|
Movies Books Music Food Tv Shows Technology Politics Video Games Parenting Fashion Green Living more >

Lunch » Tags » Movies » Reviews » IP MAN » User review

IP MAN

Action film based on Bruce Lee's Teacher in Hong Kong

< read all 4 reviews

Thrilling Martial Arts Action Film Based On the Life of Bruce Lee's Teacher...

  • Feb 17, 2009
Rating:
+5

               final fight

In the tradition of Jet Li's "Fearless" and "Fist of Legend", comes the fourth collaboration between the Wilson Yip-Donnie Yen tag team who also brought us the phenomenal "Sha Po Lang" in 2005. "IP MAN" is based on the life of the man responsible for making the Chinese kung fu style of "Wing Chun" (invented by a woman), which is up to this day, is among China's most revered style. Yes, Ip Man is also the man who has a huge number of talented disciples--most notably, the late great Bruce Lee.

In the 1930's, the Chinese province of Fo Shan is a thriving place of martial arts schools, with various sects of different styles. Fo Shan is said to be the place where the famous Fong Sai Yuk learned his art and therefore this place has a reputation. Ip Man (Donnie Yen) is a very accomplished martial artist but he keeps to himself, maintains a low profile and quietly spars with friends at home. But after an acknowledged victory over a fighter from the Northern quarter, Master Jin (Fan Siu Wong), Ip Man becomes an instant hero in Fo Shan.

Time passes and in the late 1930's, following the Japanese invasion, Ip Man's property was confiscated by the Japanese army and his family is forced to live an abject existence. One day, general Miura (Hiroyuki Ikeuchi), a fanatical practitioner in Karate, witnesses the skills of this Wing Chun master. The general becomes obsessed with Ip man, and demands that the Chinese style of Wing Chun be taught to the Japanese army. But Ip man refuses and instead challenges Miura to a duel. Ip Man has to uphold the benevolence of his art and protect Chinese dignity. The battle for national pride is about to begin….



The one thing I know for sure is that Ip Man is indeed Bruce Lee's first teacher in Hong Kong for many years, and that Ip man was indeed asked to teach the Japanese; the rest of the significant historical details in this biopic is a little questionable. Yip and screenwriter Edmond Wong does get some details right, but please keep in mind that this is an action film first and foremost--it is hardly a historical drama. The action direction by Hong Kong legend Sammo Hung is indeed amazing, and it is the film's main draw. The story has the usual elements of honor, family, loyalty and pride and offers very little that is new and  fresh--but this doesn't mean that it made the film any less exciting.

There is very minor characterization involved. The film has two acts, and the first has Ip Man's status in the Fo Shan province. He is a business man and he doesn't teach his art, there are hints that he used to compete, but he decided to keep a low profile because of his wife, Cheng (played by Lynn Hung). His relationship with his wife and son is somewhat estranged at times because of his love for sparring--she throws a tantrum whenever he fights; Ip Man is a humble man, and shows his wife the respect due her. The second act exposes the effect of the Japanese invasion of 1937 on Master Ip, his family and the Chinese people. While Donnie Yen may indeed lack the necessary acting ability to portray him dramatically--he sure has the presence of a highly trained martial artist. Director Yip did the right thing in focusing more on fights than dramatic impact. There are also some touches of social commentary seeing as how some Chinese prey on their countrymen and they only look out for themselves.

            Ip Man  

As I've said, Sammo Hung's action choreography is indeed phenomenal and it sure helps when you have a cast of real-life martial arts practitioners and action-honed actors such as Yen, Louis Fan and Hiroyuki Ikeuchi, who holds a Kuro Obi in Judo in real life. Sammo Hung maintains a nice balance between finesse, realism and downright brutality--the fights are very intense and very focused. It is a mix of the usual wire-fu and occasional acrobatics. Highlights include, Ip Man taking on 10 Japanese fighters in one time, the fight between Fan Siu Wong and Yen is quick but exciting, complemented with some subtle doses of humorous cracks. The fights are exquisitely shot, with multiple camera angles in a perspective view to close ups, so you can see all the hard-hitting action. There are also times when an opponent is thrown in the camera's view and I thought this added a lot of style and intense attitude. Director Yip and company knows exactly how to shoot and edit fight sequences, this proves to be the film's main showstopper along with the superb fight choreography.
 
            Ip man    

The action encounters are nicely placed and Wilson Yip needs to be credited for maintaining an excellent pace with its balance between action and drama. While this film is historically inaccurate, for the most part, it does succeed as an action film--a very well done at that. The film does ultimately fail as a character-driven, true-to-life biopic. Donnie Yen's "Ip Man" is more about his capabilities as a fighter than who he really was as a man, which is no doubt due to fact that it wanted to maintain a China-friendly film. The film's structure is more of a popcorn action film than an emotional biopic of a man who made his mark in using his fists to unite the Chinese people. It plays too fast and free to fully realize the film's potential as a "based on true events" type of deal.

Despite some flaws in the script, and the filmmakers relying too much on the audiences' good beliefs rather than developing Ip Man as a man than as a caricature of a folk hero; (no doubt an attempt to match Wong Fei Hung in "Once upon a Time in China" and Huo Yuan Jia in "Fearless") to portray him as an inspirational role model/saint. "IP MAN" is a truly exciting film which is just full of action and the energy it exudes is just so much fun to watch. I am rather very interested in seeing as to what Wilson Yip and Donnie Yen would bring "IP MAN 2", which would hopefully show more of his experiences in Hong Kong (which may include his time with Bruce Lee). Of course, by that time, Wong Kar-Wai's version of "IP MAN" will be released and will hopefully have more historical significance than action thrills.

Still, this film comes with a "Highly Recommended" rating from me, it does kick major ass as a martial arts action film. [4 ½ Stars]

Note: The language in the film carries is Bi-Lingual with both Cantonese and Japanese Languages.

Added: IP MAN 2 was also reviewed in this community.



promo poster movie poster scene HK dvd cover final fight

What did you think of this review?

Helpful
26
Thought-Provoking
15
Fun to Read
15
Well-Organized
16
Post a Comment
June 25, 2011
Loved this
 
October 19, 2009
Great film! Great portrayal of a legend.
October 20, 2009
Thanks! Please also see BLACK BELT aka. Kuro Obi if you like movies like this...
 
October 08, 2009
Still haven't seen this one, but I'm counting the days until I am able to get hold of a copy!
October 08, 2009
I will send you a message when the date has been set.
October 08, 2009
Can't wait.
 
September 29, 2009
Finally had a chance to see this movie while I was sick in china/thailand (ya, sux to be sidelined during vacation for 4 days and watch movies instead of going out). I loved it except for one thing, the final fight seems a little bit of a let down to me. I was hoping it would've been a tougher fight for Ip Man and a bit longer too would've been better.
September 30, 2009
Yeh, the final fight is a little underwhelming but the movie still rocks! Wilson Yip is going to follow this up with a sequel; featuring Bruce Lee as a child. Wong Kar-Wai is also coming out with a docudrama about Ip Man that is supposed to be more accurate....I guess it is sort of a "Tombstone"-"Wyatt Earp" approach.
 
February 20, 2009
I heard about this release from my Chinese son in law, of all sources. He's about as Chinese as Clint Eastwood on most days. Anyhow I've been waiting for the release of this flick for some time now and can't wait to see it even if it is somehow lacking in credibility.
March 06, 2009
Karen, this is well waorth owning if you like martial arts films. I will be by to stop by everyone this Sunday...tons of things to do!
 
February 18, 2009
Thanks, Trashie, comments like yours make my efforts worthwhile. I love asian cinema. As for the encounter with 10 black belts, most of it were accounts by witnesses--Master Ip doesn't brag or talk about his fights. Yes, the rapid movements of punches can be practiced--trust me, I know. These types of fighters however, never compete--much like Master IP. Check out the "Prodigal Son" with Yuen Biao; it is about Master Ip's teacher. I edited my review bump the rating up to 5 stars rounded up, and included "kick ass"--my previous write up was clean because I will also post this review at Hkflix. I have connections in Chinatown and Japantown so I do get the official releases before amazon and hkflix. Check out motionandsound.com.
 
1
More IP MAN reviews
Quick Tip by . November 17, 2010
I watched this last night whilst I wasin between a few busywork tasks on the couch (I watched the English dubbed version), and I enjoyed it for the most part. It's a very interested true story that combines some elements of other WWII flicks (one part SCHINDLER'S LIST, one part THE DIARY OF ANNE FRANK) and thrusts in the age-old debate between kung-fu (Chinese) and karate (Japanese) with some masterful fight sequences. I wanted a bit more meat on the story between Ip and his wife and his son, but, …
Quick Tip by . September 10, 2010
posted in ASIANatomy
Great movie and one of my favorites. I could watch the 1 vs 10 scene 10000 times in a row.
Quick Tip by . July 10, 2010
posted in ASIANatomy
This is Donnie Yen's best acting role yet! Terrific action and a Good Plot flows perfectly just like water.
About the reviewer
William ()
Ranked #1
Please "Like" Film and Movies and Keep the Economy strong....LOL!!      My Interests: Movies, Anime, History, Martial Arts, Comics, Entertainment,Cooking, Things I don't … more
Consider the Source

Use Trust Points to see how much you can rely on this review.

You
woopak_the_thrill
Your ratings:
rate more to improve this
About this movie

Wiki




Ip Man is a 2008 semi-biographical martial arts film based on the life of Ip Man, a grandmaster of the martial art Wing Chun and the first person to teach Wing Chun openly. One of his students was the widely influential and acclaimed martial artist and filmmaker Bruce Lee. The film focuses on events in Ip's life that took place in the city of Foshan during the Second Sino-Japanese War. The film was directed by Wilson Yip, and stars Donnie Yen as Ip Man, with martial arts choreography by Sammo Hung. The supporting cast includes Simon Yam, Lynn Hung, Lam Ka-Tung, Xing Yu and Hiroyuki Ikeuchi.

The idea of an Ip Man biopic originated in 1998 when Jeffrey Lau and Corey Yuen discussed the idea of making a film based on Bruce Lee's martial arts master. However, the studio producing the proposed film closed, and the project was abandoned. Producer Raymond Wong decided to develop his own Ip Man film with full consent from Ip's sons, and had filmmakers head to Foshan to research Ip's life. Ip Chun, Ip Man's eldest son, and several other Wing Chun practitioners served as technical consultants for the film. Principal photography for Ip Man began in March 2008 and ended in August; filming took place in Shanghai, which was used to architecturally recreate Foshan. During filming, conflicts arose between the producers of Ip Man and filmmaker Wong Kar-wai over the film's working title. Wong, who had been developing his own Ip Man biopic, clashed with the producers ...
view wiki

Details

Director: Wilson Yip
Genre: Action, Adventure
Release Date: 12 December 2008 (China)
MPAA Rating: R
Screen Writer: Edmond Wong
Runtime: 106 minutes
Studio: Beijing ShengShi HuaRei Film Investment & Management Co.
Polls with this movie
poster

Martial Arts Mania

by

© 2014 Lunch.com, LLC All Rights Reserved
Lunch.com - Relevant reviews by real people.
()
This is you!
Ranked #
Last login
Member since
reviews
comments
ratings
questions
compliments
lists