|
Movies Books Music Food Tv Shows Technology Politics Video Games Parenting Fashion Green Living more >

Lunch » Tags » Untagged » The Year of the Gadfly » User review

Complex, claustrophobic, overwritten ... but right for the extremist?

  • Jul 22, 2012
  • by
Rating:
+1
Perhaps appropriately for all the layers and subtexts present in this story, I can see two ways to review "The Year of the Gadfly."

On the one hand, this book was overwritten and convoluted. The entire "extremophile" conceit felt like a heavy-handed way to remind us that the kids at Mariana Academy are in a pressure-cooker environment ("pressure-cooker is a cliché," Edward R. Murrow reminds me). The idea of our 14-year-old protagonist being a reporter-to-be devoted to the survival of print journalism seems unlikely in 2012 -- roughly akin to someone the same age being engrossed in typewriter repair or the music of Vaughn Monroe. I also wondered how she settled on Murrow as her inspiration, particularly given that he spent his career as a broadcast journalist. Harrison Salisbury, say, might have made more sense, but he's less romantic. Still, better Murrow than a fraud like Walter Duranty.

Most of all, "Gadfly" reads like the work of a writer who believes the way to make sure her "literary gifts are on virtuoso display," in the words of the back-cover blurber, is by using every outlandish metaphor or overclocked simile she can. My favorite of these may well be the following (and keep in mind this does not come from a 20-something PhD science teacher, one of our central characters, but from a third-person section that is, presumably, the author's own voice): "Throughout junior high she floated on the periphery of the popular clique, and they tolerated her presence like a harmless parasite -- a tooth amoeba that nibbled on whatever the toothbrush missed, or maybe a dust mite that made you sneeze constantly but didn't cause any real damage. When she approached the popular girls at recess, their circle would automatically constrict like a cell warding off a virus," and so on (p. 62). When we're treated to a few lines of the young journalist's own work toward the end of the book, they're as purple as the previous 350 pages, and in exactly the same voice ("the fluorescent lights within have not simply chased the shadows into their corners, but illuminated the corners themselves" [p. 351] -- as lights will do). Read through this lens, I found "Year of the Gadfly" hard to get through. It really could have been 100 or even 150 pages shorter with a little more effort.

On the other hand, "Year of the Gadfly" is a story of experiments within experiments, and of organisms adapting -- or failing to adapt -- to life in extreme conditions. In an otherwise somewhat overlong reenactment of the Milgram experiment on his students, the science teacher mentioned above explains that both the button-presser AND the "victim" simulating pain are subjects of the experiment. Perhaps author Jennifer Miller has not only created an extreme environment in which to observe her characters, but also told the story in an extreme way to measure the adaptability of her audience? I believe another reviewer said something to the effect that this novel is "too offbeat" for the average reader, and I agree that "Gadfly" probably won't take a place on the shelf of traditional coming-of-age ("cliché") books. But for "extremists" of the sort characters in this book believe themselves to be, it may be a welcoming environment indeed.

What did you think of this review?

Helpful
0
Thought-Provoking
0
Fun to Read
0
Well-Organized
0
Post a Comment
About the reviewer
Andrew S. Rogers ()
Ranked #364
Mostly, I'm a moderately prolific Amazon.com reviewer who's giving Lunch a try as another venue for my reviews.
About this product

Wiki

"Part Dead Poet's Society. Part Heathers. Entirely addictive."
-Glamour

Harrowing, enchanting, and utterly original.”
-Daily Beast

"A darkly comic romp...vivid and very enjoyable."
-Washington Post

"Engages and provokes."
The Boston Globe

"There is a relentless authenticity in her prose...Miller effectively places here characters in a vice and squeezes the truth out of them."
—The Atlantic.com

"A smoldering mystery set in a New England prep school... The author skillfully ratchets up the tension as Iris (and the reader) finds it harder and harder to tell who the good guys are... A gripping thrill ride that’s also a thoughtful coming-of-age story."
-Kirkus Reviews

"In thisengrossingnovel, a would-be journalist unearths scandalous secrets at her prep school with the help of a famous reporter’s ghost."
-O Magazine

"A coming of age page-turner."
Library Journal

"Hysterical and moving,The Year of the GadflyfusesSpecial Topics in Calamity PhysicswithPortnoy's Complaintfor girls. This book is an imaginative delight."
—Gary Shteyngart, author ofSuper Sad True Love Story

"A dark, whirling, and compelling read.The Year of the Gadflyis a hilarious and heartbreaking story about friendship, acceptance, and trust — the way our search for them shapes our youth and how that search can haunt us forever."
—Jennifer Close, author ofGirls in White Dresses

"This novel has so much going for it: the feisty, heartbroken heroine, the ghost of Edward R. ...

view wiki

Tags

Details

© 2014 Lunch.com, LLC All Rights Reserved
Lunch.com - Relevant reviews by real people.
()
This is you!
Ranked #
Last login
Member since
reviews
comments
ratings
questions
compliments
lists