Movies Books Music Food Tv Shows Technology Politics Video Games Parenting Fashion Green Living more >

Lunch » Tags » Movies » Reviews » Thinner (1996 movie) » User review


The film based on the book by Stephen King

< read all 1 reviews

Jenny Craig Has Nothing On This "CURSED" Diet!

  • Oct 26, 2009

“Thinner” was the 25th book by Stephen King (boy, I’d love to meet his agent) to be adapted to a full length film. The book was under one of his pseudonymous Richard Bachman novels with the same name as this film. Remember the old adage; “You can never be too rich or too thin”? Well, obviously, whoever said that haven’t seen or read the tale behind “THINNER” (1996). I wouldn’t complain about becoming too rich; but thin like this, count me out. Part horror film, part morality tale and part action drama, "Thinner" is also part guilty pleasure.
William “Billy” Halleck (Robert John Burke) is an obese big-shot attorney who had just won a defense case for mobster Richie Ginelli (John Mantegno) who now holds him in high regard. Given a lot of credit for his victory by his associates, Halleck is treated to a nice victory dinner that evening. On the drive home, Billy is being treated by his wife Heidi (Lucinda Jenny) to dessert when he hits an old woman accidentally. However, Billy with all his connections, is barely given a spanking and avoids a manslaughter charge in a small proceeding that is a mockery of a trial. Lucky for Billy that his friends are looking out for him; unluckily for him the old woman that he had killed accidentally is the daughter of Tadzu Lempke, a 106 year old king of the gypsies. Tadzu now wants revenge upon all those who had wronged his family and wishes Billy to become thinner…
Most King adaptations are either good, mediocre or really bad; “Misery”, “The Shawshank Redemption” and “The Shining” were good, but honestly most King adaptations are pretty mediocre. “Thinner” may not be the best and I haven’t read the book so I really cannot judge how well this movie is faithful to its source material. I would assume that it is pretty close although most of the adaptations were never written by King himself. The film’s screenplay is written by Michael McDowell and the director, Tom Holland. The film isn’t so much about scares and foreboding atmosphere, it plays more like a morality tale that questions what is right and what is wrong. Is it wrong to use one’s connections to avoid jail time or is it wrong to seek justice through the use of extreme means? The film does ask the correct questions, as a ‘curse’ is definitely evil but was it necessary? I all depends on how you think.
It was clear that Billy wasn’t at fault and it was an accident but the injustice was that he never went through a real court proceeding. The judge hated gypsies and was more than happy to make the proceedings a lot easier for Billy. There was a red flag when Billy and an associate were checking out Tadzu’s granddaughter Gina (played by luscious Kari Wuhrer) that these group of people dabbles in the occult, as she seemed to know what they were talking about although they were a few stories up. I guess this scene serves as a quick characterization and makes Tadzu’s reaction that much more credible. Well, we also get to see Kari Wuhrer’s black panties so there is one acceptable plot device.
The horror elements of the film actually come from Billy’s accelerated lost of body weight; Billy would try to gorge himself to try and gain some of the weight back. Some of the make up effects on our obese Billy may seem rather obvious but I would have to say that they were nicely done. I remember the feeling I got out of watching David Cronenberg’s “The Fly”, as the longer I got into the film, the more I dreaded how Billy would look like in the next frame. Billy Halleck was becoming too thin no matter how much he ate. During these sequences, the make up effects were more polished as Billy began to look more like a ghoul than a human.
Now as soon as the movie somewhat abandons its horror elements, it becomes a sort of a revenge flick with action that opens up several plot holes and gaps. Richie “The Hammer” Ginelli (nicely portrayed by Mantegno) is your ruthless mobster and he knows a thing or two about gypsy curses; the way he sprang into action for Billy was very entertaining although the film could have used better dialogue to portray this character. I liked the approach to the getting the curse lifted as each action grew more severe than the other; but what I found it hard to buy into is the fact that the gypsies gave up too easily. I guess the old man didn’t want his granddaughter to be subjected to such danger. I would have wished that the movie would have brought in Gina’s reaction to the old man’s decision. The film also has the stereotypical “dream” sequence that has plagued most of King’s movie adaptations. It wasn’t bad but it sure didn’t help the film any.
The film does have its touches of black humor about eating but does not go too far enough to make its point. The subplot with Billy’s wife Heidi and a certain Doctor “Mikey” was touched on but never given a solid answer. It may have been just paranoia in Billy’s part but there is evidence that the two were playing whoopee with one another. (after all, Mikey likes to touch Heidi’s thighs) This is where we get to the film’s resolution as another question of morality springs into play; would you wish your misfortune to be suffered by another or should one just accept his fate?
“Thinner” may not become a classic but it is also a lot of fun. Stephen King himself plays a cameo as the doctor Banjor and sexy vixen Kari Wuhrer adds a lot of ‘zing‘ even for her limited screen time. It is the ultimate tale of eating to death or eating to stay alive; it may also be a ghoulish satire about losing weight if you see it from a lighter viewpoint. I really liked this film the first time I saw it, but this second time, I can really see its faults. A lot of the film’s flaws come from its failure to exploit its potential for torture and dread, even its black humor was touched upon but abandoned in favor of a run-of-the-mill chase thriller that forgets the movie was meant to be an occult thriller. The film’s concept was presented but never fully followed through.
Recommended with caution, rent it first [3 Stars]


What did you think of this review?

Fun to Read
Post a Comment
October 27, 2009
I tried watching this. Honest to God, I tried.  But I just couldn't get through it.  Not because it was bad, but because every time I always have to go somewhere or do something.  All I can remember is that the acting was pretty bad so far (and Stephen King's cameo which was... amusing... that guy wears the thickest glasses EVER!).  
October 30, 2009
I was laughing when I saw him with those glasses. Doesn't he usually do a cameo for the movie adaptations?
November 23, 2009
I remember the first time I EVER saw him in a movie--it was George Romero's KNIGHTRIDERS and he looked like he had Chicklets for teeth. He was the very definition of "geek".
October 26, 2009
It's such a cliche, but either a Stephen King-based film is either a masterpiece or a complete crap. This is one of the few exceptions where it's kind of mediocre.
October 27, 2009
what's your favorite King adaptations?
October 27, 2009
Probably, "Shawshank Redemption", "Stand by Me", "Misery", and "Carrie". I also really liked "Dolores Claiborne".
October 27, 2009
was THE GREEN MILE also by King? can't remember...
October 27, 2009
Yeah, it was. I liked that film but not nearly as much as the ones above. I also never read the books since it's hard to find them all in one volume and as you know, I'm dirt cheap. ; )
About the reviewer
William ()
Ranked #1
Please "Like" Film and Movies and Keep the Economy strong....LOL!!      My Interests: Movies, Anime, History, Martial Arts, Comics, Entertainment,Cooking, Things I don't … more
Consider the Source

Use Trust Points to see how much you can rely on this review.

Your ratings:
rate more to improve this
About this movie
First to Review
© 2015 Lunch.com, LLC All Rights Reserved
Lunch.com - Relevant reviews by real people.
This is you!
Ranked #
Last login
Member since