Movies Books Music Food Tv Shows Technology Politics Video Games Parenting Fashion Green Living more >

Lunch » Tags » Music » Reviews » Tommy James 40th Anniversary Singles Collection » User review

The most comprehensive Tommy James collection ever!

  • Aug 24, 2010

When Tommy James was just 13 years old, he and a group of junior high school buddies formed a rock `n roll band in their hometown of Niles, Michigan.  They called themselves The Shondells.  The group caught the eye of a local record producer and The Shondells were given a chance to cut a record.  The Shondells released a tune called "Judy" in 1962.  Although that record went nowhere, a local DJ that was starting a new label late in 1963 decided to give The Shondells another shot.  They recorded a tune called "Hanky Panky" on the fledgling Snap label and this time they had themselves a local hit.  However, the record never received any airplay outside the local area.  Fast forward now to 1966 when Tommy James received a bizarre phone call from a promoter in Pittsburgh with an urgent request that he come to town to do a live concert.  Since Tommy had never even been to Pittsburgh he had no idea what was going on.  As it turned out, this promoter had found a copy of "Hanky Panky" in a used record bin.  He liked it so much that he began playing it at dances all around town.  Suddenly, radio stations in Pittsburgh were getting requests for this tune.  Tommy James packed his bags and headed for the Steel City.  The original Shondells had broken up so if was going to do concerts he would need a band to back him up.  He hired a local Pittsburgh outfit called The Reconteurs to fill the bill and Tommy James and the Shondells were born.  Soon thereafter the group signed with Morris Levy's Roulette records and re-recorded "Hanky Panky".  This new recording was a bit more uptempo than the original and was an immediate smash.  "Hanky Panky" would climb all the way to the top of the Billboard Hot 100 Singles chart and would remain there for two weeks.  Tommy James and the Shondells were on their way.  After all these many years Collector's Choice presents "Tommy James and the Shondells: 40th Anniversary Singles Collection".  This impressive 2 disc set offers up four dozen tunes by Tommy James both with The Shondells and as a solo performer.  For all but the most rabid fans, it is probably more Tommy James than you would ever want or need.

Collectors Choice has taken special care in trying to differentiate "40th Anniversary Singles Collection" from some of the other anthologies that have been released previously.  You will find the original 1963 Snap recording of "Hanky Panky" included here.  Between 1966 and 1970 Tommy James and the Shondells placed a total of 19 singles on Billboard's Hot 100.  Virtually all of them are included here including "I Think We're Alone Now", the #1 smash "Crimson and Clover" from 1969, "Crystal Blue Persuasion" and the highly annoying "Mony, Mony"God I hate that song!!  The first 15 tracks are presented in their original "mono" format that had never appeared on compact disc before.  You will probably notice some slight differences on a few of the tunes.  In 1970, Tommy jettisoned the band and began pursuing a solo career.  Unfortunately, the songs sounded an awful lot like the ones he did with the Shondells.  He did manage to snag one more big hit with 1971's "Draggin' The Line".  But the public began to lose interest and although Tommy continued to churn out single after single they all seemed to stall in the middle to lower reaches of the Hot 100.  Tommy James disappeared from the scene for several years before signing a new deal with Millennium records in 1980.  His comeback single "Three Times In Love" was a pretty decent pop tune that managed to crack the Top 20.  A follow-up called "You're So Easy To Love" would be somewhat less successful.  Both of these tunes are included here as well.

As always, the good folks at Collector's Choice have done an outstanding job in putting together "Tommy James and the Shondells: 40th Anniversary Singles Collection".  Ed Osborne's liner notes provide tons of information on the artist and the photos from Tommy James' personal collection are highly enjoyable to peruse.  While Tommy James certainly had his share of hits I am not really sure that this artist merits such an elaborate anthology.  I am perfectly happy with Rhino's 2 LP "Anthology" that I purchased many years ago.  But for many long-time fans and serious collectors I am quite sure that "40th Anniversary Collection" will fill the bill nicely.  Recommended.

The most comprehensive Tommy James collection ever!

What did you think of this review?

Fun to Read
Post a Comment
August 24, 2010
I recently purchased a cd two-fer including Cellophane Symphony and Crimson & Clover. Although both are extremely dated and sound far less complex than my eight y/o ears remember from '69, the sound of James and the Shondells remains unmistakable and for my money Sweet Cherry Wine is still wonderful and the one 45 that I can never forgive my mother for throwing out (however, with regards to the '72 Horace Clarke Topps Action Card that also got trashed, I am prepared to let bygones be bygones.)
About the reviewer
Paul Tognetti ()
Ranked #2
I guess I would qualify as a frustrated writer. My work requires very little writing and so since 1999 I have been writing reviews on non-fiction books and anthology CD's on amazon.com. I never could … more
Consider the Source

Use Trust Points to see how much you can rely on this review.

Your ratings:
rate more to improve this
About this song


It hardly needs to be said that Tommy James, both with and without the Shondells, had some of the definitive AM radio hits of the 1960s, but this 40th anniversary collection reminds listeners just how good and expansive that catalog is. This two-disc retrospective gathers all the A-sides, with the original mono mixes intact--the only James collection that contains the original Shondells sound. The comprehensive and scholarly liner notes by Martin Fitzpatrick (author of James's bio) complement the package.

1 Hanky Panky 2 Say I Am (What I Am) 3 It's Only Love 4 I Think We're Alone Now 5 Mirage 6 I Like the Way 7 Gettin' Together 8 Out of the Blue 9 Get Out Now 10 Mony Mony 11 Somebody Cares 12 Do Something to Me 13 Crimson and Clover 14 Sweet Cherry Wine 15 Crystal Blue Persuasion 16 Ball of Fire 17 She 18 Gotta Get Back to You 19 Come to Me 20 Ball and Chain 21 Church Street Soul Revival 22 Adrienne 23 Draggin' the Line 24 I'm Comin' Home 25 Nothing to Hide 26 Tell 'Em Willie Boy's A-Comin' 27 Cat's Eye in the Window 28 Love Song 29 Celebration 30 Boo, Boo, Don't Cha Be Blue 31 Calico 32 Glory Glory 33 I Love You Love Me Love 34 Tighter, Tighter 35 Love Is Gonna Find a Way 36 Three Times in Love 37 You Got Me 38 You're So Easy to Love 39 Say Please 40 Go 41 You Take My Breath Away 42 Who Do You Love 43 I Love Christmas 44 Sweet Cherry Wine 45 Isn't That The Guy 46 Love Words 47 Hold the Fire 48 Long Pony Tail
view wiki


Performer: Tommy James
Release Date: November, 2008
Label: Collector's Choice
Label: Collector's Choice
Genre: Anthology
Release Date: Novermber, 2008
© 2015 Lunch.com, LLC All Rights Reserved
Lunch.com - Relevant reviews by real people.
This is you!
Ranked #
Last login
Member since