Movies Books Music Food Tv Shows Technology Politics Video Games Parenting Fashion Green Living more >

Lunch » Tags » Movies » Reviews » SAMURAI X: Trust and Betrayal » User review

Ruthless Hands, Gentle Heart....Heaven's Justice

  • Feb 21, 2009

Noburo Watsunuki probably had no idea just how popular "Rorouni Kenshin" would be. What started out as a manga became a long running TV series and has spawned a major animated movie. "SAMURAI X Trust and Betrayal Director's cut" (aka. Ruroni Kenshin: Meiji Kenkaku roman tan: Tsuioku hen) is the precursor to the TV series, and tells the origins of the assassin called Kenshin Himura. Both "Trust and Betrayal" have been edited together, combining the 4 OVA episodes into one coherent movie. If you've seen "Reflections" then you will need to see this installment to fully understand the roots of its story. The film is based on the "Romantic Tales of the Meiji Era" and scenes were added to give the script a lot more continuity and more detail.

A samurai in his purest form were built upon a technique that is as much a science as an art form. A samurai would live and die under his code of Bushido--they embraced art, culture and were philosophers in their own right. I loved the classic samurai tales of Kurosawa, Kobayashi and Okamoto. Director/writer Kazuhiro Furuhashi along with screenplay by Masashi Sogo has captured the spirit of the chambara classics and essence of the romantic classics in anime form. Telling fictionalized origins but partly based on true accounts, this is the story of Hitokiri Battousai--the man who kills men like a demon.

During an attack by bandits, a young boy named Shinta was rescued by a highly skilled swordsman named Seijuro Hiko. Touched by the boy's passion and sense of justice, he trains the young boy in the teachings of the Mitsurugi style of swordplay and renames him Kenshin Himura. Kenshin (voiced by Mayo Suzukaze) is an idealist, very pure in his beliefs in creating a better world. Kenshin is recruited by the leader of the Choshu clan to perform acts of political assassination, and he becomes the most feared assassin in Kyoto. However, Kenshin's soul is becoming as war torn as the battlefields of Japan--his bloody work slowly stripping away his humanity. Kenshin still hopes for peace and finds his hopes personified in a beautiful woman named Tomoe (voiced by Junko Iwao) who shows him a life beyond the sword. Sadly, Tomoe is also torn by ghosts from her past. Can Kenshin and Tomoe save each other and find happiness?

The film's backdrop is set during a civil unrest in 1864. Different factions are in a struggle for power and the ruling Shogunate is known for enforcing abrasive laws. The Shinsengumi are the enforcers of the governing body and they are tasked in quelling rebellions before they come to fruition. All clans have their own brand of justice and they all believe they have a noble cause. Such is the Choshu clan to which Kenshin is affiliated with, they believe their cause is honorable and Kenshin lends his sword to their brand of justice.

While the show does have its levels of political intrigue, and has the usual elements of honor, duty and loyalty; the film focuses on Kenshin. His emotions, doubts and hopes take center stage, as well as his relationship with Tomoe. I really liked the detailed execution of the screenplay and the structure of its storytelling. It just so full of emotions and I was very impressed. Director Furuhashi knew exactly what he was going for, and while the story itself isn't wholly original, I couldn't help but be very involved with its storyline. Hatred and revenge, disappointments, love and redemption--betrayal, loss and tragedy are the film's main strengths. The film has a very serious tone and the animated cinematography is both beautiful and sad, with some use of metaphors and symbolism, fitting to the film's main premise. The film just manages to flesh out and define each and every emotion (or shifts in emotions) to give a fine narrative impact.

The film also has an abundance of swordplay. The fights are exquisitely animated and very bloody--the usual Japanese trademark of splattering blood is used to emulate its violence and brutality. Heads are stabbed, bodies are cut in half, necks are slashed. The film is perfectly animated and the camera shots are quite similar to jidai geki films such as "Lone Wolf and Cub" and "Azumi". The action is nicely placed and each encounter carries a lot of expressive impact and at the same time, cold and visceral. The scenes of violence and brutality is an inherent part of its plot and not unwarranted as with some other anime who uses this effect as a gimmick. It is not your kid's anime.

Those who are used to the animation in the "Rurouni Kenshin" TV series may be taken aback. Its style is quite different and has no over-expressive bulging eyes. The colors are occasionally muted to convey its mood, although some shots are colorful but nonetheless retains a dark and gloomy atmosphere. The eyes and facial expressions show a lot of humanity--when a character is in emotional pain, the camera will linger a bit to make the viewer feel the running emotions. The rendering is simple and while not exactly as accurate (clothes and hair styles) historically, it maintains an anime style, but it didn't hamper the film even one bit. The music is also quite enthralling and goes nicely with each scene to reflect the mood.

"Samurai X: Trust and Betrayal" is a very good film. It is not perfect but it is just so entertaining and touching in its execution. It succeeds in delivering much needed emotions and has given anime fans a good reason to celebrate. It can satisfy action fanatics and delivers an intelligent, cleverly structured samurai drama. Its subtle touches in wordplay, metaphors and melodrama are well-balanced that proved to be a very good re-watch. The film has definite replay value and is a fantastic companion film to the TV series. After you see this, you will love the TV show even more. Deeply tragic and quite beautiful in structure, this anime movie is Highly Recommended! [4 ½ - Out of 5 Stars]

Dvd cover promo Kenshin scene

What did you think of this review?

Fun to Read
Post a Comment
May 22, 2009
Someone from this site pointed me to your review and that motivated me to give this a crack! I'm all the better for it, this was an excellent movie...and review. Thanks.
May 23, 2009
Glad I convinced you to take a chance on this anime movie. Make sure you check out "Shigurui Death Frenzy"...I also reviewed that anime series here. If you loved this one, I'm pretty sure you'll like that one! Thank you for the read.
February 24, 2009
T-man, me too. I think I may review "vampire Hunter D Bloodlust" first since I haven't seen it in ages. you seen Ghost in the Shell yet?
February 22, 2009
T-man, it's called Samurai X Reflections...that one was also really emotionally driven. I'm trying to re-visit classic anime, and I may just run into your fave again; Vampire Hunter D.
February 22, 2009
Just to let everyone know, I couldn't find an official trailer for this anime movie--and all I found was a fan made trailer. the music on the film isn't the same one as in the anime film...
More SAMURAI X: Trust and Betrayal reviews
review by . May 22, 2009
Samurai X
It's a shame that George Lucas didn't hire the writer of Samurai X to pen his most recent StarWars trilogy. As I watched this absolutely amazing movie, I couldn't help but feel that this is exactly what the backstory for Anakin Skywalker should have been.    The main character of Samurai X, Kenshin, has a lot in common with Anakin. Both were sold into slavery, and both have an uncompromising idea about what justice is and how it should be carried out. But unlike Anakin, with …
About the reviewer
William ()
Ranked #1
Please "Like" Film and Movies and Keep the Economy strong....LOL!!      My Interests: Movies, Anime, History, Martial Arts, Comics, Entertainment,Cooking, Things I don't … more
Consider the Source

Use Trust Points to see how much you can rely on this review.

Your ratings:
rate more to improve this
About this movie



MPAA Rating: Unrated
DVD Release Date: May 20, 2003
Runtime: 120 minutes
Studio: Adv Films

First to Review
© 2015 Lunch.com, LLC All Rights Reserved
Lunch.com - Relevant reviews by real people.
This is you!
Ranked #
Last login
Member since