|
Movies Books Music Food Tv Shows Technology Politics Video Games Parenting Fashion Green Living more >

Lunch » Tags » Television Shows » Reviews » Noein » User review

Noein

An anime series

< read all 2 reviews

To your other self...

  • Dec 19, 2009
  • by
Rating:
+2

Pros: Fascinating premise, character development of the main characters, character designs, musical score, interesting fictional technology.

Cons: Awkward pronunciations in dub, premise is never fully explored, weak conclusion, animation, under-developed characters, genre-mixing.

Plot Summary: The Wiki article (see above) summarizes the series very well, so I will not be redundant and restate it.

Review: Firstly, one of the more positive aspects of Noein is that of its soundtrack. The opening and closing themes are both J-Pop songs by female vocalists, but both are catchy, and I often found myself humming them throughout the day. The background music is also fitting and enjoyable, though not as memorable as the opening and closing themes.

I usually prefer English dubs, but in Noein's case, the English dub is a mixed bag. On the one hand, all of the characters' voices seem to match their characters, but on the other hand, every single voice actor, aside from Crispin Freeman (Karasu) and Melissa Fahn (Haruka), cannot seem to pronounce Haruka's name correctly. They call her Ha-ROO-ka, which, although only it's a minor flaw, becomes incredibly irritating after the first two episodes, especially because everyone always seems to be screaming her name. It was extremely hard to ignore.

Noein's animation also has its ups and downs. The character designs are unique, but the CG used to animated Haruka's house and a few other locations blends in so badly with the rest of the animation that it looks cheap and mediocre. There are also times when the characters look like they were drawn sloppily in pencil, which is evident especially in the fight-scenes. There were even a few fight scenes where no color was used. It looked sloppy and lazily-done.

Noein's biggest problem, however, is its utilization of multiple genres in order to tell a story. When I first read about Noein, I was fascinated at the idea of an anime exploring Hugh Everett's Many-Worlds Interpretation, the Copenhagen Interpretation, existentialism, and the paradox of Schrodinger's cat. (It would take too long to explain these concepts here, but there are several online resources available.) However, the majority of the series focuses on Haruka, Yû, and their three friends as they go ghost-hunting in a cemetary, experiment with a ouija board, handle their parents and school, and deal with mixed feelings and crushes. While the slice-of-life aspect is entertaining to watch, as the characters are extremely likeable, I could not get over the fact that none of it had to do with the plot. Even with the appearance of Karasu, the kids go on with their whimsical, pre-teen lives, only becoming concerned when an enemy surfaces. Perhaps this was to cause the viewers to care for the characters, or to make them seem more innocent so that the events of the series would be more affecting, but I personally feel that the plot could have been explored in more depth without compromising character development. It was almost like a physics-based anime for children, in that it never becomes too deep.

Overall, Noein was a let down in the sense that it opened with an interesting premise that was never really explored. There are under-used characters that exist solely for the purpose of revealing information about physics to the viewer(s), and the series' conclusion is disappointing in that the problems caused by the antagonist are resolved after a brief "revelation". After it was all over, I felt that it took far to long just to get to the point where the series ended. Noein was an entertaining series to watch, mainly because the characters were so likeable, but it could have been so much better.

I would recommend Noein only if you are interested in watching a character-driven series. If you are interested in learning more about physics, read a book on the subject instead.

To your other self... To your other self...

What did you think of this review?

Helpful
20
Thought-Provoking
19
Fun to Read
20
Well-Organized
21
Post a Comment
December 22, 2009
Currently in the middle of this series as we speak (actually starting the fifth and final disc). My thoughts on this one haven't been sorted yet (sometimes I have to reflect on these things for a few days before I can review).. But very nice write up. I can't help but feel like my review score will be similar.
December 22, 2009
Thank you very much. I'll look forward to your write-up, if you decide to write one.
December 22, 2009
For sure.. I think my expectations may have been a bit high going in. I think your review is a MUCH more realistic/ grounded view of the property.
December 22, 2009
Why thank you. I can't say that I was incredibly disappointed, but I wish I had't read so many reviews beforehand. It made me go in expecting something really excellent.
 
December 20, 2009
superb review! I actually saw this a couple of years back and I agree that the animation was a little uneven. I did like its premise though, but I can't say I can argue that it could have been executed a little better. I did like its character-driven approach/study. Glad to see another anime fan breaking into the Lunch community.
 
1
More Noein reviews
review by . December 28, 2009
posted in ASIANatomy
So Much Potential Wasted Here
Well I better clear the air right from the get-go; this review isn’t going to be very positive.  And don’t for a minute think that it’s due to the property’s lack of potential.  In fact on paper, this series comes off like a science fiction fan’s dream come true: Quantum physics, multidimensional travel, and converging timelines… There’s just so much to get excited about.  Unfortunately, it becomes apparent fairly early on that the purity …
About the reviewer
GCS ()
Ranked #86
My user-name was derived from the title of a poem by Edgar Allan Poe. I came to Lunch with the hopes of publishing reviews that would be appreciated by others and reading the reviews of others that hope … more
Consider the Source

Use Trust Points to see how much you can rely on this review.

You
Ulalume
Your ratings:
rate more to improve this
About this tv show

Wiki

Fifteen years in one of the possible futures, a violent battle using fictional technology takes place between two "time-spaces": La'cryma, a possible future of our own universe, and Shangri'la, another possible dimension fifteen years after ours, intent on the destruction of all space and time. The key to stopping Shangri'la's invasion is a mysterious object known as the "Dragon Torque". A group known as the "Dragon Knights" is sent through space and time to find it. In the present, twelve-year old Haruka and her friend Yū are contemplating running away from home when they meet a member of the Dragon Knights named Karasu, who is a possibly Yū from fifteen years in the future. Karasu believes that Haruka is the Dragon Torque, but vows to protect her rather than sacrifice her for his timespace, La'cryma. Other than the Dragon Knights, Haruka is targeted by the mysterious Noein, the entity behind Shangri'la who is intent on bringing her into his timespace to end all universes.
view wiki

Details

Genre: Science Fiction, Drama/Comedy

First to Review
© 2014 Lunch.com, LLC All Rights Reserved
Lunch.com - Relevant reviews by real people.
()
This is you!
Ranked #
Last login
Member since
reviews
comments
ratings
questions
compliments
lists