Movies Books Music Food Tv Shows Technology Politics Video Games Parenting Fashion Green Living more >

Lunch » Tags » Movie » Reviews » The Guitar » User review

Becoming Free and Bold can Lead to Self-Discovery

  • Feb 28, 2009

A 2008 Sundance Film Festival selection, "The Guitar" is a film that takes us into the unpredictable world of a woman with a terminal illness. Directed by Amy Redford and with a script by Amos Pie, it is a story that dives into the mind of a lonely, grieving cancer patient and her final days--it is a story of frustrations, freedom, disconnection, and awakening.

Melody Wilder (Saffron Burrows) is a woman who had just discovered that she only has two months to live--she has been diagnosed with throat cancer. To make things worse, she had just been laid off from her job and before she can confide with her boyfriend about her affliction, he breaks up with her. So what does Melody do? She cleans out her existing bank accounts, and rents a short term loft. Without any fears and inhibitions, Melody makes a carefree life for her last days--maxing out her credit cards, walks around stark naked in her loft, abandons her healthy diet, indulges in exploratory sexual experiences, until finally she learns to play a guitar.

Delving into the mind of a cancer victim is a very interesting premise, think "Last Holiday" and "the Bucket List" but on a much smaller timeline. However, the film does have quite a number of weaknesses. The script feels to display a some of overload of the bleak things that can happen to one person. I mean, it is possible for all these things to happen, but I think it leaned too much on the cruelty of the world, and it feels a little heavy-handed. The direction by Amy Redford does get its message across; it is a forceful approach enough, but it just feels too much of an exhibition that just grabs the viewer, that some may have a slight suspension of disbelief and a leap beyond logic.

The way Melody expresses her grief may be a little predictable--buying totally unnecessary things, indulging in foods high in cholesterol and calories, and secluding herself in an enclosed space is believable but the way the following events occur is just too convenient. She develops friendships with a courier delivery man named Roscoe (Isaac De Bankole) and a pizza delivery girl named "Cookie" (Paz Dela Huerte), and of course she has sex with both of them. Mel's situation should be more complicated, and the screenplay fails to add complexities to her last few days. It just feels too predictable and what happens in the loft isn't anything new. The film is very simple, and has the "living the moment" theme going for it, but it felt too simple for its own good--nothing much happens.

For a film like this to succeed, the lead actress has to be very capable. Well, despite the weaknesses of the script, Saffron Burrows manages to draw the best out of what she had while being restrained by the script, but she can‘t really fully succeed. I really liked her in "Deep Blue Sea" and even in smaller roles such as in "Troy", I thought Burrows is an underrated actress. Most parts of the film had little or no dialogue at all, (I thought this was a good approach to the film) and Burrows does manage to express the needed emotions that ranges from fear, desperation and pain, covered up by over-indulgence. The chemistry between Melody, Roscoe and Cookie does serve up the necessary ingredients that kept my interest, its energetic material does put some of its overly done plot elements at ease. "The Guitar" does somewhat succeed as a semi-character study of an ill woman, her frail sickly frame and plaintive gestures of sadness does generate sympathy.

"The Guitar" does have missed opportunities in its narrative, it failed to deliver a truly complex character drama and opted to elements which are too predictable for my tastes; it lacked a strong grip on tangibility and realistic inventiveness. Its themes about self-discovery, maturing through disconnection and finding artistic redemption was missing some needed dramatic impact on its narrative. The lively bond between Melody and her new friends brought some sexy scenes of experimentations, and exacerbating chemistry in the screenplay. I thought the acting by Burrows proved to be its main strength as a cancer victim searching for contentment. While the film could have soared a lot, lot higher, I'm happy to say, at least it managed to stay aloft.

Recommended with caution, Rent it first  [3 ½ - Stars]

movie poster

What did you think of this review?

Fun to Read
Post a Comment
November 19, 2011
I have never even heard of this one I don't think, excellent write up WP.
March 03, 2009
I love independent cinema, though you often get a mixed bag. This looks intriguing and as someone who always wanted to play the guitar I should see it. Maybe the prospect of inevitable death will get my ass into gear and force me to learn.
March 08, 2009
Count, I love independent cinema myself--although it is rare that I see something truly awesome--but most of them are imaginative enough. You know how to play the guitar? that's so cool...
March 09, 2009
Nope, you've misunderstood. I was saying that I always wanted to learn how to play the guitar. I've just never had either the immediate talent or the ambition to go about it. Back in high school, a number of my friends played the guitar and I thought about seeing if they'd teach me, but they weren't very good and they wanted me to pay for "lessons'. I guess every teenager, at least every teenaged boy, wants to play the guitar. I was one of those who never did. Still, it might be fun to learn how. I do write songs and it sucks not being able to play.
More The Guitar reviews
Quick Tip by . July 10, 2010
posted in Movie Hype
A very good film that follows the last few months of a woman diagnosed with cancer and nothing to lose.
review by . February 27, 2009
DVD cover
Melody is out-of-work and out-of-love and has just found out she's dying. She decides to spend her remaining days holed up in a penthouse apartment with a phone and her credit cards, and she also wants to rekindle her childhood love affair with a shiny, red electric guitar.     I hadn't heard of this movie and didn't expect it to be any good, but happily, I was wrong! This is a well-made indie film with a compelling script, convincing actors, and clever direction and photography …
review by . March 08, 2009
Short Attention Span Summary (SASS):     1. Once upon a time there was a young woman named Melody (Saffron Burrows)   2. Her doctor (Janeane Garofalo) gives her the truth about life and tumors   3. Her boss gives her the axe   4. Her boyfriend needs space   5. After brief contemplation of death, she decides to live a little   6. She rents a spacious loft on a short term lease, and proceeds to fill it with everything her heart …
About the reviewer
William ()
Ranked #1
Please "Like" Film and Movies and Keep the Economy strong....LOL!!      My Interests: Movies, Anime, History, Martial Arts, Comics, Entertainment,Cooking, Things I don't … more
Consider the Source

Use Trust Points to see how much you can rely on this review.

Your ratings:
rate more to improve this
About this movie


The Guitar is a 2008 drama film about a woman who decides to pursue her dreams after being diagnosed with a terminal illness. The film was directed by Amy Redford, and stars Saffron Burrows, Isaach De Bankolé, Paz de la Huerta, and Richard Short.

view wiki



First to Review

"Surprisingly good"
© 2015 Lunch.com, LLC All Rights Reserved
Lunch.com - Relevant reviews by real people.
This is you!
Ranked #
Last login
Member since