Movies Books Music Food Tv Shows Technology Politics Video Games Parenting Fashion Green Living more >

Lunch » Tags » Movies » Reviews » Secretariat » User review


A movie directed by Randall Wallace

< read all 5 reviews

There's Something Special About That Horse

  • Oct 14, 2010
I know how movies like this are supposed to work, and this time, it doesn't bother me one bit. "Secretariat," in the tradition of recent films like "The Blind Side," "Invictus," and "The Longshots," adapts a true story into a reliable but successful inspirational sports drama. I admit that I knew nothing of the real Secretariat before seeing ads for the film, and I still know nothing about horseracing. However, I do know a good movie when I see one (although many have suggested otherwise). "Secretariat" is, indeed, a good movie, full of excitement and hope, brimming with enthusiasm, steadfast in its declaration that good things can happen as long as we have faith in ourselves and the people around us. Perhaps this is a bit idealistic, but since when has that been a bad thing? Sometimes, we actively seek movies like this, movies that can reinvigorate the idealist in us all.

Secretariat, for those of you who don't know, was an American thoroughbred racehorse who in 1973 made history by becoming the first U.S. Triple Crown winner in twenty-five years. He also set new race records by completing the Kentucky Derby in 1:59 and the Belmont Stakes in 2:24 - records that, to this day, have not been broken. The film, suggested by William Nack's book "Secretariat: The Making of a Champion," does a wonderful job not only of depicting both races, but also of dramatizing the struggle to make his achievements possible. At the center of this struggle was housewife and mother Penney Chenery, who in the late 1960s took control of her ill father's horse breeding ranch in Virginia, which was suffering financially. It was there that Secretariat was born in the spring of 1969.

Chenery is portrayed in the film by Diane Lane as a determined, intelligent woman who trusts her instincts so deeply, it's almost as if the word "doubt" has absolutely no meaning. After refusing to sell her father's farm, much to the chagrin of her faithless brother (Dylan Baker), she participates in a coin toss with millionaire Ogden Phipps (James Cromwell), which would determine who would have first choice over the farm's two pregnant mares; technically speaking, she loses, although she's left with the mare she wanted, so in fact, she wins. No one other than her believed her mare would give birth to a quality racehorse, considering the parentage. When the colt is born, however, it's obvious that there's something special about him - he stands and begins walking faster than anyone working for the farm had ever seen.

The film does a good job conveying the sheer magnetism of Secretariat. Physically, he looks no different from any other horse. And yet, when the camera goes in for a close up of his face, his eyes gleam with passion and energy. Everyone around him senses it, including his groom, Eddie Sweat (Nelsan Ellis), who in real life spent more time with Secretariat than with any other human being. In due time, Chenery is able to convince a retired trainer named Lucien Laurin (John Malkovich) to give up spending the rest of his days playing golf; he too sees something special in Secretariat. Laurin is an eccentric man - moody and demanding, with a wardrobe that suggests he may have gone colorblind at some point in his life.

What the film never adequately addresses is Chenery's balancing act between her farm life and her relationship with her family. According to what we're shown, she essentially abandons her husband, a lawyer named John Tweedy (Dylan Walsh), and her four children, the oldest a teenager named Kate (Amanda Michalka), who in the turmoil of the early 1970s became a liberal activist, in part, I suspect, to rebel against the old fashioned beliefs of her father. While Chenery generally seems to miss her family - she often cries whenever she speaks to them on the phone - it's never made explicitly clear why she found Secretariat and his racing career more worthy of her attention. I would have appreciated a more thorough examination of this aspect of her life.

Despite this, we find that Kate is actually inspired by her mother's determination, and by the end, she will become her most vocal supporter. Indeed, many scenes with Chenery are no less than inspirational. Some of the best are reserved for pre-race press conferences, where Chenery and her opponent Pancho Martin (Nestor Serrano) trade verbal jabs, his angrier and more direct, hers quieter and more underhanded. There's no need for her to be hostile. She knows Secretariat is a winner. There's a scene later in the film, for example, when she asks to have a moment alone with the horse; when Sweat and Laurin step aside, Chenery and Secretariat face each other without saying anything for a few seconds, after which she quietly but confidently says, "Okay then. See you in the morning."

Little moments like this, moments that underscore Chenery's strength of character, are what make "Secretariat" such a pleasant movie, more so, in my opinion, than the racing sequences. I will not say that this is one of the year's best films, for while it is hugely entertaining, it also does little more than follow a very well established formula. That being said, it follows its formula very well, giving audiences every reason to cheer once the credits start to roll. In addition, the performances are wonderful; I'm fairly certain Diane Lane in particular will be considered for an award or two come springtime. If it worked for Sandra Bullock, it could work for her too.

What did you think of this review?

Fun to Read
Post a Comment
October 20, 2010
Oh, and he was foaled in March of 1970. Only 3 year olds can run in the Triple Crown races.
October 20, 2010
Oh boy does this film ever follow a well established formula! It practically takes Big Red and turns him into Seabiscuit. I suppose you have to inject a little drama into s situation where there was next to none, but playing so loosely with the facts is insulting to those who know them. Yeah the farm was in big financial trouble but they completely fail to mention the existence of riva Ridge (Penny's favorite horse) who won 2 legs of the Triple Crown for her the year before Secretariat ran. And that bit about Big Red being terribly ill due an abcess as the reason he lost the Wodd--partially true. He had an abcess alright but he trained for the Derby brilliantly and never skipped a meal--the exact opposite of what was depicted in the movie. If anyone had medical problems in any of those races it was poor Sham who knocked out a tooth in the starting gate (can't remember which of the 3 races it was). Probably didn't bother him much though during the race. They have trouble pulling these horses up when they break a leg. I doubt he felt pain from the tooth until after the race. It was a front tooth so it would have caused him problems grazing--he could still eat. There were a lot more inaccuracies. And it was a mediocre horse movie at best. Still there were moments when if I squinted my eyes I could almost deluded myself into believing I was seeing Big Red again...one last time.
More Secretariat reviews
review by . January 29, 2011
posted in Movie Hype
Whether you know the full story and the whole history or not, 'Secretariat' is a terrific family movie. This Disney film zeroes in on the horse and its owner, Penny Chenery (Diane Lane) in a way that makes us care deeply about both. The pensive moments marvelously frame the most exciting scenes, and Lane is pitch perfect as the beleaguered woman who must face debtors, relatives, competitors, and the media in the face of a dream that could cost her everything. Director Randall Wallace knows how to …
review by . March 23, 2011
posted in Movie Hype
*** out of ****     "Secretariat" is the kind of "based-on-a-true-story" film which never uses that phrase as a gimmick or a way to make money. The film is purely craft, and is about ten times better than you would expect it to be. I went into the film wondering how good it would be. I kind of expected it to be fairly forgettable, sappy, and corny. As it turns out, "Secretariat" is neither of those things. In fact, it's a completely enjoyable, well-acted, and well-made drama. …
review by . October 16, 2010
posted in Movie Hype
Good but not great
Denver housewife Penny Chenery (Diane Lane) takes over her father's horse racing empire when he falls ill, commuting to Virginia to take care of the farm. Having grown up in the racing world, she knows about bloodlines and invests all her efforts in young Big Red, soon to be renamed Secretariat. She hires a good, but retired trainer (John Malkovich) and soon the horse is headed for the Triple Crown.      Secretariat was arguably the best race horse ever and deserved a good …
Quick Tip by . October 04, 2010
posted in Movie Hype
I don't have to see this flick to know that it's another formulaic, dull as dishwater movie in which a plucky woman needs to save the farm and a crusty old trainer who comes out of retirement to help her do the impossible. Now all we need is a troubled jockey who needs redemption and we'll have all the cliches covered. They've been doing this crap since the days of Mickey Rooney and Judy Garland. Oh yeah. There might be a horse in there somewhere too.      When …
About the reviewer
Chris Pandolfi ()
Ranked #5
Growing up a shy kid in a quiet suburb of Los Angeles, Chris Pandolfi knows all about the imagination. Pretend games were always the most fun for him, especially on the school playground; he and his … more
Consider the Source

Use Trust Points to see how much you can rely on this review.

Your ratings:
rate more to improve this
About this movie


The "greatest racehorse of all time" mantle fits easily around the neck of Secretariat, the 1973 Triple Crown winner. So why not a movie version of this champion's life?Secretariatbegins in the late '60s, with some good behind-the-scenes material on how thoroughbreds come to be (there's flavorful atmosphere inside the horsey world, including an account of Secretariat's ownership being decided by a coin flip as part of an old-school agreement). A highly lacquered Diane Lane plays Penny Chenery, the inheritor of her father's stables, who segues from being an all-American mom to running a major horse-racing franchise; reliable character-actor support comes in the form of John Malkovich, as a gaudily outfitted trainer, and Margo Martindale, as Chenery's assistant. Screenwriter Mike Rich and director Randall Wallace must do some heavy lifting to make Lane's privileged millionaire into some sort of underdog--luckily, the hidebound traditions of the male-dominated racing scene provide some sources of outrage. The need to stack the deck even more leads the movie into its more contrived scenes, unfortunately, as though we needed dastardly villains in order to root for Penny and her horse. Meanwhile, attempts to reach for a littleSeabiscuit-style social relevance don't come off, and a curious religious undertone might make you wonder whether we're meant to assume that God chose Secretariat over some less-deserving equine. The actual ...
view wiki


Director: Randall Wallace
Genre: Drama
Release Date: October 08, 2010
MPAA Rating: PG
Screen Writer: Mike Rich
Studio: Walt Disney Pictures
First to Review
© 2014 Lunch.com, LLC All Rights Reserved
Lunch.com - Relevant reviews by real people.
This is you!
Ranked #
Last login
Member since