Movies Books Music Food Tv Shows Technology Politics Video Games Parenting Fashion Green Living more >

Lunch » Tags » Movies » Reviews » Troy » User review

Troy (Two-Disc Widescreen Edition) (2004)

A movie directed by Wolfgang Petersen

< read all 7 reviews

Misses the point of the mythology

  • Dec 13, 2008
  • by

In recent times, Hollywood has sparked a renewed interest in the great epics of ancient Greece.  May 14th of 2004 brought the release of Troy starring Brad Pitt.  Before this, there were countless miniseries, movies, and TV shows, both accurately and inaccurately, depicting the mythological life of Homer's great epic heroes.  Included among these was a wonderful NBC mini-series called The Odyssey, which, in fact, covered both of the poems of Homer to some extent.  There is a great difference though, between the stories told today and the stories told in ancient times, even if both fall under the title of the Iliad or the Odyssey.  This isn't surprising, given the enormous disparity between ancient audiences and modern day audiences and the fact that the current "Homers," the Spielbergs and the Raimis, use a very different medium from that of the ancient Homer.  The great difference is the ultimate cause of action in the stories.  While in the text of Homer, Sarpedon defines the heroic code as taking greater risks in order to win honor and undying fame, Hektor in Troy, defines his code as "Honor the gods, love your woman, and defend your country."[1]  When Homer sang to his ancient audiences, he sang of honor as being the ultimate cause of the great political maneuvers in the Trojan War and its aftermath but today, when one goes to see a depiction of the Iliad or the Odyssey it is love that serves as the key factor in said action.

The first instance that should be taken into consideration would be the Judgment of Paris.  While never occurring in the text, Richmond Lattimore, in his brilliant translation of the Iliad, states quite plainly in the introduction, the proposition that "the ultimate cause of the Trojan War was the judgment of Paris."[2]  Where the text differs from most modern adaptations of the story is how this event leads to war, why Menelaus chooses to act.  In the Iliad, Helen's seizure is completely viewed a matter of honor.  Achilleus makes that clear when he shouts in Book One, to Agamemnon, that "for your sake, o great shamelessness, we followed, to do you favor, you with the dog's eyes, to win your honor and Menelaus' from the Trojans."[3] 

In Troy, the ultimate cause of the war, while still the Judgment of Paris, is a matter of love, not honor.  In the movie it is very apparent to the viewing audience that Helen is not abducted by Paris at all.  Rather, she goes willingly with him, having fallen in love with him.  Helen says to Paris, "I'm afraid of watching you sail away and never coming back."[4]  The audiences get a kick out of this.  There is nothing the American public seems to enjoy more than a forbidden romance between star crossed lovers.  In any case, Helen is miserable with Menelaus and does not love him.  Therefore, she runs off with Paris.  Instead of Paris slighting the honor of Menelaus, it is Helen's action in the name of love that incites the Trojan War.  Hektor advises Paris to return Helen, but Paris merely replies, "I love her."

A second instance to explore also deals with the capture of a woman, since dishonor is often achieved through a woman connected with a Homeric hero.  This instance is in Book One of the text, the story dealing with the seizure of Briseis, the concubine of Achilleus, by Agamemnon.  In hoping to rebuild his honor after the loss of his own war bride, Agamemnon seizes Briseis, angrily asking Achilleus, "What do you want?  To keep your own prize and have me sit here lacking one?"[5]  Although tempted to engage in combat with Agamemnon, Achilleus is advised by Athene to sit back and wait.  He obeys, but nevertheless, his pride has been hurt and this leads to a profound consequence for the Greeks.  The seizure of Achilleus' concubine by Agamemnon is the catalyst for the changing of the tide of battle because Achilleus withdraws due to a slight of his honor and asks his divine mother, Thetis, to get Zeus: "to help the Trojans, and pin the Achaians back against the ships and the water, dying, so that thus they may all have profit of their own king, that Atreus' son wide-ruling Agamemnon may recognize his madness, that he did no honor to the best of the Achaians."[6]  In other words, he wants Zeus to turn the tide of battle.  This is going to have profound political impact, as illustrated later in the poem and therefore, it can be considered a political action. 

The story changes somewhat in Troy.  True, Achilleus has been dishonored by having his concubine stolen, but in the movie it is evident that the reason Achilleus withdraws is because he has fallen in love with her.  In Homer, it is often interpreted that Achilleus is actually in love with Patroklos, his comrade in arms.  Modern day, homophobic audiences would never approve of Brad Pitt having a romantic relationship with a man on screen, so Briseis is substituted as an emergency heterosexual relationship and thus once again, the film version of Homer's story plays to modern day audiences' values.  Agamemnon certainly sees things that way.  Upon encountering Briseis, he angrily growls, "I almost lost this war because of your little romance."[7]  In case there's any doubt about Achilleus' feelings, it should be noted that on his dying breath, he utters to Briseis, "You gave me peace in a lifetime of war."[8]

Dishonor is not exclusively a matter of the bride stealing pattern.  Another way to dishonor a hero, which is in some ways easier, is to usurp or question his power.  Odysseus deals with this problem in abundance in the Odyssey when he returns home after his odyssey to find dozens of suitors seeking his wife and his property.  The slight to Odysseus' honor has been identified and it will serve as a political catalyst.  Odysseus kills all the suitors in his home when they devour his possessions.  At first, this might seem more like a personal act than a political act, but in examining the individuals slaughtered by Odysseus and his son, one can determine that there is a massive political impact in the decision to massacre.  In his introduction to the Odyssey, Richmond Lattimore discusses the significance of the grisly ending.  Theorizing why Homer chose to end the song the way he did, Lattimore states that "it certainly demands some kind of patch-up of the chaotic situation in Ithaka, where ‘all the best young men' (i.245) are lying dead."[9]  The key phrase is "best young men."  Odysseus has murdered the finest men of Ithaka.  There is absolutely no way an action of this magnitude can escape having political consequences.  Suppose Ithaka were to enter into another war?  All of Odysseus' companions from Troy are dead.  The men that might replace them have been murdered.

Difficult as it is to stomach, Odysseus' actions are not censored in modern adaptations of the story.  In 1997, Francis Ford Coppola served as the executive producer for an NBC miniseries titled The Odyssey, starring Armand Assante as Odysseus and Greta Scacchi as Penelope.[10]  This movie emphasizes the mutual love of husband and wife from the very beginning, when Odysseus is shown standing by Penelope's side as she gives birth to their son Telemachos.  Whereas the Odysseus for Homer's audience sleeps with Circe and Kalypso during his odyssey, Francis Ford Coppola's Odysseus is completely faithful to the wife that he loves, resisting temptation.  When he returns home, seeing the suitors pursue his wife harms his emotional well being, not his honor.  Troy also touches on this romance when Odysseus, desperate to persuade Achilles to join the battle, mentions that Penelope would feel safer with Odysseus going off to war if Achilles was at his side.  This great concern for his wife's emotional well being seems absent in Homer.

Just as in Homer's time, when epic created an acute interest in the past, history is repeating itself.  There is a new interest in the stories of Homer that has been brewing for the last decade.  While it's true that the catalyst for political action in the epics of Homer has shifted from a slight to honor to emotional involvement because of the shifting values of the audiences, the purpose of Homer is still being fulfilled.  Homer sang to entertain his audiences.  Part of entertaining them was telling about the social norms they related to best.  Since social norms have changed, it seems that the modern day tellers of Homer's epics are merely doing the same thing he did.  They are simply attempting to reach their audiences through the norms which they are most familiar with.  One might argue that this is keeping Homer's stories alive.  For those of the American public who don't enjoy a good love story…well…there's always plenty of honor being discussed on Star Trek.  The rest of us will enjoy Troy.

[1] Troy

[2] Lattimore 23

[3] Iliad (1. 157-160)

[4] Troy

[5] Iliad (1. 133-134)

[6] Iliad (1. 408-412)

[7] Troy

[8] Troy

[9] Lattimore 18

What did you think of this review?

Fun to Read
Post a Comment
March 11, 2009
Wow, footnotes and everything. I confess that I saw this merely because I wanted to see how they handled the mytholgical references to Achillles' invincibility--which of course they didn't. Not even a passing mention of his mother and the river. Although I thought that pulling the arrows that actually killed him out of chest, leaving only the one in heel was cute.
More Troy reviews
review by . April 30, 2009
If you liked the recent King Arthur or the Lord of the Rings movies, you should like this one. Everything about it was excellent from the cinematography, to the acting, with excellent action. The battle between Hector and Achilles is epic. Peter O'Toole is excellent, in probably his best role in years.     The makers took great liberties changing the story around from the myth with great success. Having known about the Trojan horse and how everything was going to work out in …
review by . November 17, 2008
If "Camelot" is the romanticized version of "King Arthur", then "The Iliad" went through an extreme makeover for "Troy".     There are enough pretty faces to launch several thousand ships, and I'm not even talking about Helen here. The main attractions are ripped biceps, chiseled chins, sculpted chests and smooth, bronzed legs.     This is another arrow-full movie, with lots of big battle scenes and gritty hand-to-hand combat, but be warned that an entire …
review by . September 06, 2008
posted in Movie Hype
Pros: Onslaught of action, sheer scope     Cons: Extremely stupid. Doesn't require the attention span of a typical epic     The Bottom Line: Were the 2004 Trojans the best team ever?     Troy, when it was released, proved to be Orlando Bloom’s latest step in what is apparently becoming an inexplicable – not to mention completely doomed – quest to become the next Charlton Heston. Take a quick glance at his movie resume …
review by . February 27, 2005
posted in Movie Hype
If you liked the recent King Arthur or the Lord of the Rings movies, you should like this one. Everything about it was excellent from the cinematography, to the acting, with excellent action. The battle between Hector and Achilles is epic. Peter O'Toole is excellent, in probably his best role in years.     The makers took great liberties changing the story around from the myth with great success. Having known about the Trojan horse and how everything was going to work out in …
review by . February 01, 2005
posted in Movie Hype
Based loosely on Homer's Iliad, this film recreates the Trojan war in telescoped form, compressing a decade and more of momentous events into a few weeks of political maneuvering and a few days of outright fighting. It succeeds in a variety of ways.     It creates an authentic seeming eastern Mediterranean bronze age world, not infected by the latter day Greece of classical times (which is more familiar to us), and thereby establishes a convincing cultural backdrop for the decisions …
review by . May 29, 2004
posted in Movie Hype
Pros: Spectacular battle scene, Brad Pitt’s portrayal of Achilles.      Cons: Omission of Greek gods directly effecting events detracts from the story.     The Bottom Line: Troy the movie is spectacular. And while the story does not remain true to what Homer penned some 3,000 years ago, it does offer plenty of engaging, old-fashioned action.      Plot Details: This opinion reveals minor details about the movie''s plot. Like most children …
About the reviewer
Jessica ()
Ranked #832
It is my ultimate literary goal in life to be to ancient Greece what Philippa Gregory is to Tudor England. Only better.
Consider the Source

Use Trust Points to see how much you can rely on this review.

Your ratings:
rate more to improve this
About this movie


There are many reasons to recommendTroyas a good ol' fashioned Hollywood epic, especially if you've never read Homer'sThe Iliad. Dispensing with Greek gods altogether, this earnestly massive production (budgeted at upwards of $200 million) will surely offend historians and devoted students of the classics (for them, there's theHistory Channel's Troy). But there's politics aplenty in the grand-scale war that erupts when Trojan prince Paris (Orlando Bloom) makes off with Helen (blandly beautiful German model Diane Kruger), wife of Spartan ruler Menelaus (Brendan Gleeson), whose brother, the Greek king Agamemnon (Brian Cox) prods him into enraged retaliation. Greek warrior Achilles (Brad Pitt) brings lethal force to his battles (and there are many of them, mostly impressive), and his Trojan counterpart, Paris's brother Hector (Eric Bana), adds even more buffed-up beefcake to a film so chock-full o' hunks that there's barely room for Peter O'Toole (doing fine work as Trojan king Priam) and even less for Julie Christie, appearing ever-so-briefly as Achilles's melancholy mother. The drama is nearly as arid as the sun-baked locations (Mexico and Malta) that stand in for the Aegean coast, and many critics suggested that Pitt (who valiantly tries to give Achilles some tormented dimension) was simply miscast. But when you consider that Wolfgang Petersen also madeThe Perfect Storm, there's nothing wrong with enjoyingTroyas a semi-guilty ...
view wiki


Director: Wolfgang Petersen
Genre: Action, Adventure, Foreign, War
DVD Release Date: January 4, 2005
Runtime: 163 minutes
Studio: Warner Home Video
© 2015 Lunch.com, LLC All Rights Reserved
Lunch.com - Relevant reviews by real people.
This is you!
Ranked #
Last login
Member since