Movies Books Music Food Tv Shows Technology Politics Video Games Parenting Fashion Green Living more >

Lunch » Tags » Movies » Reviews » We Are Marshall » User review

We Are Marshall

A movie directed by Joseph McGinty

< read all 3 reviews


  • Mar 27, 2008
  • by
Pros: See Review

Cons: None

The Bottom Line: "WE ARE (ALL) MARSHALL."

Plot Details: This opinion reveals minor details about the movie''s plot.

It is rare these days that a movie is deep and meaningful enough to elicit genuine emotion. We are Marshall (2006), which chronicles the horrible plane crash that took the lives of 75 people in 1970 including (almost) the entire Marshall University football team, and it aftermath, is certainly one. Going into this movie I expected a feel-good-can-do-American sprit movie; what I didn’t expect was that they would do such a fine job of making me care about it all.

The Story-Line

Directed by Joseph McGinty Nichol a.k.a. McG (The O.C., Chuck, Supernatural) We Are Marshall begins with Annie Cantrell (Kate Mara - Nip/Tuck, Shooter) the fiancée of one of the dead players, narrating as the tragedy that was the plane crash of November 14, 1970 unfolds on the screen. The Thundering Herd football team of Marshall University in Huntington, West Virginia had just lost a home game and were flying to their next match up when the team plane crashed, killing all aboard.

The Varsity team was wiped out save four seniors and the team had to be re-built from scratch. The university president Dr. Dedmon (David Strathaim – Silkwood, City of Hope) brings in Jack Lengyel (Matthew McConaughey – Angels in the Outfield, Boys on the Side, A Time to Kill) to coach the team, after Red Dawson (Matthew Fox – Party of Five, Haunted, Lost) the only surviving member of the Marshall University athletic department, turns him down. Dawson would later come back as assistant coach.

Lengyel has quirky, unconventional ways of doing everything, from remembering players’ names (though I use that method as well), to motivating the team, to approaching a rival team to let him have unfettered access to their playbook. But he manages to pull together a new team made up mostly of freshman and juniors, and wins the towns support for his efforts.

There are a few resisters, chiefly Paul Griffen (Ian McShane – Madson, Lovejoy, Deadwood), whose son was killed in the plane crash. He holds considerable sway over the university board, but in time even he is won over. After all what is more American than football?

My thoughts

We Are Marshall is of course formulaic, but that does not stop one from caring deeply about the characters. The movie is less about football and the mechanics of the game than is about the impact of the tragedy upon a typical town in West Virginia, and the people who helped put the pieces together again. It is so very human and therein lays its appeal.

We Are Marshall isn’t a deep movie, McG did not dig deeply into the lives of those involved, indeed we know these people only on the surface, but in this case a cursory understanding is all that is needed. McG deftly intersperse hard-hitting football action with close-up emotional torment; tears flow freely from the eyes of men and woman in this film with equal eagerness, and it had an effect on this reviewer. From quivering hands to beseeching swelling eyes, to simmering anger, the cast opens the door to the emotional toll such a tragedy must have taken on such a close-knit American town like Huntington WV. We Are Marshall is a quintessential American tale, full of bravado, and misplaced quilt and emotional torment, and I loved almost every minute of it!

Every member of the cast did a masterful job of bringing this story to life. McConaughey and Fox were both inspiring, as was Anthony Mackie (The Manchurian Candidate, Million Dollar Baby, Freedomland) who portrayed Nate Ruffin the senior who rallied the university student body to force the board to listen and re-constitute the football team. Other notable cast members include January Jones, Kimberly Williams, and Arlen Escarpeta.


We Are Marshall is an unabashedly sentimental, but inspiring movie that leans heavily on McConaughey’s and substantial energy and charisma as well as Fox’s quiet, dignified strength for its success. And succeed it does as a story well worth telling about a town and University well worth knowing. “WE ARE (ALL) MARSHALL.”


Viewing Format: DVD
Video Occasion: Good for Groups
Suitability For Children: Suitable for Children Age 9 - 12

What did you think of this review?

Fun to Read
Post a Comment
More We Are Marshall reviews
review by . November 01, 2008
Another movie based on sports   This time a football team   That rose up from the ashes   Of the ending of a dream     The Thundering Herd was heading home   And then disaster hit   Their plane came in a bit too low   And sadly, that was it     The board that ran the college tried   To shut the program down   But had to reconsider   When petitioned by the town     The …
review by . October 10, 2008
posted in Movie Hype
Pros: ...     Cons: ...     The Bottom Line:   "Cause out on the edge of darkness, there rides a peace train  Oh peace train take this country, come take me home again"  ~Cat Stevens         The story of We Are Marshall is one of hope and inspiration. Unlike Rudy, The Natural, or other stories of that tell of one person overcoming the odds, this one tells about the devastation and rebirth …
About the reviewer
Vincent Martin ()
Ranked #187
I am an IT Professional and have worked in the industry for over 20 years. I may be a computer geek, but I also like reading, writing, cooking, music, current events and regretfully, politics.
Consider the Source

Use Trust Points to see how much you can rely on this review.

Your ratings:
rate more to improve this
First to Review
© 2015 Lunch.com, LLC All Rights Reserved
Lunch.com - Relevant reviews by real people.
This is you!
Ranked #
Last login
Member since