Movies Books Music Food Tv Shows Technology Politics Video Games Parenting Fashion Green Living more >

Lunch » Tags » Celebrities » Reviews » State of Play » User review

State of Play

A movie released April 17, 2009

< read all 2 reviews

3 ½ Stars: The Responsibilty of Credible Reporting Collides With A Murder Mystery...

  • Sep 3, 2009

Based on the BBC mini-series, director Kevin McDonald’s “STATE OF PLAY” blends the two most reliable, favorite ingredients of an effective thriller; a political-conspiracy thriller mixed in with a journalism drama with a touch of a murder mystery mixed in. The film’s direction can be taut, clean and energetic that plays on the moralities of politics and the responsibility of credible reporting. Kevin McDonald maneuvers the film’s script in a meaty web of intrigue and suspense that is nicely acted and honest in its execution.
Cal McAffrey (Russell Crowe) is a seasoned reporter working at a struggling newspaper called “The Washington Globe“. When the research assistant (played by Maria Thayer) and lover to a congressman named Stephen Collins (Ben Affleck) is killed, her mysterious death provokes a lot of speculation for a high-profile story. Cal has a history with Collins and his wife Anne (Robin Wright Penn), so he is the natural pick to tackle this story. But Cal becomes conflicted with what story he wants to tell the longer he digs for the truth; which leads him to team up with a young inexperienced reporter named Della Frye (Rachel McAdams) to sort out the mystery full of political intrigue to avoid further bloodshed and uncover the real story behind all the rumors and deceptions. Cal now finds himself face to face with his own ‘crisis of conscience’ as his own proven investigative skills may not coincide with the needs for profit and that the real story may alienate his own friends.
“State of Play” is a thriller that tries to keep its toes by mixing in elements of a political thriller that touches on some real world events after the tragedy of 9/11 and the responsibilities of credible fact-finding. The script by Tony Gilroy (Michael Clayton), Matthew Carnahan (The Kingdom) and Billy Ray has its share of good dialogue delivered by characters that has some layers and dimensions that proved interesting. Cal represents the old-school style of reporting; he checks his facts, looks for credible sources and ignores the unnecessary hidden stories. His dislike on young inexperienced blogger Della comes absolutely natural. Cal sees her as the spoiled reporter who may write appealing articles who happen to have a better computer and a better office. The two are representations of the signs of the times and the internet phenomenon. It was also nice to see the script avoid the trappings of a perfunctory romance between the two reporters but instead director McDonald uses a sort of a mentor-student type of relationship between the two after they realize that they are both after the same thing.
The film’s political side comes from the character of Stephen Collins who may have the best interests of the country at heart, although he made some mistakes on some decisions such as bedding his own research assistant. The screenplay is a little cautious, but it does point an accusing finger at certain corporations who make huge profit from a war. Apparently the privatization of soldiers in the war against terror is one profitable industry, and these soldiers are just mercenaries answerable to no one. The moral responsibilities of fighting a war are touched upon as well as maintaining the image of a clean public figure. Smear campaigns, damaging rumors and speculations are used to manipulate Congress to satisfy the needs of big corporate America.
Director McDonald does get the atmosphere and the fast-paced feel of a newspaper right. I liked the old-school ‘press room’ with the editor looking above the reporters. McDonald is to be commended that he remembered to bring such late night hurdles into exposition; although frankly, the stereotypical character of Cal’s editor in the person of Helen Mirren should’ve been abandoned. Mirren does a good performance as Cal’s impatient and overly cautious editor, but her character has been overused in other films in this genre. The shady, corrupt politician in the person of Jeff Daniels has also been done to death. I also have issues with the age factor between Cal and Collins; Affleck and Crowe just don’t fit as former college buddies. Affleck is decent as the congressman but Crowe just looked so much older than him, I couldn’t really buy into the idea that they’re the same age. The relationship between Cal and Anne isn’t really brought into fruition; quite frankly, it felt a little forced to add some spice to the screenplay.
The manner of which the plot unravels is full of various storylines that come to a satisfying ending but some elements feel unnecessary. The script should have been more compact and some scenes dragged a little bit. It doesn’t really hurt the film but Jason Bateman’s scenes should have been more efficiently played out. It also seemed to try too hard on satisfying its audience in both the cerebral conspiracy thriller fan base and the action junkies; it does work on some levels but I thought the script may have had the fear of becoming too talkie that it needed to bring some gunplay into the mix. Some of the scenes just didn’t match the film’s tone at times.
“State of Play” does have some nice touches such as an old-fashioned workhorse in the face of “blogger-space”, it explores the morals of profit gain and the responsibilities of public officials; the problem is, sometimes, it just felt that the film didn’t have confidence enough to stay within the realms of a journalistic drama. It tries to be too complex just for the sake of becoming complex, that it felt like it threw too many ideas that slowed the film’s pace. It does feel predictable in the middle of the film, but I did appreciate the effort in delivering a credible thriller. It does deliver the goods and the effective revelations do hit the right spots.
Recommended! [3 ½ Stars]
Video/Audio: 2.35 ratio anamorphic widescreen. The picture looks pristine even when the colors looked a little restrained. The quality of the picture matches the film’s tone. The 5.1 Dolby Digital track is clear enough and well channeled.


What did you think of this review?

Fun to Read
Post a Comment
September 05, 2009
Crowe is about 8 years older than Affleck and that he looks so scruffy doesn't help the matter any. Of course you could argue the case simply by saying that he entered college later, but the fact that it draws anyone away from the story has to be considered a minus. Of course this is on my list, but I'm very superficial I likes my Russell Crowe movies with him lookin' a bit better, so it's taking its own sweet time workin' its way to the top. Still I suspect I might appreciate it more than you with or without Crowe. Nice work, Woop.
September 05, 2009
I like Crowe too which is why I checked this one out. Affleck was passable but the guy just has not intensity in his acting. This wasn't bad at all, it's just that some scenes felt a little stretched out and I thought that it could've been better as a solid thriller than adding some pieces of action. Seen the BBC mini-series?
September 05, 2009
No, I haven't. I wouldn't say that he lacks intensity either. It's just that he's different. He's very much an interior actor. I'll bet he looked the same way right before he'd get into one of those bar fights he used to get into as he did at any other time. He has sort of a "flat affect" as a shrink might say. He'd make a really good serial killer.
September 07, 2009
Good point. Affleck just looks boring but I agree, he may just make a good serial killer.
September 08, 2009
In real life as well as in reel life. =)
More State of Play reviews
review by . May 05, 2009
I very much enjoyed this movie.  Something about the inherent drama of the newsroom really set the stage.  The current day tie ins (insider politics, corporate conspiracies not to mention the death of print media) were bordering on heavy handed but still worked.  The acting was fine, the plot was great.  
About the reviewer
William ()
Ranked #1
Please "Like" Film and Movies and Keep the Economy strong....LOL!!      My Interests: Movies, Anime, History, Martial Arts, Comics, Entertainment,Cooking, Things I don't … more
Consider the Source

Use Trust Points to see how much you can rely on this review.

Your ratings:
rate more to improve this
About this movie


State of Play is a 2009 American political thriller. It is a film adaptation of the critically acclaimed six-part British television serial State of Play, which first aired on BBC One in 2003. The film was directed by Kevin Macdonald from a screenplay written by Matthew Michael Carnahan, Tony Gilroy, Peter Morgan, and Billy Ray.

The film tells of a journalist's probe into the suspicious death of a Congressman's mistress. Russell Crowe plays the journalist and Ben Affleck plays the Congressman. The supporting cast includes Rachel McAdams, Helen Mirren, Jason Bateman, Robin Wright Penn, and Jeff Daniels. The plot of the six-hour serial has been condensed to fit two hours, and the location changed to Washington, D.C. Macdonald said State of Play is informed by the films of the 1970s, and explores the topical subjects of journalistic independence and the relationship between politicians and the press. It was released in North America on April 17, 2009.

view wiki


Genre: Drama
Release Date: April 17, 2009
MPAA Rating: PG-13
Runtime: 1hr 58min

© 2015 Lunch.com, LLC All Rights Reserved
Lunch.com - Relevant reviews by real people.
This is you!
Ranked #
Last login
Member since