|
Movies Books Music Food Tv Shows Technology Politics Video Games Parenting Fashion Green Living more >

Lunch » Tags » Stephen King » Reviews » The Shining (1980 movie) » User review

The Shining

1980 horror film directed by Stanley Kubrick

< read all 12 reviews

"Heere's Johnny!"

  • Nov 8, 2009
  • by
Rating:
+4
Over the years Stanley Kubrick's "The Shining" has become one of his most well known films, but only because either won't shut up about how it isn't close to the book at all (we hear you, and would invite you to stop reminding us now) or because people are often quick to jump up and say just how much the movie frightens them.  The "Heeeeeeeere's Johnny!" moment is perhaps one of the most quoted lines in Hollywood.  As I've said before, when it comes to movies being adapted from books or being remade from other films etc... I just don't care about whether or not they get it "right."  Those who keep complaining, "The Shining is nothing like the book!" and whine whine whine whine whine whine... well, granted you ARE right, but if I really wanted the book that badly... I'd read the book.  No, instead I like looking at the film as well... a film.  So no, it is nothing like the book.  But let me be the first to tell you that I don't care one way or the other.  We're looking at this as a film and in spite of some of its problems it is still a well done film.  The idea that a movie based off a book is bad just because it doesn't follow the book closely seems relatively dumb to me (even dumber is the idea that a movie that follows the book closely is good... have you guys seen Pet Sematary?). 

You'll probably need no reminder for me what the movie is about.  Kubrick's film as well as King's novel, have become so iconic that just merely hearing the name almost everyone knows it.  Jack Torrance is the winter caretaker for the Overlook Hotel during the off season, and while he's there he is compelled by outside forces (primarily ghost) to kill his wife and child.  The book was a complex beast that couldn't have been easy to adapt.  Kubrick on the other hand, for those wondering, has NEVER given a damn about what the author thinks.  Once the rights of the book have been sold, Kubrick understands that it's HIS project now.  Nicholas Sparks often tells authors, "If you don't want your book being messed with you shouldn't sell the rights."  With Kubrick this is definitely true.  It's not the first time Kubrick didn't care much about what the original author thought.  With a A Clockwork Orange and 2001: A Space Odyssey you can find that Kubrick had clashes with those authors over their works as well (the clash over A Clockwork Orange caused a lot of controversy).  So when it came to The Shining and hearing about the artistic differences between Kubrick and King, I was not at all surprised.

Jack Nicholson plays Jack Torrance.  If there was anything that did grate on my nerves a little bit about Kubrick's interpretation of The Shining... this would be it.  Admittedly, I'm not even a big Jack Nicholson fan to begin with.  The man goes a little overboard in his acting and with The Shining there's no difference here.  We get that Jack Torrance will go crazy... and when he does Nicholson does a brilliant job.  Before Jack loses his mind?  Well, for some reason Jack Nicholson has this creepy, "I'm going to go apeshit crazy," look on his face the ENTIRE film.  If his facial expression changes it is only to smile maniacally.  It actually pulls you out of the film at some points if only because his decent into madness isn't gradual (as the film wants you to believe) but almost sudden.  The moment the movie begins you expect Nicholson to start killing SOMETHING.  It's really not that scary or even suspenseful.

With that aside, however, many of the other aspects of The Shining are pretty good.  Despite Nicholson over-acting and looking like he's going to go crazy the entire film... when things actually DO go crazy, the film becomes fun and even quite scary... but only because Nicholson is actually in a role that calls for this kind of over-the-top acting.  He's not supposed to be charming and fun... he's supposed to be crazy and spooky.  He achieves both.  But the film also makes good use of music and editing shots to achieve this rather well.  Kubrick is known for two things in particular.  The first is being a crazy reshooter.  In a scene here in The Shining he reshot it 127 times.  That's STILL the record for most reshoots ever in a film.  Jack Nicholson and Shelley Duvall were reported to be so tired after shoots that they often went home and immediately collapsed.  The scene that was reshot 127 times?  One of Kubrick's actors (Scatman Crothers) reportedly started crying, "What do you want from me!?" he screamed.  This would all sound crazy if it were any other director, but Kubrick almost never really had a knack for making his actors love him during shooting.  He made them work... and they worked very hard.

The visual flair and overall tone of the movie is what helps it the most in its horror.  The feeling of isolation as the snowstorm comes on in, and even Danny Lloyd playing Danny (how odd is that that two of the actors share the same first name as the characters they play) makes a lot of the film come alive.  And because the use of music is so good many of the film's moments don't come off as being cheesy or anything at all.  The film went on to become a cult success for its time and still holds that cult status today.  You either really love The Shining or you don't.  Putting aside Jack Nicholson's over the top antics just about everything else about the film is put together and produced rather well.  There aren't that many movies that scare me, but Kubrick's version of The Shining is perhaps one of the only horror movies that makes me feel scared at any point in time.  This is mostly because so much of what it does it does well.  It's not overly violent like so many horror movies out there and I think that actually helps because now instead of going to see the movie for the sake of seeing people die, we're actually going to see if they survive.  And horror is always scarier when we fear for the characters rather than hoping for them to die.  Some diagree with this sentiment, but for me the movies that scare me are the ones where we desperately want those in trouble to live.  The Shining isn't "torture porn" it's authentic horror.  The type of horror that we rarely see in mainstream cinema anymore.

Now onto the other big thing about The Shining.  By now it is no secret that Stephen King didn't like Kubrick's version of The Shining.  King hated it so much he bought the rights of the film himself and did a 1997 television mini-series.  King's hatred of Kubrick's film became so bad that in order for him to buy the rights back King had to sign a contract saying he wouldn't publically slander Kubrick's film ever again.  Ten years after Kubrick's death, King still holds true to that agreement (King never hated Kubrick himself--King even speaks fondly of him) and refuses to talk about Kubrick's version of The Shining publically. 

In short, yes, if you're a purist of the book and one of those people who believes an adaptation has to be accurate to be good... you're not going to like The Shining.  To get upset at Kubrick for not following the book is to misunderstand Kubrick himself.  The man has always done what he wanted to do and never done what others wanted him to do.  But just because it doesn't follow the book to a tee (in the credits it might as well have said, "Inspired By The Shining by Stephen King" rather than saying "based off the book by Stephen King.") shouldn't suggest the movie is bad in anyway.  It's not.  And those who say it is are too emotionally invested in the book and King to step back and actually accept it for what it is.  It makes no sense to hate an apple because it's not an orange.  For Kubrick it was never about what King or his audience wanted.  It was about what he wanted and what he wanted to do.  And it should be.  The film is, after all, Kubrick's creation.  The book was Stephen King's.  The 1997 mini-series was Stephen King's.  This particular version of The Shining is Stanley Kubrick's.  I'll go as far as to say that had he been closer to King's book it might've enhanced certain things about the film (particularly Jack's descent into madness which is a bit too sudden here) but I keep thinking that there were some aspects Kubrick's film that on film are better.  Let us take the weapon of choice Jack uses to go after Wendy and Danny.  In the book he uses one of the hotel's rogue mallets.  In this film he uses an axe.  Now, in the book the rogue mallet approach is fine, but you only need to look at that 1997 adaptation to see that on film there's not much creepy about it (but that may be because that's horribly directed).  There are certain approaches to the film that do hold up rather well.  And this is because books and films are two completely different animals.  What works well in a book (like that rogue mallet) just might not work too well on film.

In the end, Kubrick's film is actually a good film.  It has a cult following for a reason (Kubrick himself is a director with a cult following), and that's because for those who like Kubrick, it's nice to see his approach to this genre in particular.  It doesn't hold a candle up to some of his better works such as Dr. Strangelove, A Clockwork Orange or 2001: A Space Odyssey, but it still manages to be a bold film all on its own.

What did you think of this review?

Helpful
3
Thought-Provoking
3
Fun to Read
3
Well-Organized
3
Post a Comment
November 08, 2009
You always talk about me being a good movie reviewer, but you're damn good yourself. Great review. I for one is pretty tired of folks complaining that the film wasn't faithful to the book, this film was great; period. This was Kubrick's version and I couldn't agree with you more; I find Nicholson's acting style a little too over the top at times but there are roles that really fit his style. The mini-series was more faithful to the book, but the pacing was a little off as far as I can remember.
 
1
More The Shining (1980 movie) reviews
review by . October 09, 2011
posted in Movie Hype
**** out of ****     Some of the best films are the ones which provoke us to return to their often questionable realms for a second coming, not long after we've tried to - or succeeded in - absorb every last bit of information that we possibly can. Perhaps we come back because we still have questions left unanswered, or maybe we just want to experience it all again. The places that I speak of are sometimes pleasant (the beach resort of "Mr. Hulot's Holiday"), and other times …
Quick Tip by . March 09, 2013
Caption
Shot for the title sequence of Stanley Kubrick's film adaption of The Shining, supererogatory footage of Montana's Glacier National Park was subsequently exploited by Ridley Scott to supplement the denouement of Blade Runner's theatrical cut. Actor Joe Turkel plays important roles in both pictures. Featured prominently in The Shining, Scatman Crothers had previously portrayed an orderly named Turkle in One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest, twice co-starring with leading man Jack Nicholson. …
Quick Tip by . January 14, 2012
posted in Movie Hype
While I still haven't chosen which Kubrick movie is my favorite, The Shining is easily one of my favorite movies ever.  Since I'm not one that's easy to scare, this movie is one of the extremely rare specimens that'll haunt me when I go to bed after watching it.  Even though all the acting is top-notch, it's Jack Nicholson that stole the show in this one because he was PERFECT as the isolated man on a descent into total madness.      Thanks to this …
review by . March 16, 2010
posted in Movie Hype
An excersie in what isolation can do to the mind...
They say that sometimes when a person is isolated from other people  or things he or she is familiar  with  you start to slowly loose your mind, you start seeing things  that  aren't real, hearing voices in your head, walking nightmares. It is called Cabin Fever and In Stanley Kubrick's psychological horror thriller explores what happens when a recovering alcoholic ex-teacher (Jack Nicholson) starts to literally loose his mind   when isolated in a beautiful hotel …
Quick Tip by . July 04, 2010
posted in Movie Hype
Kubrick's classic adaption of Steven King's classic horror novel is errie and amazing to watch. Strays far from the source material in some places and drags on in scenes but it does help add to the tension of a family taking care of a mountain hotel and the father slowly going insane.
review by . May 06, 2009
The Shining was Stanley Kubrick's attempt to make a bona fide horror film. Despite the fact that he has never really directed one, he was infatuated with the project. He read the novel by Stephen King and set out to recreate the novel, his own way. What we get is a cold ans sterile film that resembles the original source material some what. We get a maniacal and crazed Jack Nicholson, a doormat Shelly Duvall and a minor actor/performer Scatman Crothers a shot a some big time acting. The actors were …
review by . December 30, 2008
posted in Movie Hype
Pros: Duvall     Cons: the talking finger & cast speech patterns     The Bottom Line:   "Come on you raver, you seer of visions,   come on you painter, you piper, you prisoner, and shine!"  ~Pink Floyd         Although The Shining is considered one of the classic horror movies and there is much to love about the film, there are also some glaring negatives as well.  That certainly …
review by . February 12, 2008
posted in Movie Hype
Though me and my mom normally share various points of views on certain film makers, we tend to split when it comes to Stanley Kubrick. My mom says, "he's so weird." I tell her "yeah, but he's a brilliant film maker, who films visually stunning films that are also mesmerizing." To this she just shrugs and says, "I don't care, he's still weird." Though a big fan of the director, for some reason his 80's horror film, "The Shining," escaped me for the longest time. Based off the best selling book by …
review by . October 31, 2007
(4 1/2 *'s) After all these years, I hedged at the prospect of watching `The Shining`. Having seen the snippets of Jack Nicholson's skillful performance, I partly dismissed the movie. In my mind, thinking of his famous line, "Here's Johnny!" the film seemed a novelty, something entertaining in a way it wasn't intended. Between Stanley Kubrick's amazing direction and Nicholson's and Shelly Duvall's excellent performances, first impressions can be misleading. Watching `The Shining' is a real treat.   & …
review by . October 31, 2002
posted in Movie Hype
Pros: Jack Nicholson is one of the world's great psycho actors     Cons: May make you paranoid     The Bottom Line: Here's Johnny! I love that.     Just what do you think of when you think of a haunted house? The stereotypical haunted house is little more than a large shack, very loosely boarded up with rotting wood, creaking floorboards and stairs, loose doors and a massive maze of codwebs. The ghosts that often haunt these places are …
About the reviewer
Sean A. Rhodes ()
Ranked #6
I'm a more analytical person. I believe that the purpose of the review is not for me to give you my opinion but for me to give you an analysis and help you decide if you want to get it. If you reading … more
Consider the Source

Use Trust Points to see how much you can rely on this review.

You
Sean_Rhodes
Your ratings:
rate more to improve this
About this movie

Wiki

A horror film directed by Stanley Kubrick based upon the bestselling novel by Stephen King.

Opening with spectacular aerial shots of a beautiful, mountainous landscape, Stanley Kubrick's horror classic THE SHINING sucks the viewer into his frightening tale with quiet, relaxing visuals--but the ominous soundtrack warns that all is not right at the gorgeous Overlook Hotel. Based on Stephen King's best-selling novel, the film stars Jack Nicholson at his eyebrow-raising best in his portrayal of Jack Torrance, a Vermont schoolteacher working at the Overlook as a winter caretaker. The glorious early-20th century resort only operates in warm weather because the snowy roads deny access in the colder months, so Jack brings his wife, Wendy (Shelley Duvall), with him, as well as his young son, Danny (Danny Lloyd), who possesses some unique psychic powers. As the Torrances settle in for the long, lonely months ahead, strange, unexplainable things start occurring in the hotel--and in every scene Jack seems to be growing a little more evil and dangerous.... <br> <br> Cinematographer John Alcott (who also wo...
view wiki
Polls with this movie
A Nightmare on Elm Street

Horror Flicks

by

First to Review
© 2014 Lunch.com, LLC All Rights Reserved
Lunch.com - Relevant reviews by real people.
()
This is you!
Ranked #
Last login
Member since
reviews
comments
ratings
questions
compliments
lists