Movies Books Music Food Tv Shows Technology Politics Video Games Parenting Fashion Green Living more >

Lunch » Tags » Untagged » Against Their Will: North Carolina's Sterilization Program and the campaign for reparations » User review

Haunting, giving voice to the silent

  • Jan 11, 2013
I read mostly fiction but every once in a while a non-fiction book comes along that I can’t resist, and Against their will is just such a one. I knew nothing of North Carolina’s sterilization program as I started to read, and I want to tell myself these things could never  happen now, but I’m not sure I can. “Experts” argue the case for sterilization of individuals in these historically accurate documents. Their words are transliterated by non-experts, analyzed by committee, and turned into judicial pronouncements leaving human lives torn apart. I find myself wondering what experts are saying now and how the rights of individuals are so easily lost in the application of laws.
That the sterilization program was still in effect so very recently astounds me. That individuals could be denied reparation in the courts over long years of arguing their case, that science could have been twisted and co-opted this way, that World War II’s evil eugenics had so amazingly little impact... But the articles collected in this book have a deeper purpose. They show a country where journalists are willing to ask the tough questions, find the victims and give them voice, and where people are willing to read and willing to change. And that gives me hope.
“We Americans tend to ignore our past,” the editor quotes from filmmaker Ken Burns in his introduction, reminding readers of the dangers of repeating what we do not examine. The book contains a pleasing mix of articles written at different dates, where genuine victims of the program come forward and reappear like old friends asking us to listen and listen again, where clear statistics and honest investigation reveal how common belief unquestioningly denies uncommon truth, and where the greater good is neither great nor good, whatever the words may say. Each article stands on its own, but the inevitable touches of repetition serve only to emphasize. Read together, the articles pull the reader in to wanting more for the victims, hoping to hear more, wishing things had been different. From the horrors of a 1947 poem, to churches so carefully choosing which topics will appall them, to the tragedies of Lumbee Indians, and ancient arguments about purity, this book amazes and saddens while engaging and enthralling me. Economics, medical experiment, social uniformity… Behind it all are real human beings, wounded by real human beings. And all of us are vulnerable, either to being hurt or to hurting others. All of us should care and be vigilant.
Disclosure: I was given a free copy of this book with a request for my honest review.

What did you think of this review?

Fun to Read
Post a Comment
About the reviewer
Sheila Deeth ()
Ranked #44
Sheila Deeth's first novel, Divide by Zero, has just been released in print and ebook formats. Find it on Amazon, Barnes and Noble, Powells, etc. Her spiritual speculative novellas can be found at … more
About this product


Readers see what happens when medical decisions are made without informed consent by bureaucracies using faulty, biased science. An important, heartbreaking addition to writings on medical ethics and the history of medicine. ---Library Journal, March 9, 2012

The Winston-Salem Journal ran a series of articles on eugenics, prompting official apologies and initial legislative efforts aimed at compensating victims. ---New York Times, Dec. 9, 2011

These articles raised awareness about the modern eugenics program, revealing its workings, the lasting pain of its victims, and even speculating upon how genetic testing could lead to new forms of eugenics. Now as North Carolina is about to pay reparations to those who suffered from forced sterilization, their story is both chilling and an invaluable lesson in state abuse of power that must be remembered, lest it be repeated. A must-have for social issues collections, Against Their Will is highly recommended. ---Midwest Book Review, March 2, 2012
view wiki



First to Review
© 2014 Lunch.com, LLC All Rights Reserved
Lunch.com - Relevant reviews by real people.
This is you!
Ranked #
Last login
Member since