Movies Books Music Food Tv Shows Technology Politics Video Games Parenting Fashion Green Living more >

Lunch » Tags » Books » Reviews » Kindle 3G Wireless Reading Device » User review

Amazon Kindle 3 3G / Wi-Fi eBook Reader

The third generation of Amazon's wireless reading device.

< read all 4 reviews

Kindle 3G makes black and white screen cool again. And the free 3G web and email works really well

  • Oct 2, 2010

The newest Amazon Kindle 3G makes black and white screen cool again with their newest e-ink technology. While I hesitated to give Kindle 3 a try because I like the feel or real paper and I initially thought it will probably take a generation before paper books will become obsolete, the idea (of convenience) of having all your books on a single device is so appealing and I decided to check what the fuss is all about with this electronic reading device. I tried the nook first before settling down with the Kindle 3G. I'm not going to talk about the book reading experience since many people has covered it and I will talk more about the web experience (and some tips on how to check your web mail etc) which I think is really good especially if you set your expectation right. And if you are travelling a lot and don't have unlimited data plan in your cellphone, Kindle can be very useful to check your webmail, maps/direction, travel/restaurant recommendation, etc.

How's the screen (e-ink) compare to color LCD or Paper book?
Well, nothing is like paper book for sure, but it's close enough for me to recommend people to at least give it a try. And compared to the color LCD, again to view photos and multimedia color LCD wins but for basic function (reading book, browsing some basic pages, and checking web email, and reading/staring at the screen for a long time, I will give the black and white kindle/e-ink the edge). Refresh rate isn't as fast as LCD and sometime the previous page black ink doesn't turn to white right away and for a split second old and new pages are transposed together before only the new pages/web pages are fully displayed, but this could be just the feature/limitation of e-ink. It bothers me a bit in the beginning but I'm used to it now.

Why do I choose Kindle 3G vs Nook?
While I like Nook's extra color screen, read book for free with your nook when you use your nook at barnes store, lend your book to your friends, replace your battery yourself, the Kindle is thinner, lighter, faster, have keyboard, free 3G web downloading and browsing (nook 3G only allow book download). Also Kindle navigating system (with the arrow button) is much more superior than Nook especially on navigating the web.

Why do I choose the white over the grey Kindle?
I decided the white keyboard button might be easier to read. A few people said the grey color keyboard is harder to read. Plus the white Kindle looks cool (like a macbook or the original Apple ipod). Some said the grey color is distracting, while some other said the white makes the screen background not as white. In the end, I think it's just going to be about personal preference.

Why do I say the web exprience is great?
The browser is basic (and Amazon marked is as experimental) but the newest version of the browser that come with Kindle 3G can load complex pages that contain javascripts. The web has article mode where it collapses complex pages into one single column and make it easier to read/navigate. Navigating isn't the best experience

How do I check my webmail (yahoo and gmail) with Kindle 3G through the 3G network?
You can check the standard website but I recommend using the mobile version as it is faster, more readable (as it is formatted for mobile devices with smaller screen) and more stable (less Java/Javascript on the mobile version), but if the standard pages works fine fo you. Here's my step-by-step tips to check your email on Kindle over the free 3G newtork .

For Yahoo email:
1. go to the yahoo mobile email website (m dot yahoo dot com slash mail), or mobile main yahoo website (m dot yahoo dot com) to read news instead of checking email
2. enter user name and password, and go to your inbox.
3. bookmark the page (and next time you can just use the bookmark to go your inbox right away). Depending on what option you choose, you might not have to type in your username and password and just visit bookmarked page and/or click reload to bring your newest.

For Google email (For some reason I can't type my user name and password on the gmail mobile site so I use the following method and it works):
1. go to the standard gmail website (gmail dot com)
2. enter username and password
3. then go to the gmail mobile after you successfully login to the standard gmail page, then type/go to the mobile gmail site (m dot gmail dot come) and go to your inbox.
4. remember to bookmark the page after you go to your inbox (if you need to relogin, repeat from step #1 otherwise just go to the gmail mobile inbox right away through the bookmark)

For msn/hotmail, I haven't tried it but I imagine it's going to be similar, using the hotmail mobile or msn mobile website. Let me know if it doesn't work.

How do I navigate within a page (choose buttons/links to click) since Kindle has no "mouse"?
I wish Kindle has a touch pad or a track ball but for now, the directional arrow button for navigation is acceptable/good enough. It will allow us to choose links or button to click. The side button help to scroll up and down the page when browsing the web. Having said all that in my opinion the directional button is probably the most critical element of the device (and the screen itself probably comes second). One might argue to use keyboard shortcuts but it's not the same (kind of like using desktop/laptop with only keyboard)

What are some of the other uses of Kindle 3G?
You can do facebook, twitter, and many other social networking activities. You can read newspaper/magazine/periodicals and have it delivered electronically. You can also play games. 2 of the games already offerd for free and they are quite fun ("Every Row" and "Shuffled Row" which are word scramble game like scrabble)

Hope you enjoy your kindle as much as I do (when you decided to join the bandwagon and get one).

Happy Kindling!

Sidarta Tanu

What did you think of this review?

Fun to Read
Post a Comment
April 02, 2012
Great to know!
February 02, 2012
Excellent review. Have been looking to get one of these devices myself. Is this device the one selling for $79?
February 09, 2011
Excellent review! I own a Nook myself, but you present some valid arguments as to why a Kindle might be the choice readers should make when it comes to an e-reader. Thanks for all the insights!
October 03, 2010
Thanks for the great review -- I've been looking for info on how the Kindle performs as a browser, and this gave me a lot of very helpful info.
October 06, 2010
Thank you comdet! I hope you like your kindle 3 as much as I enjoyed mine. :)
October 02, 2010
Whoa, what a great, in-depth review! I don't yet have a Kindle, but I'm digging the Kindle app for iPhone so much that I just might. Thanks for sharing, Sidarta!
October 03, 2010
Thank you Devora! :)
More Kindle 3G Wireless Reading Dev... reviews
review by . January 31, 2011
Last year, I bought a Kindle DX from the Amazon site and returned it within 24-hours. I was underwhelmed, because:    1. It was heavy  2. The refresh rate was slow  3. I couldn't access New Releases by genre (NOT the same thing as New and Notable)  4. I couldn't get lost in the reading experience    Well, I was in a Staples over the weekend and they had the new generation Kindles on display (immediately, I LOVED the graphite color …
review by . November 29, 2010
Years ago it would have been rare to find me without a book. I was reading an average of 1-2 books per week and had stacks of books around my home. Unfortunately over several years with two growing kids, a full time job and running a household; I found that I had lost the enjoyment and escape that books had given me.     I have been aware of the Kindle since the original one was released. I thought it was interesting, but since I wasn't reading as much it didn't seem worth my …
review by . October 15, 2010
Pros: size, weight, capabilities, ease of use and understanding     Cons: I'm a visual book buyer     The Bottom Line:   "And my heart cannot be    Kindled without you   With your heart kindle my hear"  ~Abigail     I'll be the first to admit that most items technology geared turn my "deer in the headlights" switch on faster than ice melts on the Equator.  However, when I won my Kindle 3G Wireless …
About this product


Amazon announced a new generation of the Kindle on July 28, 2010.   While Amazon does not officially add numbers to the end of each Kindle denoting its generation, most reviewers, customers and press companies refer to this updated Kindle as the "Kindle 3".

The Kindle 3 is available in two versions. One of these, the Kindle Wi-Fi, is initially priced at US$139 / GB£109, and connects to the Internet exclusively via public or private Wi-Fi networks. The other version, considered a replacement to the Kindle 2, is priced at US$189 / GB£149 and includes both 3G and Wi-Fi connectivity. The new Kindle with 3G is available in two colors: classic white and graphite. Both models use the new E-ink "Pearl" display, which Amazon claims is 50% better in contrast - a claim that is backed up by early user reports.

Among other hardware changes Kindle 3 has a larger 1750 mAh lithium polymer battery, AnyDATA DTP-600W 3G GSM modem and Atheros AR6102G 802.11bg WiFi chip.

The third generation Kindle is 0.5 inches shorter and 0.5 inches narrower than the Kindle 2. It supports additional fonts and international Unicode characters. An experimental browser based on the popular WebKit platform is included, as well as text-to-speech menu navigation. Internal memory is expanded to 4 GB. The battery can allegedly last for up to one month of reading with the wireless radios turned off.

Pre-orders for the new Kindle began concurrent with the announcement of the...
view wiki


© 2015 Lunch.com, LLC All Rights Reserved
Lunch.com - Relevant reviews by real people.
This is you!
Ranked #
Last login
Member since