Movies Books Music Food Tv Shows Technology Politics Video Games Parenting Fashion Green Living more >

Lunch » Tags » Tv Shows » Reviews » Stargate Atlantis » User review


Stargate Atlantis is part of the Stargate franchise owned by MGM.

< read all 1 reviews

Gone Before Its Time, My Heart's Still in the Lost City of "Atlantis"

  • Jul 28, 2009
  • by
 After five seasons and one hundred episodes, Stargate Atlantis was canceled prematurely by the Syfy Channel.  The cancellation was said to have been a join decision between both the network and SG-1 and Atlantis co-creators and producers Brad Wright and Robert C. Cooper in order to make room for their new series Stargate Universe.  On top of SGU, Wright and Cooper also wanted to go ahead with another SG-1 film as well as an Atlantis film to wrap up the series.  While I believe all of this is true, it was a bad move for both the network and the producers.  In the process of canceling Atlantis, Syfy lost what would have become their flagship program once Battlestar Galactica went off the air and also managed to upset what has to be the most loyal fan-base in all of Science Fiction.  SGU, despite my obvious excitement for a new show, could have waited, it wasn't going anywhere, but instead, they made the move and put to death a great show that had at least two more great seasons left in it.

Was I surprised when the announcement came that Atlantis was being Canceled?  Not in the least, simply because I was expecting it.  It was a subject that had been talked about for months, and knowing the way in which the Syfy channel thought, I had already braced myself for the worst.  Instead of being upset, I was left feeling disappointed knowing that I was right and that one of my favorite TV shows was  coming to an end.  Unfortunately, the cancellation cannot all be blamed on producers and the network.  Atlantis had one major flaw and that was casting.  In the first season a lead was replaced due to not enough character depth.  In season three, Torri Higginson, who played Dr. Elizabeth Weir, was asked to leave the show due to the same reasons along with the character of Dr. Carson Beckett being killed off (only to be brought back as a clone due to mass fan outrage), replaced by Jewel Staite as Dr. Jennifer Keller.  Weir's character was replaced by Samantha Carter played by Amanda Tapping, one of the original members of SG-1, for season four.  Unfortunately after only one season, Tapping left Atlantis to go work on her new show that she both produces and stars in, Sanctuary.  She was then replaced by long time guest star on both SG-1 and Atlantis, Robert Picardo as Richard Woolsey.  So, in three seasons of the show, there were four major cast changes which unfortunately is never good news for a program.  What didn't change though, was despite all of these casting issues, the show always kept getting better.

The Season 4 Cast

In some ways, Atlantis was a much better show than SG-1 was.  While SG-1 took place in the Milky Way and on Earth, Atlantis took place in a whole other galaxy, adding some mystique that at times, SG-1 lacked.  For the first couple of seasons, there was this sense of desperation as well as fear and loss since the expedition wasn't able to get back home.  This made for some really good first and second season episode writing.  The show always got better though, even when they were eventually able to return back to Earth.  The show dealt with issues of whether it was safe to go back because of the Wraith threat or spies from the Milky Way coming to Atlantis.  Sure, there were a few really bad episodes along the way, but that comes with any television show.  Even with the final fifth season, which seemed more like a stand alone season than episodic, left me truly hooked and entertained. 

A shot from Season 5 of Atlantis

What made Atlantis superior to other shows on at the time was the character depth within the cast.  Even with all the changes that took place, these were characters that you couldn't help but care about.  There were so many great relationships in the show.  The constant bickering yet brotherly relationship between Rodney and Sheppard...Rodney and everyone for that matter, the Han/Chewie type relationship Sheppard had with Ronon.  These are just two examples.  What matters most though was that whenever something happened to these characters, you got angry or you got scared which is so important in acting and for a show to be successful.  Take the season five episode, "The Shrine".  Rodney is dying in this episode because he is slowly losing all of his brain function, making him appear to be "mentally retarded" despite the fact that he is a genius.  This was probably one of the hardest episodes of the show to watch because David Hewlett, who plays McKay, came through with such an amazingly convincing acting performance.  Along with that, you had the rest of the team basically saying their final goodbyes to him and they all are so believable.  It was truly touching.  It was episodes and acting like this that made Atlantis my favorite TV show.

From "The Shrine"

While I was sad to see Atlantis go, I can rest easy knowing there is more to come.  The script for the forthcoming Atlantis film is almost completed and I can't wait.  If you have never watched the show, but you're a big fan of SG-1, pick up these five great seasons of Stargate Atlantis, it won't let you down.  From multiple guest appearances from the SG-1 characters you love, to getting to know a brand new team that you'll love just as much, the stories from Pegasus will leave you at the edge of your seat wanting more.  I only wish I could tell that there was going to be more.  All I can do is hope that Stargate Universe lives up to its namesake.  One thing is for sure, my heart is still in Atlantis.  Leave the gate open, I'm coming through.
Atlantis Rising Atlantis Gate Season 5 Cast two ships

What did you think of this review?

Fun to Read
Post a Comment
July 29, 2009
damn you, you made me miss Atlantis even more than I already do!
About the reviewer
Julian Brown ()
Ranked #33
Hi, my name is Julian Brown. I currently write for The Brotherly Game, a local Philadelphia soccer website where I cover the US Women's National Team and the local WPS Philadelphia Independence. I … more
Consider the Source

Use Trust Points to see how much you can rely on this review.

Your ratings:
rate more to improve this
About this tv show


Stargate Atlantis
(often abbreviated as SGA) is an American-Canadian science fiction television program, part of the Stargate franchise owned by MGM. Developed by longtime SG-1 producers Brad Wright and Robert C. Cooper, it is a spin-off from the television series Stargate SG-1. It is filmed and produced in Canada.

Stargate Atlantis follows the adventures of a human expedition to the lost city of Atlantis in the Pegasus Galaxy. The Stargate has brought humanity into contact with other cultures, including new and powerful enemies: the Wraith, the Genii, and later the Asurans, all while trying to uncover the secrets the Ancients left behind.

Stargate Atlantis premiered on the US Syfy Channel on July 16, 2004 with "Rising", a movie-style two-part episode, that guest starred Richard Dean Anderson and Michael Shanks from Stargate SG-1. The series is broadcast in HD in selected countries.

SGA follows the flag ship team on Atlantis.  The team consists of Major/Lt. Col. John Sheppard (Joe Flanigan), Teyla Emmagan (Rachel Luttrell), an Athosian, Lt. Aidan Ford (Rainbow Sun Francks), Dr. Carson Beckett (Paul McGillion), Dr. Elizabeth Weir (Torri Higginson) and Dr. Rodney McKay (David Hewlett).  In the second season, Francks left the show and his replacement on the team Ronon Dex, a Satedan, played by Jason Momoa.  In Season 3, Paul McGillion's character, Beckett was killed off and replaced by Dr. Jennifer Keller (Firefly's Jewel Staite).  Fans were ...
view wiki
Polls with this tv show

The best shows on T.V.


© 2015 Lunch.com, LLC All Rights Reserved
Lunch.com - Relevant reviews by real people.
This is you!
Ranked #
Last login
Member since