the film for the most part, although I was still a bit unwise to approach the film. I was warned of graphic castration (which was unexpectedly shown completely on-screen) and women taking a circular saw to the face; although I was unaware of how intensely these two things (and others) were going to be depicted. In terms of being sick, depraved, and irredeemable; this is certainly a big step up from the original film.

There was one scene that I really liked. One scene where Roth displayed some welcome hints of pure artistry in an otherwise wannabe-artsy piece of exploitative shit. The scene which I speak of is the one in which "Cannibal Holocaust" director Ruggero Deodato makes an appearance as a cannibal who presumably feeds off the scraps of the torture victims as well as fresh meet that he gets ahold of himself. Given the filmmaker's background as well as his on-screen actions; there's a certain artistry to the scene that I just wish the entire film had achieved. Sadly, this isn't the case; and this horror sequel is left bleeding to death, with only the most faithful and easily pleased genre fans cleaning up the big old mess of liquid red.

What did you think of this review?

Fun to Read
Post a Comment
More Hostel Part II reviews
review by . May 12, 2009
posted in Movie Hype
Hostility On The Screen
For those of you who loved the original, I think Hostel 2 is a worthy sequel. If you are like me & weren't particularly crazy about the first one, you might still enjoy it. I waited for DVD on this one & actually watched it twice on the same day.      I don't know where to begin on this one. For so many different reasons, Hostel 2 was a vast improvement over the first & I could easily watch it again. Roth had a great premise the first time around but really delivered …
review by . May 14, 2009
Hostel Part II Poster
There are horror movies and then there are movies that are there not to scare you, but to severely gross you out and show as much blood and gore as possible.  These are movies like the Saw films (which I loath) or any of the other "horror" films that have been coming out today, but the Hostel films, helmed by Eli Roth do more than that.  Both of Roths films have had a plot (for the most part) and that plot continues into the next film.    I really enjoyed the fact that …
review by . October 31, 2008
Hostel Part II
Hostel II is a decent horror flick, but can't quite hold up to its predecessor, the first Hostel movie. In Hostel we followed male college students, in Hostel II we follow some female students who are led astray by female model, promising them the vacation of their lives. After a strange run in on a train, they are invited to a big party where one of their numbers immediately goes missing. Searching for their missing companion, the rest fall into terrible peril at the hands of the men who have paid …
About the reviewer
Ryan J. Marshall ()
Ranked #11
It's very likely that the only kind of reviews I'll ever post here are movie reviews. I'm very passionate about film; and at this point, it pretty much controls my life. Film gives us a purpose; … more
Consider the Source

Use Trust Points to see how much you can rely on this review.

Your ratings:
rate more to improve this
About this movie


Starring Lauren German, Roger Bart, Heather Matarazzo, Bijou Phillips
Directed by Eli Roth
Writer: Eli Roth
Sequel to Hostel

With only one film under his belt and the endorsement of Quentin Tarantino, Eli Roth became a virtual horror brand with HOSTEL (2005), a yarn about a group of thrill-seeking American college dudes backpacking through Europe, only to be seduced into a Slovakian money-for-torture ring where they become the prey. The sequel begins right where that film left off, filling us in on the whereabouts of lone survivor Paxton (Jay Hernandez)---but before long, we see that gender roles are reversed and we are traveling with sensible Beth (Lauren German), hedonistic Whitney (Bijou Phillips), and virginal Lorna (Heather Matarazzo). After tussling with a gaggle of shifty men on a train, they meet Axelle (Vera Jordanova), a gorgeous woman who persuades them to follow her to a rejuvenating spa in Slovakia. <br> <br> As the trio checks into the same infamous hostel, Roth shows us the inner workings of the previously mysterious torture club. Once the girls are put up on the auction block, online bidding begins among the c...
view wiki
First to Review
© 2015 Lunch.com, LLC All Rights Reserved
Lunch.com - Relevant reviews by real people.
This is you!
Ranked #
Last login
Member since