Movies Books Music Food Tv Shows Technology Politics Video Games Parenting Fashion Green Living more >

Lunch » Tags » Tv Shows » Reviews » Mad Men » User review

Good but I get the formula...

  • Sep 21, 2009
  • by
Mad Men is well casted, well acted, well written and well directed - it's pretty much everything that regular TV is not. And while the first season was really addictive, I've spotted the formula which has meant we've more or less lost interest in the show. This was mainly due to the fact that we had a weekend marathon of watching all the episodes (thanks, Amazon Video-on-Demand!).

Mad Men catches viewers' interest by injecting story lines that never get resolved: the lead character is doing a Martin Guerre by capturing a dead soldier's identity, one of the ad executives is flirting with his homosexuality, the New York company gets bought out by the Brits. Essentially, every time there's a new to pump life into the office drama, some new and relatively implausible thread gets thrown into the mix, and it can take an entire season - or two - to play out.

From a writing point of view, I like the approach, since it practically guarantees no end in sight for an episodic TV show. But as a viewer, I feel manipulated and would really like the show of the first season to come back. Plus, AMC and Showtime seem to have an unspoken rule to have at least one pushing-the-boundaries-of-TV-but-lame-for-the-Internet sex scene in every show (the red-head secretary gets practically raped by her fiance, and the gay executive experiences, ahem, you know what) and in the same way that Californication lost its clever edge in exchange for lewdness, Mad Men is trending down the same path.

Still, I was an addict for 24 even though I spotted the formula there too ("I going dark!"/"Put it on my screen!"/'There's a mole in CTU!"/"They've kidnapped your daughter... again!"), before it became completely insane. I fear that Mad Men will drift into the 24 territory of utter nonsense, but hopefully it won't come before another series or two.

PS - The whole thing must be sponsored by Marlboro given the number of cigarettes per scene!

What did you think of this review?

Fun to Read
Post a Comment
September 22, 2010
I would say that so far with Season 4, there's no danger of what you describe. Don being divorced has opened up a whole new world to explore with him.
November 21, 2009
Did you continue to watch the show into the 3rd season? If so, did you like the finale?

Fun fact: since real cigarettes are prohibited on tv shows, I read that they use all-herbal 'butts in the show! Crazy- I never knew! That's a whole lot of little teas/flowers/weeds they must be burning up on the Mad Men set! :)
November 21, 2009
Mad Men is a weekly staple in my household, so I continued to watch - I think the last two episodes of the season were really good actually. It's like they switched the writers or something. It looks like they're writing Betty Draper out which would be a plus: her storylines aren't really going anywhere, and I think the characters in the ad agency have infinitely more scope. Still, we'll see in series 4! I had no idea about the cigarettes... how ridiculous you can't show smoking in TV but you can show drinking, drug abuse, fighting and shooting! Still I bet those menthol cigs are helping the actors deliver the lines :-)
More Mad Men reviews
review by . August 19, 2009
Mad Men
  I’ve heard non-stop praise and acclaim about Mad Men over the last two years. Having only seen promotional clips, I was skeptical about the hype. To me, it looked like a peek into a time when men acted as self-interested, arrogant and cut-throat possible; while women played subservient roles in traditional family households and dealt with unimaginable amounts of sexist behavior. Who needs to see more of that? But similar to my fortunate rendezvous with Showtime’s Dexter OnDemand, …
Quick Tip by . January 08, 2012
posted in Pass The Remote!
I've watched several episodes of Mad Men, and I totally understand why its so appealing. It's well-written and very stark and blunt in its portrayal of social attitudes and norms from the 1950's and 60's. And Alison Brie is in it. But I just can't really get into it myself. Maybe I was in the wrong mood or something, but it just hasn't grown on me the way it has other people.
Quick Tip by . October 09, 2010
If you were alive in the early 60s, even if you were very young, this show will bring bacjk things you thought you had forgotten.
Quick Tip by . July 10, 2010
Donald Draper is the most lovable misogynist I've ever known, and I simply cannot get enough of Joan Holloway, (she was quite a fox as Saffron in Firefly, as well, but the clothing of this period really does suit her well).
Quick Tip by . May 18, 2010
An exquisitely made series. Intelligent, sharp, witty and totally engrossing. Well worth your time.
Quick Tip by . August 20, 2009
Super awesome costumes, makeup and savoir faire (sp?). Very satisfying slow burner. MORE MORE MORE!!!
About the reviewer
James Beswick ()
Ranked #13
Lunch.com's "token Brit".
Consider the Source

Use Trust Points to see how much you can rely on this review.

Your ratings:
rate more to improve this
About this tv show


Mad Men is an American television drama series created and produced by Matthew Weiner. It is produced by Lionsgate Television and is broadcast on the cable network AMC. It premiered on July 19, 2007, and completed its second season on October 26, 2008. The third season is scheduled to begin August 2009.

Set in New York City, Mad Men begins in the early 1960s at the fictional Sterling Cooper advertising agency on New York City's Madison Avenue. The show centers on Don Draper (Jon Hamm), a high-level advertising creative director, and the people in his life in and out of the office. It also depicts the changing social mores of 1960s America.

Mad Men has received widespread critical acclaim, particularly for its historical authenticity and visual style, and has won numerous awards, including three Golden Globes, a BAFTA and six Emmys. It is the second cable series to win the Emmy Award for Outstanding Drama Series and the first basic cable series to do so.

Lead characters

  • Don Draper (born in 1925 as Richard "Dick" Whitman) (Jon Hamm): Creative director and eventual junior partner of Sterling Cooper Advertising Agency; Draper is the series' protagonist.
  • Peggy Olson (Elisabeth Moss): She began as the ostensibly naïve "new girl" at Sterling Cooper. Starting as Draper's unassuming new secretary, Peggy showed a talent in advertising strikingly similar to Draper's own.
  • Peter "Pete" Campbell (Vincent Kartheiser): A young, ...
view wiki


Polls with this tv show

Top TV Shows


The best shows on T.V.


First to Review

"Mad about it"
© 2015 Lunch.com, LLC All Rights Reserved
Lunch.com - Relevant reviews by real people.
This is you!
Ranked #
Last login
Member since