|
Movies Books Music Food Tv Shows Technology Politics Video Games Parenting Fashion Green Living more >

Lunch » Tags » Movies » Reviews » THX 1138 » User review

THX 1138 (The George Lucas Director's Cut 2-disc Special Edition DVD)

George Lucas' 1971 science fiction film and feature film debut.

< read all 1 reviews

A Stark Vision of a Future Where Love Is the Ultimate Crime

  • Jan 13, 2009
Rating:
+4

-This review pertains to the George Lucas Director's Cut of THX 1138-

 

Before achieving critical and commercial success with his films American Graffiti and Star Wars, George Lucas directed the ill-fated THX 1138. The film was a valid attempt to expand upon the story and themes of Lucas' avant-garde student film Electronic Labyrinth: THX 1138 4EB, which itself was based upon a short story by Matthew Robbins and Walter Murch.

An emotionally stunted populace... 

The film was an ambitious cinematic experiment that showcased Lucas' highly stylized sensibilities and his talents as a visual storyteller. But despite its originality, THX would prove to be a commercial and critical flop. The question remains: why?

First of all, the film was released in 1971 and the hippie movement was still "in bloom" and THX was not an optimistic picture of the future. Darkly humorous and deeply satirical, the film was an attempt to comment on the growing consumerist/capitalist culture of the U.S. and the disintegration of human emotion. Apparently the dark humor and irony was lost on audiences and film critics alike. The film was too intellectual and not commercial enough.

 The reason that prisons should segregate the sexes...

It also didn't help that the film utilized a minimalistic narrative approach, which was inspired by Japanese cinema (the films of Akira Kurosawa, in particular, were an inspiration) that gave little indication to viewers as to exactly what they were seeing on the screen. To most the film was fragmented, shallow and too depressing, and yet that was the point of THX to begin with. THX wasn't your typical movie-going experience. Instead it was a challenging and provocative film, which did have a hopeful ending. However the film was misunderstood and was generally dismissed by those who saw it. The common complaint being that it wasn't upbeat enough (‘cause everybody knows that reality's so cheerful and naturally our overabundance of joy should spill across the multiplex screen).

Strange camaraderie... 

The cast includes Robert Duvall as THX, Maggie McOmie as LUH, Donald Pleasence as SEN, and Don Pedro Colley as SRT. Each member of the cast gives appropriately eerie and emotionally detached performances.

 

 

THX 1138 is an abstract vision of a possible future, where human beings are forced to live underground because the surface of the Earth is no longer inhabitable (though no further explanation for this is given). Here in a bleak subterranean cityscape, the remnants of the human race have formed a rigid social structure of complete conformity and mindless consumerism. There is no elect government per se, however the population is controlled through a series of sedatives used to repress human emotion. In this dystopian society people are manipulated and subjugated, not by an external dictatorial power, but by their own emotional detachment. Every individual is equal, but only through a mutual obsolescence. Personal identity is extinct and people are reduced to being little more than serial numbers.

When LUH begins skipping doses of her medication she finds herself flooded with a range of emotions, emotions that she's never known, but she has no one to express them to and no one to empathize with her. Desperate to share these feelings she begins weaning her platonic roommate THX off his medications. Soon the two find themselves feeling sexually attracted to one another and they commit the ultimate sin: love.

When LUH becomes pregnant, she and THX are separated and imprisoned. Determined to reunite with LUH, the woman who liberated him from his soulless, monotonous life, THX begins a search to find her. But his efforts to rescue her fail and soon he is being pursued by robotic sentinels. Can THX escape and find freedom on the Earth's surface or is he doomed to remain a drone in a soulless technocracy?

 

 

Originally THX was the first film to be released through a partnership between Warner Bros. and Francis Ford Coppola's American Zoetrope, but the film lacked the commercial appeal that Warner Bros. craved and as a result they canceled their contract with American Zoetrope and cut five minutes from THX before releasing it. After the monumental success of Star Wars, Lucas went back to Warner Bros. and convinced them to let him reinsert the five minutes worth of deleted footage. However as often is the case with Lucas, even the restored version of the film didn't match his initial vision, so he created a newly restored version.

Policing civilians... 

Now using modern filmmaking technology, Lucas has not only restored and remastered the film, he has also enhanced numerous scenes with computer-generated imagery (or CGI), making  the director's the ultimate version of the film. 
THX 1138 (2-disc George Lucas Director's Cut Edition)

This mind-numbingly good DVD includes an audio commentary by George Lucas and Walter Murch, an isolated music and sound effects audio track, "A Legacy of Filmmakers: The Early Years of American Zoetrope" documentary, "Artifact from the Future: The Making of THX 1138" documentary, George Lucas' original short film Electronic Labyrinth: THX 1138 4EB, "Bald" vintage featurette, trailers and TV spots.

Poster Only with love are we human... Robot police Policing Civilians LUH The reason that prisons should segregate the sexes A Strange Camaraderie Provoking an Emotional Response Refusing to Cooperate THX in Isolation A Stark Vision of a Future Where Love Is the Ultimate Crime A Stark Vision of a Future Where Love Is the Ultimate Crime A Stark Vision of a Future Where Love Is the Ultimate Crime A Stark Vision of a Future Where Love Is the Ultimate Crime A Stark Vision of a Future Where Love Is the Ultimate Crime

What did you think of this review?

Helpful
22
Thought-Provoking
4
Fun to Read
6
Well-Organized
8
Post a Comment
February 03, 2009
I'm with you. I don't want to see the new and improved film, I want to see the movie I fell in love with. Someone actually went back and inserted a lot of crappy CGI in Ernie Fosselius' HARDWARE WARS which ruined the whole thing and completely defeated the purpose of the film. Fosselius at least got them to put on the new box that he had nothing to do with that.
 
January 16, 2009
If I were to focus on what he COULD HAVE done instead of what he did, I'd probably get depressed. The thought of a world without "Star Wars" is scary, but a world without Episodes I and II, a world without Indiana Jones 4... that sounds better to me!
December 10, 2009
Seriously, you do realize that like 70% of critics agreed that it was awful, right?
 
January 14, 2009
Great review, Count, I rather enjoyed this one and I do think it was pretty good for its time.
 
January 14, 2009
No sadly, I won't ever be able to. The original cut has never been available on DVD or VHS. However, I have seen the original version of the director's cut before the new special effects were added and big surprise, the original director's cut was better. But of course, I'm a cinema purist and I'm always annoyed when filmmakers alter their movies. Leave a good thing alone and it becomes classic, try to perfect something and it becomes flawed. When will directors learn? Oy!
 
1
About the reviewer

Ranked #10
Member Since: Dec 16, 2008
Last Login: Jun 7, 2012 07:25 PM UTC
Consider the Source

Use Trust Points to see how much you can rely on this review.

You
Count_Orlok_22
Your ratings:
rate more to improve this
About this movie

Wiki


Set in the 25th century, the story centers around a man and a woman who rebel against their rigidly controlled society.
view wiki
© 2014 Lunch.com, LLC All Rights Reserved
Lunch.com - Relevant reviews by real people.
()
This is you!
Ranked #
Last login
Member since
reviews
comments
ratings
questions
compliments
lists